The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 10 · December 1919
352printed page
scan 54 of 82
Facsimile · scan 54 of 82
Scan of p. 352
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

applauding hearers of the hopes of all Israel for a homeland, now drawing toward fulfillment. After paying his homage, under hearty concurrence of the assembly, to Messrs. Balfour and Wilson as the most eminent sponsors of our national cause, he called upon the man who accompanied Justice Brandeis to Palestine to address the gathering — Mr. Jacob de Haas.

Mr. de Haas, in a soul-stirring word picture of present-day Palestine, visited by him but the other day, unrolled the panorama of a land endowed by nature with indestructible beauty and fertility, but suffering today from what the speaker felicitously called "man-made unloveliness," from the ravages of war, from disease and artificial barrenness through neglect. He held his audience spellbound by an account of the actual and potential rescue-work and reconstruction work of Zionist effort in Palestine and especially of the American Zionist Medical Unit, concluding:

"If love for Zion makes Zion ours, we can truly make all of Palestine ours by loving, earnest, physical effort."

The next speaker of the evening, Major Lowenstein, was introduced by Judge Mack as one privileged to go to Palestine from America twice within twelve months, and as the Judge commendingly observed, deserving that mitzvoh, because he has given his life to the cause of the Jews and to the up-rearing of thousands of orphans.

Major Lowenstein then told of the work of the Relief Department of the Zionist Commission in Palestine, defending it against unfair attacks and solemnly declaring that relief was administered in a thoroughly non-partisan and undiscriminating way.

Major Lowenstein cheered his audience by telling it of the encouraging and hopeful inspirations he got from trips made to the Jewish colonies, where a beautiful spirit of reconstructive solidarity prevails among both men and women. Of this spirit he cited some concrete examples, winding up, under the cordial acclamation of his hearers.

Dr. Stephen S. Wise was then introduced as a man who had stood at the cradle of the organization twenty-one years ago, and who had been faithful to the cause ever since. Dr. Wise entertained his audience, in the beginning of his speech, with reminiscences of the poverty-stricken East-Broadway era of the movement. Under tremendous cheering, he then welcomed back into the fold, upon his return from Palestine, Justice Brandeis. The entire audience rose to their feet, cheering its honored leader on the platform.

Dr. Wise, continuing, spoke of Israel's readiness to forgive old injuries and of its new friends and sponsors among the nations—Great Britain, America, France and Italy. That our friends among the nations cannot give us Palestine—that we must earn it ourselves by a tremendous and long-continued effort, was the main insistence of Dr. Wise's cogent and impressive argument, concluded under prolonged applause.

After a brief address of Mr. Barak summing up the Palestinian insistence upon spiritual self-determination, Rabbi Hirsch Masliansky, as the Yiddish speaker of the day, was given the floor.

Rabbi Masliansky held the audience spellbound with the earnestness and eloquence with which he spoke of forty years of Zionist endeavor. He recalled the early days of Zionism in Russia —the days of Choveve Zion—when Dr. Weizmann, a mere boy, was his pupil. And so he went on, with unusual dramatic power. He narrated the story of Zionism to the present day—to the day of Brandeis, pointing to him as he was sitting on the platform. This was the signal for an ovation that lasted for minutes, with Mr. Brandeis rising repeatedly and bowing to the audience. With the singing of the "Star Spangled Banner" and "Hatikvah" the meeting adjourned at 11:30 P. M.

Three Hundred Fifty-two

NINTH SESSION

THURSDAY MORNING, SEPTEMBER EIGHTEENTH

At the opening of the ninth session called to order by Mr. Lipsky at 9:30 business was resumed at the point where it stood at adjournment the foregoing afternoon. In view however of the negligible number of delegates in attendance it was suggested that the roll call on the Organization Resolution be postponed for a later period of the session.

Thereupon Mr. Cooper, Chairman of the Committee on Resolutions, submitted, at the request of the orthodox Rabbis of the Convention, the following resolution:

WHEREAS, There seems to be a misunderstanding among the Jewish public as to the attitude of the Zionist Organization of America towards the Orthodox Zionists in this country, and

WHEREAS, Such misunderstanding is likely to undermine the future success of the great cause to which we all are willing to give our last measure of devotion and sacrifice, and

WHEREAS, In these critical times peace and unity in all the Zionist ranks and forces is most essential.

Therefore, be it resolved, That the Orthodox Rabbis (numbering 53) delegates to this Convention, assembled at a conference on September 18, request the Convention to take all possible steps and measures to reunite all the Zionist forces of American Israel under the banner of Eretz Israel, and that an impartial committee of five be appointed to start immediate negotiations with the Mizrachi and Poale Zion and other factions, if any, to secure Zionist solidarity, so that all parties which have hitherto worked independently and outside of the Zionist Organization of America, shall now form themselves as constituent elements under one central body, the Zionist Organization of America.

It was duly moved and seconded that this resolution be adopted.

Mr. Lipsky spoke against the resolution, as tending to reopen the way to fruitless negotiations. In this stand he was supported by Mr. Brodie, who moved that this matter be referred to the incoming Executive Committee for action. Motion seconded and carried.

Mr. Cooper submitted Resolution No. 2:

Resolved, That steps be taken to reach an amicable agreement between the Zionist Organization and the Order Sons of Zion, and to that end we respectfully request that a committee be appointed by this Convention to meet a committee of the Order Sons of Zion to effect this purpose.

Be It Further Resolved, That this Convention extend an invitation to the Order Sons of Zion to appoint a committee for this purpose.

The inference drawn from the debate that there was lack of harmony between the Order Sons of Zion and the Organization was strongly deprecated by the chairman who referred to a resolution of the Order advising all members to register in their districts as members of the Zionist Organization of America—an advice followed by 80 per cent of the membership. Mr. Brodie's resolution to refer the whole matter to the incoming Executive Committee was thereupon seconded. A minority report on Resolution No. 2 was submitted and both resolutions tabled upon motion of Mr. Abrahams, of Chicago. A number of minor resolutions submitted were unanimously adopted. All resolutions being disposed of, the chairman recognized the Chairman of the Committee of Finance, Mr. Peter Schweitzer. Briefly summed up, his report shed light upon the following main details.

During the past financial year, the item of so-called fixed expenses amounted to about $515,000. A goodly part of these expenses were devoted to useful propaganda, literature, education, and so forth. But after making every allowance the report declared the expenditure too high when measured against the total net income, which during the year, was only one million and a half. Among the excessive expenses to be lowered by better management, the report mentioned the item covering stationery and printing which has swollen to an amount owing to what the report called "paper bureaucracy." The speaker de-