The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 10 · December 1919
369printed page
scan 71 of 82

The Maccabaean

polations, appendices, addenda and corrigenda. In accounting for this involved tangle, we venture upon two supplementary guesses based upon inference:

1. From the insertion of much valuable but irrelevant or semi-irrelevant material—such as for instance a monograph dealing with the philosophic writings of Manasseh Ben-Israel, an entire chapter on Napoleon's Sanhedrin, etc.—we gather that the publisher's insistence upon additional copy in some instances prevailed over the author's selective judgment.

2. The author appears before the court of public opinion with such a numerous train of industrious letter-writing witnesses and preface-writing compurgators that we cannot but think him infected a little with our newly-fangled American ways of overstressing the value of "testimonials." To that extent, we of America have probably suggested the injection into Mr. Sokolow's work of an additional element of incoherence and confusion.

Where neither lack of time, nor the urgencies of his publishers, nor the suggestion of American methods are pressing upon the author, his strong Jewish good sense asserts itself in his struggle with the difficulties before him. The first difficulty confronting every writer of sectional or monographic history is: where to begin. His decision must necessarily be a more or less arbitrary one, since all such monographs are reaching backward with their roots into vast historic backgrounds. Mr. Sokolow, with excellent judgment, has chosen for his start the age of the Jewish reflux to England under Cromwell —with excellent judgment because the Old Testamentary leanings of the Puritans and the chiliastic beliefs and strugglings of Manasseh are the first important sublimation, in modern times, of Jewish Messianic sentiment into action of far-reaching import. Our author, after devoting eight interesting chapters to English sixteenth-century developments affecting the Jews, and two further chapters to English love of the Holy Land in its concrete manifestations, leaves British character and British soil for the space of six chapters to make an excursion into Napoleonic France. That Bonaparte, in his dealings with religious denominations, was a humbug ready to "take up" any and every religion under the sun if it happened to serve his momentary political shifts, does not seem to dawn upon the author's reflective faculties. He deals with Napoleon's Oriental schemes and manifestoes with an unblinking seriousness which makes us remember, with a twinge of regret, the brilliant delineator of Jewish tragicomedies in "Die Welt." Perhaps Mr. Sokolow thought humor an ingredient of composition not dignified enough to go into the making of his opus magnum, where, indeed, it is conspicuously absent. If so, we earnestly advise him to reconsult the great models of all history-writing —Motley, Macaulay, Carlyle, and the rest of Clio's immortals —who knew better.

Returning to British territory and its atmosphere of moral earnestness again in Chapter XVII, our chronicler of serious Zionist learnings is once more in his proper element. There is a peculiar charm, a warmth of affection about his character-sketches of British Zionist types which augurs well for Mr. Sokolow's progressive Anglicization. The same intimate charm abides with him when he deals with the Russian Zionism of his own Ghetto past, which forms the intermediary stage from deedless or fruitless individual Zionism to the modern mass-movement of our days. He is competent to do justice to the Choveve, the Neo-Hebraists, etc., not only through early associations, but for a reason which explains a great many of his hits and misses throughout the work. The religious factor in Zionism, on its scriptural face-value, is the same in all ages. It is quite possible to write attractive biographies of religious Zionists, without tracing religious inspiration to historical actualities. In plainer words, it is possible to write such biographies without being a historian. Mr. Sokolow, therefore, is happy in his element until, in Chapter XLVII of the first volume, he reaches modern Zionism. Thenceforward, in the concluding chapters of the first volume and throughout the entire length of the second, his failure is too manifest for dispute.

III

Without a preceding analysis and evolutionary history, however brief, of Jewish developments under the sway of emancipation, any

account of modern Zionism is bound to be a mere newspaper romance, without appeal to the sympathetic understanding of outsiders in search of information. Such an analysis (a wonderfully acute one but far too laconic to be truly satisfactory) we find, for instance, in H. Sacher's classical essay entitled "A Century of Jewish History." When, in an account of Zionism, we come to Herzl, there is an end of unrelated spiritual adventure. Questions of weight inevitably obtrude themselves: What made careers like those of Herzl and Nordau possible? What relative justification had assimilationism during the first four of five decades of its career? What caused its moral collapse? What stages of Jewish intellectual and moral development are represented in the West by Zionism and anti-Zionism? What changes did anti-Zionism undergo until it became a treasonable compromise for the benefit of the few against the many? What causes shifted the hegemony within the Zionist movement, since the days of Herzl, from the representatives of the Jewish West to those of the Jewish East? Why are the post-bellum anti-Semites of the European East active persecutors and oppressors of Zionist organizations? What concrete political motives arrayed the Entente Powers on the side of Zionism? What factors of international concern to Jews caused the American movement, for the time being, to depart from the essentially federative character of the Zionist movement in general? These and a score of questions of similar import give Mr. Sokolow no pause in his narrative. He seldom interrupts his narration of events to explain, though he often does so for the purpose, irrelevant in a history, to vindicate the Zionist position against an adversary. Astonishment, according to the Greek sage, is the beginning of all philosophy. That faculty of wonder which impels analytic inquiry into historical causes and effects, is either absent or dormant in Mr. Sokolow. His second volume, like his first, treats Zionism, on the whole, as a maze of individual adventure tending to a single aim, rather than a causal nexus. At the outset of the second volume, a strange lassitude seems to relax the grip of the author on his theme. He becomes a mere compiler, a chronicler trusting to the exciting contents of his documents rather than to his own expository ability in an effort to keep his chapters from the shoals of tedium. In this effort he succeeds, as indeed a man of lesser abilities than Mr. Sokolow's might have easily succeeded. It would take a veritable genius in the art of rendering important topics tiresome to produce an uninteresting volume on the history of modern Zionism, as long as the facts are allowed to speak for themselves. Apart from the strong interest of the subject-matter, Mr. Sokolow, in treating of modern Zionist affairs may truly say of himself: quorum pars magna fui—which in itself tends strongly to keep his pages free from ennui.

But whatever the defects of this remarkable opus, considered as a history, may be, there can be no doubt regarding its immense value as storehouse of miscellaneous information of interest to Zionists. The unwearied diligence of the author and his vast erudition have brought together, within comparatively small compass, an extensive and wonderfully interesting portfolio of Zionist documents. There are no less than ninety-one appendices to the second volume, which, if printed separately as a collection of Jewish miscellanies, would probably be the delight, in years to come, of the bibliophile in search of characteristic ana. In this connection, we may observe that Mr. Sokolow’s defective qualifications as an organizer of a big historic enterprise are by no means an unmixed evil. A number of big items contained in his two volumes would be eagerly read and, we doubt not, greatly admired, if reprinted as monographs—among others, his beautiful obituary of Sir Mark Sykes, his treatise on Manasseh ben-Israel and his sheaf of documents entitled “Zionism during the War.”