The Maccabaean
permissible for one to be possessed of any form of wealth at all, it should be unjust to the last degree to dispossess him who happens to have converted his property in the form of land.
On the question as to whether it is the first settler or the last who confers value on land, I am not sure that the Single Taxer is right either. If the second settler finds it so much more convenient to settle in the neighborhood of the first, then it can hardly be said that the long vigil of the first pioneer was without value to the community that subsequently grows up around him. Why then should it be claimed that the earlier settlers derive an unearned increment occasioned by the growth of population on the land? The reverse would be nearer the truth —that the newcomers derive an increment resulting from the hardihood, the daring and the self-mastery of the pioneer.
Certainly, speculation in land values must be abolished. But so also should speculation in corn, wheat, meat, sugar, leather, lumber, coal, oil, iron, etc., etc. To seize upon land-values alone as the bete noir of our existence, is to give a distorted, one-sided picture of the state of affairs, and to punish one section of the people for the shortcomings or incompetence of the whole. Speculation in land, though we may consider it reprehensible, stands upon precisely the same footing as speculation in commodities generally, neither better nor worse. Nor is it altogether correct to speak of an “unearned increment” as a certain result of a land-purchase. Many a man, indeed, has suffered a loss of increment through having bought land. The State does not protect the buyer of land-values from loss or depreciation of his investment. Why then should it claim the right to his profit where his buy happens to be a lucky one?
On its practical side, also, Single Tax leaves something to be desired. Suppose, indeed, that all taxes were removed from improvements and put only upon the bare land. Would that reduce the amount of the tax? Hardly. The mere fact that taxes were removed from improvements would not pay government expenses. The only difference would be that the same tax, instead of being distributed over a variety of things, would be added together and placed as one big tax on land.
But it is claimed that the effect of the Single Tax would be that land could be had for the asking and there would be so much building that our economic problems would be solved. I doubt it. The fact is that land can be had for the asking or almost for the asking, now. Why is there no rush for it? Because of the tax on improvements, answers the Single Taxer. But the same tax, being a necessary government expense, must be paid in any case! I reply. In vain I point to the acres of beautiful upstate land right in New York that can be bought for the price of less than a foot of city land. The Single Taxer tragically points to a few vacant city lots to which no one may have access except at a speculative figure. One must admit that the last is a telling point against speculation in land, but not in favor of Single Tax. The fact of the matter is that the reason why a plot on Broadway may fetch a million dollars is not because it is more productive than an equal area in Greene County, but because it is a more strategic spot on the battle-ground of economic anarchy. It is a seat in the Municipal Stock Exchange. Only under Industrial Franchise with its standardization of prices would there be an elimination of industrial conflict and such a decentralization
of the catch-as-catch-can markets in the great cities, as would lessen the abnormal congestion in the larger cities and, incidentally, bring down the price of city real-estate.
Nor can I see where the poor man will fare better under State landlordism than under private ownership of his home. Suppose, for example, that A, whom we may suppose a pioneer Zionist, locates in Palestine, builds a shack, which he calls his home, near Haifa, and settles down to wait for his brethren to join him there. Gradually he is joined by other Jews, until he finds himself surrounded by quite a prospering community, including a number of wealthy families in pretentious villas. The newcomers have had a chance to amass wealth, while poor A was spending the best part of his life trying to accommodate himself to his hard life. Single Tax finds this community and proposes to make it happier. It assesses an increased land tax proportioned to the increased value of the land due to the fine residences erected there and the increased population and demand. In vain A protests that, although located in a desirable spot, he only inhabits a shack, has already paid for it, and can not pay governmental rent despite the pretentious houses surrounding him. Under the old system poor A might have lived on undisturbed in his poor shack even though unadmired. But now he is at the mercy of an insistent, remorseless landlordism with no public opinion even to appeal to. If he cannot meet the new financial standards legally enforced by the waves of prosperity about him, he must abandon his home and move to poorer quarters. For under Single Tax, the poor man who is favorably located must either pay increasing rental values or get out and loses his fee simple besides. Single Tax and double trouble!
Now let us see, by way of comparison, how speculation in land would be prevented under Industrial Franchise. (I quote from the Program of the Industrial Franchise League).
“First: That all future conveyances of residential lands, to be valid at law, must be made direct to users only; and that such direct users may only convey, in turn, to direct users whose bona fides in such transactions must always be proven and demonstrated.
“Second: That all industrial, agricultural or mining lands may only be conveyed to industrial, agricultural or mining federations, duly federated and franchised to engage in their respective industries.
“Fourth: That all lands held out of use or occupation be made subject to a Luxury Land Tax.”
It will be observed that the first clause prevents trading in lands for speculative purposes, without resort to confiscation, or depriving the owner of the enhanced value of land in actual occupation. The second clause emphasizes the fact that, under Industrial Franchise, lands intended for industrial exploitation can only be conveyed to the franchised industry concerned. Assuming that the fortunate conveyor of such land obtained the market value for the conveyance, the future "unearned increment" of such land would inure to the benefit of the country as a whole, since the investor would in no event be entitled to more than his interest on capital invested at the time of investment. In other words, the public would be entitled to the "unearned increment" because it would have earned it by stepping into (Continued on page 328)
(Continued on page 328)