The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 10 · December 1919
368printed page
scan 70 of 82

Books-New and Old

Mr. Sokolow’s Big Venture

History of Zionism, 1600-1918. By NAHUM SOKOLOW. Longmans, Green, London. 1919. 2 vols. pp. 313-480.

The history of Zionism as a Jewish mass-movement affords, in a suggestive particular, a parallel to the annals of civilization. Its preliminaries are long and known only in fragmentary outlines, its records are relatively brief. In the history of mankind, five thousand years of civilization are preceded by a hundred thousand years and more of human struggles and developments, known only by their fruits and by a litter of stones and bones. Twenty-five years of Zionist movement (or forty, if localized propagında be counted) are preceded by eighteen hundred years of sporadic, unrelated Zionist sentiments, voiced in every age following the destruction of the Second Temple, at all times by Jews and sometimes by Gentiles, in every clime and every nation. For the most part, their sentiments are eccentric, individual, and without propagandistic force. In long intervals, they appear as group-sentiments, arising out of historic currents and; influencing the fate of the Jewish race. For a common source, they have Scriptural pledges and traditional Messianic hopes, read out of the Bible and into the Bible by fifty generations of.human beings used to look at their own physiognomies in the mirror of Holy Writ. It is plain that Zionist sentiments and aspirations before Herzl did not have any conscious secular basis. Their common denominator, in human consciousness, was a religious one— an unwavering belief in Biblical promises on the part of the Jews, translated, now and then, into strivings and deeds, a re-emphasis upon Old Testamentary pledges on the part of certain Gentile individuals and groups. In the assertion of these sentiments and aspirations there was no continuity, no far-reaching, long-sustained and effective co-operation, no tradition establishing well-known literary and historical precedents for succeeding generations. For many centuries before Herzl the light of Zion was extinguished in some places and rekindled in others, by people knowing little or nothing of each other’s doings— Sephardim, Askenazim, freemen, Ghetto-serfs, luminaries of the Eastern yeshibas, scholars of Western civilization, far-sighted statesmen and purblind mad dervishes, strong-willed Tories and hazy-minded socialists, gifted American ephemerals like Mordecai Noah and lofty-minded immortals like George Eliot, staid respectabilities like Sir Moses Montefiore and untameable gypsies like Herz Imber—a strange medley of incidental, unlike, incommensurable personalities, whose Zionist pronouncements and activities represent not Zionist history, but its discordant, rapsodizing prelude. The History of Zionism as a movement begins with the appearance of the Choveve in the public arena, right after the pogrom wave of 1882-83. Local in its first stage, the movement became international—like all diasporic movemenis of any consequence—in 1897, ihe year of the first Basle congress. The Basle formulation of a simple aim—the acquisition of a Jewish home in Palestine secured by public law—made it secular in tendency, catholic in scope, and based it squarely upon the doctrine of an avowed Jewish nationalism. Thenceforth, Zionism ceased to be an inorganic welter of aspirations. It became an organic movement influenced by and influencing world-affairs, an integral part of Jewish and universal history, a national effort on a grand scale‘ awaitine a historian of its developments.

I

Mr. Nahum Sokolow, known heretofore to the Jewish public as a tireless propagandist, able administrator, and author of brilliant feuilletonistic brevities, has come forward now with a "History of

Zionism." He has set himself the stupendous task of writing a history, not of the modern Zionist Movement merely, but of Zionist aspirations since about 1600—aspirations of which the movement, in Mr. Sokolow's presentation, is but the ultimate pragmatic embodiment of our own times. In the execution of this task ultra vires he produced a paradox—a valuable encyclopedic survey instead of a history—a library of monographs, interesting but by no means altogether relevant, in lieu of a structural unit—a work that conspicuously failed of its aim and yet will be indispensable to future historians of the Zionist movement.

In fact, Mr. Sokolow attempted a double venture: To rationalize pre-Herzlian Zionist sentiment, wherever it appeared, into something like a chain of causes and effect, and to write the history of ihe Zionist movement proper. The first venture, to our way of thinking, could have been brought to a successful issue by no one, for reasons inherent to the subject matter; the second resulted in a personal failure. But the most paradoxical circumstance about the work before us seems to be this: when the author, in his first volume, wrestles with a downright impossibility, viz., the co-ordination of pre-Herzlian Zionism .into an organic whole, he earns laurels upon laurels as an explorer of little known regions of Jewish history; when he is confronted, in his second volume, with a perfectly practicable task, namely, the anaylsis and summarization of a historical movement, he falls so deeply below the level attainable by a real historian as to become a mere compiler of more or less valuable documents and newspaper clippings. The reasons for this seeming paradox are patent enoueh:

Mr. Sokolow has been known for years as an able scholar and an admirable delineator of human character, but the analytic and constructive faculties of the historian face to face with a comprehensive task are denied him. Now it so happens—for reasons indicated in the outset of this brief review—that pre-Herzlian Zionism is a proper subject-matter for biography rather than history; in this field, therefore, the excellencies of an indefatigable research-worker and a writer of fine character-sketches, as combined in Mr. Sokolow, are sufficient to produce a valuable sequence of portraits; but when it comes to the why and the wherefore of a modern mass-movement, its actions and reactions, its internal struggles and historical setting, the industry of the antiquarian and the literary ability of the feuilletonist ceases to be of more than casual avail; hence the failure of Mr. Sokolow to rise above the status of a mere chronicler in his second volume.

II

The immense laboriousness of Mr. Sokolow’s pioneer-work is a feature disarming criticism and evoking the affectionate gratitude of all Zionists. It is throughout informed with an,ardent love of Zion and, occasionally, with an insight into its own defects, frankly avowed, which does honor to the virile intellect and candor of its author. He does not state when he first shouldered his self-imposed task or what length of time he was laboring over the two volumes now before us, but there are a hundred indications that the actual composition—apart from the research-work—was done in haste— presumably, to meet public interest in Zionist affairs at its zenith. It is plain there was no time for the execution of a well-conceived structural program if, indeed, the author had enough time allowed him for conceiving any such program. There seems to have been no time even for careful proof-reading and no chance for the insertion of afterthoughts in their proper places. As a consequence, the volumes are a veritable labyrinth of prefaces, introductions. inter-