The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 10 · December 1919
363printed page
scan 65 of 82

The Maccabaean

American press. By the time these lines appear, Professor Geddes, who leaves England to-day, will probably have started upon his momentous task. Some eminent experts have also been engaged for the purpose of drawing up plans for the economic reconstruction of Palestine, particularly in regard to railways and harbors; and they too will begin their work without delay. On the other hand, turning to developments within the Zionist Central Office itself, I am able to record growing activity in the field of publicity. The Zionist Bulletin, containing an up-to-date budget of news of Zionist and general Jewish interest, appears weekly in English and Hebrew. It takes the place of the English edition of the Bulletins of the Copenhagen Bureau, which rendered an excellent service during the war. The official Hebrew organ, Haolam, which was suspended during the war, is also to be revived here, and will appear as a weekly. And there is serious talk of issuing a monthly review under the title of The Jewish Commonwealth, which should form a forum for the earnest discussion of all Zionist problems as well as questions of general national import.

Apart from Palestine the three principal matters now engaging serious attention are Rumania, the Ukraine and Poland. Rumania is making a desperate effort to wriggle out of signing the Treaty containing special safeguards for the national minorities within her border. M. Bratianu has been indefatigable in explaining to the press, both in his own country and abroad, that the signing of such a Treaty would constitute an abridgment of Rumania's sovereign rights. But Rumania's scandalous record of the treatment of her Jewish subjects is too well known to the Peace Conference for it to be moved by such abstract sentimental considerations. Rumania has not only flouted the signatories of the Berlin Treaty for the last forty years, but has also placed herself beyond the pale of civilization by stigmatizing and maltreating her native Jews as foreigners. Had she emancipated her Jewish subjects after acquiring the independence of a State, she would probably have been spared the indignity of having to sign a special treaty for the protection of her national minorities. But Rumania has such a record of duplicity and injustice that she cannot be trusted, and her obligations for the future must be absolutely clear, adequate, binding and unescapable.

There can no longer be any doubt that the worst pogroms that have taken place this year have been those in the Ukraine. According to a moderate estimate there have been massacres of Jews in about 130 places, and the number killed is said to be from 30,000 to 35,000. Some estimates give even a higher figure for those massacred. But the lower figure is certainly appalling enough. Unfortunately we have become so much accustomed now to pogroms that these figures fail to rouse much emotion. The pogroms in Poland must, by comparison and contrast, appear quite unimportant. But there is one cardinal distinction between the massacres in the Ukraine and those in Poland. In the former country the Government never attempted to deny their occurrence or shield their perpetrators. On the contrary, drastic measures were always taken and the principal culprits were put to death; while the Government has devoted very large sums of money to the relief of the surviving victims. Poland, however, has always declared that there have been no pogroms, and even in the measures taken for the suppression of the ",disorders" none of the principal malefactors have yet been touched. The military officers

December, 1919

responsible for the crimes of Lemberg, Pinsk and Vilna are all known, but they are still scot free.

The condition of our fellow-Jews in the Ukraine literally beggars description, and the most urgent task of the hour is undoubtedly to bring help and comfort to the communities that have been so barbarousiy orphaned and impoverished. One of the most effective means of staying the disaster and relieving the victims is to get a well-equipped Mission of Allied Jews attached to the Ukrainian Government and also to Denikin’s military headquarters. Such a task should not be insuperable. I think that the Peace Conference would favor the plan, provided it were presented in a cogent yet acceptable form; for not only moral but utilitarian considerations indicate the imperative necessity of peace, order and security in Russia.

But the question arises: Who shall prepare the plan and submit it? The Alliance Israelite is altogether too inert, cold and "careful" to tackle the problem. Our Joint Foreign Committee might be urged to do something, if the President of the Board of Deputies were now in England; but Sir Stuart Samuel left last week to investigate the programs in Poland, and he will probably not be back for two months. Our eyes therefore turn to the American Jewish Committee, which is possessed of greater initiative and resources. But apart from these old established organizations there is the Committee of Jewish Delegations in Paris, which has already accomplished so much for the welfare of East European Jewry, and which has resolved to continue in being until the closing of the Peace Conference. This committee is, by reason of its membership, most strongly entitled to speak on behalf of the oppressed Jews in the Ukraine, as on behalf of those in other parts of Eastern Europe, and it should, therefore, without delay, elaborate and submit adequate proposals for the protection and rehabilitation of the devastated and terror-stricken communities.

II

AS the time approaches for the final settlement of the destiny of Palestine, the question is receiving renewed attention in the press. Considering the hundreds of columns that have been written on Zionism since the publication of the Balfour Declaration, it is indeed remarkable to find that there are still writers of repute, otherwise well-informed, who display such a woeful ignorance of the elements of Zionist policy. Within the last two or three weeks there appeared two articles in London papers which showed a singular misconception of the entire position. One was by Colonel Repington, who, writing in that organ of Anti-Semitism, the Morning Post, poured gentle ridicule upon the Zionist ideal, on the ground that England had quite enough to do without concerning herself about a Jewish National Home. The other was by Mr. Crawfurd Price, who may be an authority on Balkan affairs, but has yet to prove that he has a right to speak on the future of Palestine. Writing in the Sunday Times, he observed that he had not yet come across any Jews who were desirous of settling in Palestine, and thereby betrayed the limitations of his knowledge. If Mr. Price had taken the trouble to acquaint himself with the facts of the situation, he would know that one of the great difficulties with which the Zionist leaders have now to cope is not to find emigrants for the New Judea, but to stem the threatening tide of immigration.

But the deprecatory articles of these two writers are the exception. The British press, on the whole, continues to

Three Hundred Sixty-three