The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 10 · December 1919
364printed page
scan 66 of 82

The Maccabaean

manifest sympathy, confidence, and good-will. The most prominent of our supporters is the Times, which has consistently, and with increasing emphasis, urged the justice of the Zionist solution of the Palestine question. Only a few days ago it published, in prominent type, an article from “a competent quarter” on the problems of the Near East, in which the writer, after recalling the promises made by the Allies to the Zionists, declared “Palestine should be constituted as a separate political unit in which, under a general mandate of Great Britain, the Zionists could carry out, subject to the supervision of the mandatory Power, their plans for organising a National Home for the Jewish People.” In a leading article in the same issue, the Times describes as excellent ihe suggestions of its anonymous contributor concerning the future of Syria, Mesopotamia and Palestine, and points out that “the exact adjustment of the boundaries between these new States and the nature of the mandate in each case, present difhculties of detail which, if they are not handled with an impartiality that is above suspicion, may wreck the whole work.” It declares that the problem is “to adjust the honourable obligations of each of the four parties concerned—Zionists, Arabs, British and French—in such a way that the idea of international rivalry or Imperialistic intrigue is clearly excluded.” The Times then observes, what has so often been pointed out before, that the complete settlement of the Ottoman Empire cannot be made until it is known whether the United States will accept a mandate for herself. “But,” it remarks, “that need not prevent the United States from helping us to a settlement of the more limited problem of Syria, Palestine and Mesopotamia. . . . If she would help in the working out of the details and the adjustment of the various claims, not only would the settlement be just, but, what is equally important, it would be acknowledged to be politically pure and above suspicion of self-seeking.”

The very friendly tone of this article is in rather striking contrast to the statements made by the Emir Feisal in an interview recently given to a representative of the Jewish Chronicle.* The attitude towards Zionism expressed by the Emir in his well-known letter to Professor Felix Frankfurter, was not only so sound but also so sympathetic, that the remarks he is reported now to have made six months later, must create no little surprise. To express the matter in a nutshell, Emir Feisal wishes well to the Jewish National Home in Palestine provided it forms a part of the great Arabian Kingdom of which he dreams, and will be under the general control of the Arabian Government. If this forms the considered judgment of the Emir, it is rather remarkable that he has not given expression to it sooner, particularly as he must doubtless be fully acquainted with the ideals and principles of Zionism as submitted to the Peace Conference last February. If any explanation is to be sought for the manifest inconsistency of his position, it may perhaps exist in the unwitting misrepresentation of his opinions by the interviewer. It will be remembered that in his letter to Professor Frankfurter, the Emir deprecated the extremist view adopted by certain Arab politicians, but now he appears, if he is rightly reported, to have been infected by those extremists. Six months ago he wrote: "We are working together for a reformed and revived Near East and our two movements complete one another. The Jewish Movement is national, not imperialistic; our Movement is national and not imperialistic; and there

As predicted by our correspondent, the Emir has since repudiated some of the statements attributed to him in the Jewish Chronicle.

Three Hundred Sixty-four

is room in Syria for us both. Indeed I think that neither can be a real success without the other." This statement was made in a letter which Emir Feisal signed with his own hand, whereas the statements published in the Jewish Chronicle are those recorded by an interviewer. On a previous occasion, when the French press published certain utterances as having been made by the Emir which were not favourable to Zionism, he afterwards issued a repudiation through Reuter. It is possible that he will now take the opportunity of issuing a similar denial of some of the utterances reported in the Jewish Chronicle. But whether the denial appears or not, there can be no doubt that the attitude now ascribed to Emir Feisal is utterly incompatible with Zionist aspirations and likewise with British policy concerned with the Near East. It is, of course, most desirable that an understanding should be arrived at, as soon as possible, with the Arab rulers, but it can only be on the basis of an integral Palestine which shall be constituted into the Jewish National Home under the supervision of Great Britain as the mandatory Power. I may mention that prior to the publication of the interview in the Jewish Chronicle, Dr. Weizmann had a conversation with the Emir Feisal shortly after his arrival in London, with gratifying result; and it was not until Dr. Weizmann was already on his way to Palestine that we were treated to the somewhat sensational pronouncement of our Arab visitor.

There has, of course, been considerable discussion lately respecting the speech made by Mr. Israel Zangwill at the meeting in celebration of the 70th birthday of Dr. Nordau. The discussion does not concern Mr. Zangwill's appreciation of Nordeau as an orator, writer, philosopher and critic, but his rather stringent observations concerning the present phase of Zionist policy. Mr. Zangwill reproached Dr. Weizmann with not having demanded a Jewish State, and there are not a few people who endorse this criticism. This is undoubtedly an easy way, as Dr. Weizmann afterwards remarked in a public speech, to curry popularity, but it certainly shows a very deficient grasp of the facts of the situation; for even if the Zionist leaders had demanded the immediate establishment of a Jewish State and this had been granted, one is at a loss to understand how the task could be achieved in the face of Arab opposition, without the aid of more bayonets than either the British or any other Government would be prepared to provide.

Dr. Weizmann, like all earnest Zionists, yearns for the creation of a Jewish State in Palestine at the earliest opportunity, but this must not be the precipitate result of perfervid enthusiasm, but the mature product of gradual evolution. The same criticism applies to the insistent demands that have been made for an immediate and vast immigration into Palestine. Anybody with an elementary knowledge of Palestinian conditions and economic laws must realise that the sudden influx of huge numbers of immigrants into Palestine would lead to a grave disaster which might very seriously imperil the upbuilding of our Jewish National Home. The views expressed by Dr. Weizmann in his recent speeches concerning the probable rate of immigration are not the product of fancy or conjecture, but are based upon careful estimates made by our most competent experts. Nobody—and least of all the Zionist leaders—fails to appreciate the seriousness of the Jewish position in Eastern Europe, which far transcends in misery and horror any catastrophe that has overtaken our brethren since the Middle Ages. But we must not let our hearts run

December, 1919