The Maccabaean
only with organization technique, with the manner in which the members of the Executive Committee shall be chosen, and many delegates found themselves unable to grow enthusiastic over the merits of the question. Many delegates felt that with the Zionist movement facing the great task of the upbuilding of Palestine, a matter of drganization technique should not be allowed to become ihe dominating interest of the Convention. But the merits of this particular question are not so significant as the intelligent determination with which the delegates handled it. They showed that they understood the Zionist movement and the Zionist Organization to be matters for which they were responsible, and that in the exercise of their rights and duties they were not going to abdicate their judgment to the appeals of authority. This time it has been an organization issue; next time it may be, and probably will be, a Palestine issue. The moral Ta nahviane. " \
That Palestine was not the center and orbit of this Convention is the greatest source of regret. Despite the Palestine message which came from the highest quarters, not enough, apparently, was done to focus the heart and mind of the Convention on the problems of the Homeland and their solution. It is essential that even now certain conceptions with regard to the upbuilding of a Jewish Palestine should be instilled into the minds of the Zionist masses. They must be made to conceive of the task in large terms, in terms, to speak plainly, of an ordered mass colonization, and they must become possessed of a sense of their responsibility for the success of such measures. It is a fatal mistake to permit the motion to prevail that a Jewish Palestine will ensue as a result of certain political dispensations and arrangements. A Jewish Palestine will only ensue if and when the economic foundations of Palestine are established, owned and controlled by the Jewish People nationally organized. This conception, and the consciousness of responsibility which must go with it, needs to be branded into the mind of the Jewish People and in particular of the Zionists. A difficult piece of work, but not impossible of accomplishment by those who are themselves imbued with the conception and who understand Jewish psychology. And what better occasion could be found for bringing home this message than the Zionist Conventions? Why this was not done at Chicago is a question which should be asked by us and answered by others.
An examination of the formal record of the Convention reveals the fact that one resolution was passed, and passed unanimously, which did carry that conception. It is the following:
WHEREAS, The economic phase of the problem of the restoration of the Jewish Homeland in Palestine has become of immediate importance, and
WHEREAS, The International Zionist Organization is the only organized agency of the Jewish people for the creation of the National Jewish Homeland in Palestine, therefore be it
Resolved, It is the sense of this convention:
1. That, the establishment of the economic foundations of the National Jewish Homeland, in harmony with the principles of the Pittsburgh Platform, is properly the task of the International Zionist Organization.
2. That the International Zionist Organization create the proper instrumentalities for the study of the possibilities of mass-colonization in Palestine and for the preparation of plans based on the results of such study.
December, 1919
3. That the representatives of the American Zionists at the next Zionist Congress use their influence and voice to carry into effect the terms of this resolution.
This resolution went through practically without discussion. Did the delegates have a thorough understanding of it and of its implications? Did they understand that it aims to make the Zionist Organization directly responsible for the economic upbuilding of Palestine? Were they sufficiently familiar with the principles of the Pittsburgh Platform to realize that they were calling on the Zionist Organization to establish the economic foundations of Palestine on the basis of the nationalization of the land, the natural resources and the public utilities, and on the application of co-operative methods to agriculture, industry and commerce? Were they aware of the fact that they were disqualifying any man not in accord with those principles from representing American Zionists at the Zionist Congress? Were they conscious of the huge resources which the realization of such a program —a program of systematic mass-colonization—involves? Were they, when considering this resolution, facing without flinching their own responsibilities in furnishing these resources?
There is in reality no good reason for refusing an afırmative answer to all these questions. The high level of intelligence and the quick perceptiveness displayed by the delegates in deliberating on other questions encourage the belief that they perceived the implications of the resolution in question. But the sad fact stands that the focal interest of the Convention did not consist of the issues involved in this resolution. The organization issue overshadowed everything else. And for this, the “Opposition” should receive its share of blame though it cannot be denied that those who had in hand the arrangements of the Convention had it in their power to give Palestine the place in the deliberations which it should have had.
The outstanding fact should be emphasized: The Chicago Convention recorded a substantial growth in the intellectual and moral stature of American Zionism, even more significant than its physical growth. The leadership and administration will have to keep pace with it. We forget that an administration is like Gulliver in his travels: it is a giant when it comes to Lilliputia, it is a dwarf when it comes to Brobdingnag. The important question is not: What does the leadership amount to? It is, rather: What does American Zionism amount to? The leadership will be exactly what the led will it to be. And if the led will it to be a close, intimate, responsive, allthe-year round and twenty-four-hours-a-day leadership, it will have to become that.
It is a fairly safe prophecy that the question of the economic upbuilding of the national Jewish Homeland, rather than questions of organization technique, will be dominant ‚at subsequent Conventions and Congresses. Will American Zionism embrace completely and militantly the conception of a systematic mass colonization which the creation of a Jewish Palestine requires? Will it demand from its leadership the large vision, the fearless action, and the confidence in the masses of the Jewish people necessary for such a program? Zionist education can have no more essential function than to prepare Zionist public opinion to embrace this conception and stand for this demand. The Chicago Convention is a fair augury for the success of such an educational campaign.