The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 10 · December 1919
350printed page
scan 52 of 82

The Maccabaean

must be closed at 5:30. He therefore suggested that there be a time limit on the discussion of the majority and minority reports. The chairman pointed out that a time limit presupposes an agreement on the main question and that such limit would be fatal to anybody who had anything to say against the proposition. He therefore suggested that the speakers be limited to five minutes.

Mr. Morris Kramer, of New York, and Mr. Zeldin, were next to speak. Both defended the minority reports and dismissed as groundless the alleged difficulties the direct elections would create for the districts. "All Zionists are vitally interested in the affairs of the organization," said Mr. Zeldin, "and they would welcome the opportunity to have a voice in the election of members to the Executive Committee."

Mr. Senior Abel opposed this view and pointed out the small vote cast by the Zionists in electing delegates to the Convention.

Dr. Wise, in an exhaustive address, animadverted the pseudo-democratic policy of wholesale censures heaped upon the Administration, and continued in part as follows:

"Now, in regard to the Constitution. How long ago was it that the new Constitution was adopted? One year ago, or, to be accurate, fifteen months ago. We have tried the Constitution for the extended term of fifteen months, and after fifteen months, lightly and inadvisedly, because there is a sense of grievance, of disappointment, we are prepared to practically rescind, repeal and overthrow the entire Constitution.

"You gentlemen talk about being democratic. Here you are proposing to do the most undemocratic thing imaginable. You have come to this Convention, and without any mandate on these things, without any referendum to our great constituency, you plan to reverse our entire Constitution, and to introduce changes which are not merely doubtful, but absolutely subversive."

After pleading with the delegates not to act on such a weighty matter in haste, he concluded by offering the following substitute motion:

That from the body of the Convention of the Organization, there shall be elected a commission of fifteen men and women, which commission of fifteen men and women shall report not later than the first of April in writing—I mean, of course, in printing—to the Organization. By "Organization" I mean the regions, the districts, and the Executive Committee,—the entire Organization. This commission of fifteen to report not later than—well, give them to the first of April—on the problem of electing some part of the Executive Council. That plan, after having been submitted in writing to the Zionists of America, to take precedence as the order of the day at the next Annual Convention of the Zionist Organization of America.

The motion was duly seconded.

Mr. Abraham Goldberg then spoke in Yiddish questioning the necessity of having a referendum on this matter. He recalled to Dr. Wise how he (Dr. Wise) had fought for the direct election of members to the United States Senate, and pleaded with him for consistency.

After Judge Golden spoke at length against the minority report, pressure of time inclined the Convention to fall in with a suggestion of Judge Mack to hear, after close of debate, the reporter on behalf of the minority resolution, the reporter of the majority resolution, and the mover of the substitute resolution, giving a final word to each. In keeping with this arrangement, the chairman recognized Mr. Cohen first, Dr. Wise next, and Mr. Neumann last. Mr. Cohen said in part:

"We have before us great tasks which we must perform. The organization is the instrumentality whereby that work must be carried out. The organization is made up of Zionists scattered throughout the country. They are the ones who must do the work. Therefore, they must be heard, and heard as directly and as emphatically as possible, not

Three Hundred Fifty

once, not at a Convention, but their voice, we believe, in order that they may effectively participate in the great work which lies before us, must be heard perhaps once every month.

"Now we recognize the sterling qualities of our leaders. Permit me to say, if I may be personal, that whatever may have actuated the other members of this Committee—and I have no reason to think that they were actuated by anything ulterior—I personally was not actuated by the slightest particle of hostility to any member of the Administration, because I would be willing to follow their behest every single time, for I have the utmost faith in them.

"But no matter how small and unimportant we may be, if we are worthy of being placed upon a committee, it is our duty to conscientiously suggest proposals to this organization and defend them to the best of our ability.

“We believe a great deal is to be gained by letting each section of the country feel that it is directly and immediately in contact with the Executive Committee and the Administrative oficials of the organization, and we believe that the only way that that can be done is to have them elected by the various districts in which they reside, or those districts where thev are known.”

The speaker was followed on the floor by Dr. Wise, whose main contention was as follows:

"Mr. Chairman, my distinguished friend from New Haven declares that we must analyze the proposals in order to determine whether they are democratic or not. That is exactly what I urged. Only it may be that, not being schooled in the niceties and the complexities of legal statute and practice, I am unable to analyze and to grasp an important, far-reaching, fundamental series of constitutional amendments in two hours, on a warm September afternoon. It seems to me it is dealing much more reverently, in much more orderly fashion, with all the people to give them time wherein to analyze, than merely to insist that they shall prove in a moment wherein the proposed plan fails to be democratic.

"I say, the proposals are momentous. Let us not deceive ourselves, dear friends. The district plan is an admirable plan, but it is yet in the making. We have not perfected it, by any means. We have only begun to operate along these lines. Much remains to be done before we shall be convinced that it is the most effective method of reaching our problem.

"Now, suddenly we are asked to overlay this problem upon the district plan—that plan, which, I say, is in little more than an embryonic stage, and I merely am asking for time, wherein we may consider the question, and pass upon it intelligently.

"Finally, I would remind you that a new doctrine has been set up this afternoon, according to one of my very eloquent friends. According to him, the Jewish democracy rises or falls with the election of the members of the Executive Committee by the whole Convention. That is a new Zionist doctrine. In other words, 'I believe in this, therefore it is democratic; you do not believe in it, therefore you are a conservative and a hide-bound reactionary, and an enemy of all political progress.'

"Well, merely to state that proposition is to point out the absurdity of it. Theodore Herzl was a good Democrat; Nordau is a Democrat. The Greater and the Smaller Actions Committees are named by the Zionist Congress, not by district or regional delegations. Now, I do not say that that is the wiser way. I do not know. I leave my mind open.

"But, ladies and gentlemen, above all things, do not use this thing, and do not accept it, in order to prove that the Administration is to be denuded of power. Remember that the Administration asks no power with which you are not

December, 1919