The Maccabaean
formidable list of errata, to bring his story up-to-date and to assemble its disjecta membra in a somewhat more orderly fashion. Such editions are usually put upon the market a twelvemonth or so after publication of the more costly original imprint. Sometime in 1920, therefore, we hope Mr. Sokolow's work in a popular and revised edition, will reach the English-reading Jewish masses for whose benefit the author has been toiling in this and many other undertakings.
“Under Western Eyes””
The Eclipse of Russia. Dr. DILLON'S Account of the Reign of Nicholas II. Doran & Company. New York, 1918. 423 pp.
To thinking Zionists of all countries, the Russian revolution is and must remain for all times to come a topic of inexhaustible interest, both in its bearings upon the major part of the Jewish world-community and upon the progress of humanity. No book or document shedding important light upon its pre-history can therefore fail to come home to Jewish businesses and bosoms. There is fortunately no lack of such documents. The motto of every great revolution of modern times is "Camille Desmoulins' revelabo pudenda tua. The overthrow of a dynasty invariably brings to light the secret facts and makeshifts that propped its reign, the wrong-doings of sovereigns that can do no wrong, the bickerings, intrigues and treasons of ministers and generals, and the land-grabbing policies of the ancient régimé hidden under ghastly assurances of international friendship and esteem. The post-mortem trial of the fallen government lasts for years. New witnesses are coming forward with their depositions as time goes on. The most important crown-witnesses of an accusing revolution against the government it overthrew are by no means revolutionaries themselves. Dr. E. J. Dillon, author of "The Eclipse of Russia" makes his highly illuminating depositions concerning the reign of Nicholas II, not as a Russian revolutionist indeed, but as bosom-friend and confidential adviser of the late Sergei Julievich Witte, as a companion, on a familiar footing, of Russian ministers, senators, envoys, as a man of ready access to the court of St. Petersburg and to its favorites—in short, as a familiar of the old system turned "muckraker" post-festum. A few words about the man and his strange career will help our readers to a just idea regarding the importance of his testimony:
There is an Irish Galuth as well as a Jewish one, which scatters its talents, More Judaico, to all the four corners of the earth, creating thereby eccentric situations and shaping romantic life-stories. Dr. Dillon, a typical product of Irish Galuth, has dwelt among the Russian people for thirty years and longer, under three reigns, until the outbreak of the war in 1914. He is a graduate of two Russian universities, an erstwhile Professor of Comparative Philology at the University of Kharkoff, a former leader-writer of two Russian newspapers and editor of one. We are confronted with a classical witness of Russian developments during the reign of the last Czar. His latest volume is devoted to a double purpose: to expose, by new revelations, the manifold treasons and stupid machinations of the late Czar, and to extol Dr. Dillon's guide, philosopher and friend, Sergei Julievich Witte, as one of the greatest statesmen that ever lived, a Machiavelli of Russian liberalism who would have averted the Revolution and turned Russia, by pacific means, into a constitutional monarchy had not the deceitful autocrat he served been guilty of many tergiversations and criminal blunders, committed when the back of his great minister was turned. Considered either as a fascicle of new evidence against Nicholas II or as a feat of luminous presentation, Dr. Dillon's latest volume is a success; as an apotheosis of his bosom-friend Witte, it is a complete and deplorable failure, despite the author's many brilliant qualities. His revelations in "The Eclipse of Russia" are, in the nature of affairs, of a sensational character, but the author is by no means a vulgar sensation-monger of our domestic newspaper-type. His vast erudition, his skill in the presentation of political and cultural complexities, his detailed and on the whole trustworthy knowledge of international relations secure him high rank among contemporary publicists and an authority nowhere within reach of our commis voyageurs of yellow journalism. If his unusual qualifications as a historian of modern autocratic Russia did not help him to a correct estimate of Mr. Witte on the one hand
and the revolution on the other, the reason is not far to seek: “The Eclipse of Russia” is simply another proof of the old truth that political insight is primarily a matter of will shaped by environment and only secondarily of schooling. One does not hobnob for thirty years with the liberalizing lackeys of Czardom without absorbing their outlook upon men and things. We doubt not that Mr. Witte, like the Emperor of Lilliput, rose above the heads of the other pygmies of Russian liberalism, the Gutchkoffs, Rodziankos, the liberalizing generals and grand-dukes, etc., by the span of a finger-nail; but only the profound infatuation of an adoring friend could mistake him for a great man.
The main features of Mr. Witte’s career as a minister afford a remarkable parallel to that of Necker. Like Necker, he was the personally irreproachable and puritanical business-agent of a political house of ill-fame—a type disagreeably familiar to American readers. Like Necker, he was a self-made man inordinately vain of his maker, an authority on shifts of finance conceited enough to imagine that he could right the hopeless economic tangle of an absolutist regime. Like Necker, he was profoundly distrusted by his employer, unceremoniously kicked out of office, hired again under stress of dire necessity, and brusquely dismissed again after raising a supply of money for governmental needs. There was this difference, however, in the sovereigns they served: both Nicholas II and Louis XVI were henpecked husbands dominated by strong-willed relative. Both had no scruple whatever to transact public business behind the backs and without the fore-knowledge of their would-be “powerful” ministers. Both ended as traitors to their country; but Louis XVI was, on the whole, a humane and concessive nature, capable of sustaining even in a fairly intelligent minister the delusion of an impending change of heart; whereas, on Dr. Dillon’s own showing and that of numerous other witnesses, the true nature of Lord Asquith’s “late Jamented ally” cannot have been mistaken by any servant of the crown for any considerable length of time. Mr. Witte must have known, almost from the beginning, that in accepting a portfolio, he was enlisting under the falsest, craftiest, meanest of modern tyrants—under ä Phillip the Second on the throne of the Romanoffs. Yet throughout his several terms of oflice, he permitted himself to be used as a dupe and catspaw of autocracy, not by a despot of genius like Peter the Great or the Second Catherine, but by a superstitious driveller, a buyer of German Imperial gold-bricks, an autocrat cowed by uncles, dowagers, “mad monks” and drunken peasant-impostors. Mr. Witte’s first term of office—teste Dr. Dillon—produced abundant and irrefutable evidence of the Czar’s contempt for his “great” minister of finance, his incorrigible duplicity, his scarcely concealed determination to go over the head of his man-of-affairs whenever there was an open or latent contention between minister and crown. All this did not keep Mr. Witte from sticking to office, from returning to office, from exploiting his reputation for personal integrity to cover the dirtiest shifts of a moribund autocracy warring against the Russian masses, from raising in France, through his political sham-prestige, the moneys that financed Gomel and Siedlze, from financing in advance the constitutional October swindles, followed.by the October pogroms of 1905, and finally, after having eaten more crow than any other statesman of his time, from being ultimately scrapped and superseded in ofice by avowed reactionaries.. What made him eat crow and stick to office, was the indestructible, unteachable vanity of the self-made man, the megalomania of the celebrity risen from the ranks and cocksure of his own indispensableness to the scheme of things—the same megalomania that persuaded Necker, again and again, that he could transmogrify feudal France through the parlormagic of shifts in finance and through his own eminently moral example into an enlightened commonwealth governed by sentiment and the principles of Adam Smith. Toward the end of his career— after Portsmouth—his belief in his own greatness began to waver. Page 377 of the Doctor’s “Eclipse” quotes his farewell—conversation after Portsmouth:
“———. I am now going back home, bound by promises to Jews and Christians here to do my best to modify the repressive legislation that keeps the people of Russia farther apart from that of the