The Maccabaean
these words in quotation marks because it was not an opposition in the ordinary sense of that term. As was abundantly demonstrated by the votes, the "opposition" in this case constituted the overwhelming majority of the delegates and included some members of the National Executive Committee, and a good many of the officials of the organization. It was a movement organized and conducted not for the purpose of discrediting or humiliating or weakening the Administration, but rather for the purpose of purging it of whatever flaws it contained, and thereby strengthening its hold upon the loyalty and affection of the Jewish masses.
The "opposition" succeeded in accomplishing two things. In the first place, it cleared the atmosphere. For more than a year American Zionism, and for that matter, American Jewry, had been seething with discontent. On several important occasions the Zionist Administration had acted contrary to strong popular sentiment. In the minds of many it had become almost a mechanical affair, an impersonal "machine," which it is so much easier to dislike and condemn than a living person or group of persons. The air had become heavily laden with dissatisfactions, disappointments, and animosities. By the time the Convention opened, the skies of American Zionism were dark with electrically charged clouds. A thunder storm had to come in order that the sun might shine again. It was the privilege of the "opposition" to precipitate this storm.
In the second place, the "opposition" rekindled in the Zionist democracy its flickering confidence in its own latent powers. For too long a time, the Zionist rank and file had failed to exercise the sovereignty which was theirs in theory. They had grown accustomed to follow whithersoever they were led—docile, unquestioning, and uncomplaining. This tendency was naturally greatly exaggerated upon America's entry into the world conflict. Under the influence of war psychology, every bit of non-conformity was regarded almost as treason, and every whispered word of criticism of the Administration as damnable sacrilege. Various attempts at self-assertive action had ended ingloriously, so that independent-minded Zionists had begun to despair of ever "storming the impregnable positions of the Administration," or of restoring popular control.
The events at Chicago have demonstrated that this feeling of utter helplessness and consequent dejection on the part of the rank and file was unjustified and rested largely upon a myth. For, in the end, what was really of capital importance was not this or that reform, this or that method of election, but the salutary effect of the self-assertion of the
delegates—the strengthening of the conviction that forensic eloquence and parliamentary skill could not, in the end, prevail when the right was arrayed on the other side. The arm of the Zionist democracy had long been unused, and was in danger of becoming atrophied. The "opposition" at Chicago regalvanized that withering arm into life, and restored to it power of action.
One more consideration: We are now witnessing, in the Zionist Organization, though on a much smaller scale, the beginnings of a process somewhat similar to that which took place in the whole of American Jewry during the agitation for the American Jewish Congress. The control of the affairs of the Jewish community of America had for many years been lodged in the hands of a particular group or class which represented the older settlement of Jews in the United States, and no provision existed by which the newer elements in the community, the immigrants from East European countries, could automatically acquire a share in that control, corresponding to their increasing numbers and importance. The resulting struggle was an attempt to reach a proper equilibrium, a new balance of power between the various component parts of American Jewry. Similarly, in the Zionist Organization it had for many years been a tradition that the rank and file came from the East European immigrant Jews, while the leadership and direction of the movement was contributed by Jews of the older Americanized elements. During the war this "division of labor" became more strikingly evident than ever before, and considerable dissatisfaction developed because the masses instinctively felt that in matters vitally affecting the future of the Jewish nation, it was dangerous to preserve this distinction.
No doubt many of the mistakes committed by the Zionist Administration and which so irritated Jewish public opinion were due very largely to the lack of mutual understanding between the masses and the leaders. The Convention, therefore, strove to discover a method by which the present gulf between the leaders and rank and file might be bridged, so that the former would be more responsive to the stirrings of the masses, and the latter might more effectively participate in the shaping of Zionist policies.
The Chicago Convention must, therefore, be considered as pregnant with great possibilities for the future. The spell which seemed to rest upon the Zionist Organization of America has been broken. The tension has been relieved. The positive results will not be long in coming.
