The Maccabaean
that it would not allow for competition, "which is the life of trade." But I maintain that this kind of competition is not the life of trade; it is the strife of trade. It is by no means essential either to the individual nor to the community as a whole. It is high time that a distinction be made between the destructive competition of values and the healthful competition of individuals. Under Industrial Franchise the competition of created values would be eliminated. No industry would be permitted to sap or undermine another, nor steal its skilled workers, nor befuddle the public by tricks of advertising, nor adulterate its products to meet competition, nor sweat and underpay its workers, nor gamble and speculate in the cost of materials, nor by buying up the leases of competitors, nor suppressing useful inventions, nor defraud its creditors, nor sue or be sued in bankruptcy, etc., etc. But, on the other hand, nothing would prevent the individual worker in any industry under Industrial Franchise from competing in useful service, in creativity, in industrial economy, organization, invention and in the pursuit of his work-interest upon non-destructive lines and in obtaining a return commensurate with his service to the community. And this is the only form of competition worth preserving.
Then there is the objection of those that prefer to give their allegiance to the co-operative movement. The word "co-operative" sounds well to all of us. As a matter of fact, co-operation, in the broad meaning of the word, is the aim of every constructive movement. It is the paramount aim of Industrial Franchise. But I hope I will not be suspected of mere pride of opinion when I say that the co-operative movement as it works in Great Britain and Russia, large as it has become, is neither effective in itself nor applicable to our present problems in Palestine.
In Russia, I suspect, the success of the co-operative movement is largely due to the fact that that country has been industrially so backward that the co-operative movement stood virtually alone. Sears Roebuck, perhaps, would not have succeeded as well, due to the illiteracy of the people; but a Mr. Woolworth, under favorable conditions, might have done as well or better. In England and Scotland, the movement represents not an economic solution, in my opinion, but is simply an expression of thrift. For the co-operative plan does allow of a saving to its beneficiaries. As regards Palestine, the co-operative scheme is of secondary importance, because we have first to devise ways and means of introducing and intrenching the population necessary to avail themselves of the supposed benefits of this movement.
The salient features of the co-operative plan are that members can buy a limited number of shares entitling them to receive on their purchases from co-operative stores rebates representing the middleman's profits. If the purchaser is poor and his purchasing power little, naturally his profits will be little; if the member has means and his purchases are considerable, his gains will be greater. There are helpful elements in this scheme, but after all, it is closely akin to the ordinary industrial enterprise with its promise of profits to the lucky investor, except that emphasis is placed upon the purchase of commodities instead of upon shares of stock. It is still subject to the risks of ordinary business and the hazards of competition, which is the reason why so many co-operative enterprises have been wrecked both in this country and abroad. As the paramount appeal of the co-operative industry is to the consumer, and as it
must compete with the prices of non-cooperative industries, it is not in a position to afford a radically better wage-scale to its workers.
As a matter of fact, the whole premise of the co-operative movement is based upon the false assumption that the middlemen or entrepreneur is not entitled to his profit. The failure of so many private as well as co-operative enterprises proves the contrary. As long as the middleman is compelled to risk production and distribution in competition with others, to supply an uncertain demand and deal with ever-changing values, he is entitled to charge a premium over and above his service, to cover his margin of risk. To eliminate the charge of the capitalist, it is necessary to eliminate his risk, which can only be done under Industrial Franchise.
Finally, insofar as the co-operative movement aims to become a potent economic factor ordained to solve the economic problems of the world, it is woefully clumsy and hopelessly inept. Although its membership is large in places, it will never be large enough. It is as though a cow-boy would attempt to round up a herd of cattle by dragging every steer to the spot, instead of guiding the mass by influencing their direction. Insofar as its ability to influence the economic direction of the world is concerned, it stands in about as good a position as a driver who would lead a horse by the tail instead of by using the reins. The vantage place from which to re-order the economic life of a nation is not the co-operative store, but the polls. It is not necessary to duplicate, compete with or undermine the great industrial organizations of the world. Already there are highly developed mammoth industrial establishments in countries like America, reasonably adapted to meet the consumer's requirements. All that is required is the formation, not of co-operative stores, but an insistent political organization, watchful of its opportunities, to bring our entire industrial establishment under Industrial Franchise, by the stroke of a pen.
III
Single Tax is a well-intended movement. It aims to eliminate speculation in land. But why stop there? Why not also stop speculation in all commodities? The Single Taxer rather overstrains his point when he picks upon speculation in land as the head and front of our economic troubles. Land is simply one of the values tossed around like a shuttlecock by the mischances of economic anarchy. To urge the confiscation of land values then, is, on the one hand, not drastic enough, and, on the other, too drastic. For we have to deal not only with land but with the product of land as well.
But, to the economic issue involved herein the Single Taxer has also joined a moral issue which, he believes, is peculiar to the land question. Man cannot live off the land. What right then has anyone to the exclusive possession of it? Also, it is not any single individual who gives value to land, but the presence and growth of a community in its vicinity. Why then should the individual enjoy the benefits of an unearned increment?
To these moral questions there are answers that are perfectly moral. While it is true that man cannot live away from the soil, it is equally true that civilized man can only live on it by taking a proprietary interest in it. Unlike the savage, he must have continuous possession in order to realize the fruits of his labor on it. Furthermore, if it is
