The Maccabaean
largest part of these had come to stay. For had they not demanded to be taken to Palestine when the authorities seemed to vacillate between sending them on to the "Line" and dispersing them in due time from England? With these reinforcements in view, optimists prophesied that at least fifteen hundred men had meant it when they told their families, friends, newspapers and audiences that thereafter they would be found in Palestine. "dead or alive."
By the time these lines appear a round twelvemonth will have elapsed since the last of the Jewish battalions took up garrison duty along the Palestine line of communication. By this time most of the American Jews, including nearly all who had a mind or a portion of a mind to become a citizen of the Jewish Palestine have been "separated." The American chapter in the history of the Jewish Legion is thus drawing to a close. These men came, saw and went back to the piece-goods counter, bookkeepers' stool, sewing machine, schoolroom, etc. Before examining the contributory causes for this "home-coming," in violation of a pledge, it might be profitable to see what manner of human material we had to deal with. For purposes of convenience Mr. Jabotinsky bucked the man under two headings:
1. Those who wish to be demobilized in Palestine.2. Those who wish to be demobilized outside of Palestine (America, Great Britain, etc.).
Those in (2) be dismissed abruptly, relegating them to the care of the British Government. The Government brought them over; the Government would in the ordinary course of events return them to their places of enlistment. Those in (1) Mr. Jabotinsky exhorts to be patient, models of iron-cast discipline, etc. Their hour would come. Now, it appears that a slight modification to Mr. Jabotinsky's otherwise excellent division is in order. The men in class (1) should have been subdivided something like this:
(a) Those who meant it.(b) Those who did not.
If the men we are dealing with were 1,500 archangels such a subdivision would indeed be blasphemous. But men do not always mean what they say. Nor are they always quite certain as to what they do mean. And, finally, men do change their minds, usually after they are made up, about the thing they merely wish. One is tempted to carry this subdivision to its bitterest, logical end and to distinguish between those of our men who not only wished it or meant it but willed it with all their heart and brain and brawn, and those who meant it provisionally. A large number of those who paraded and otherwise indicated and generally bragged of their intention to setile in Palestine did so because it was the fashionable thing to do. There were certain advantages and privileges to be derived from being known as a prospective Palestinian. There were colonies and “kwootzoth” to be visited where an American Jew who was stopping after the war was received on terms of equality—plus suppressed awe, the due of every one who comes from that great land. There were labor meetings and conventions to which -the American soldiers were permitted to send delegates. And, finally, was there not the “Hora” and the “Ronda,” the two and I think only popular dances to be learned? Almost every American is a past-master of both by now. The reckless adventurer was never wanting in our ranks. It is notorious that he does not stoop to consider conditions and like insignificant trifles. As a commentary on human nature
it might be observed that some of these adventurers come under 1 (a) classification. They meant it. They still do.
But the story is long and life is short. We are chiefly concerned with the men who meant it and at the last moment probably a little earlier decided to apply for repatriation, and the probable general reasons that contributed towards their change of heart.
their change of heart. The unpreparedness of the Zionist Organization in general and the powerlessness of the Zionist Commission in particular are responsible in the main for the changing of most minds. The only definite proposals that came excathedra were outlined in an address of the acting chairman of the Commission delivered in December, 1918, before two of the Battalions, under regimental supervision. Dr. Edes presented a plan for the employment of about three hundred men, having as an aim a colony founded on communal and co-operative basis, following either the "small-holding" or "profit-sharing" system. Facilities were to be given for the training of this limited number in some farm colony settlement. Before committing themselves to this scheme the selected men were to be given a sort of preliminary test in forestation work. In December, 1918, it should be noted, Dr. Edes had "reason to believe" that the work would commence in March, soon after the men were demobilized. Actually demobilization and repatriation in our units did not begin before late in August. The forestation plan died at birth. The colonizing scheme was never again heard of. The Zionist authorities abroad rejected it because it involved a budget of three million dollars. No one troubled to inform the men that the plan was given up. But it was felt, instinctively. Such a reversal was not calculated to increase the confidence of the men. Even the earnest men began asking themselves "cui bono"?
The economic conditions of Jewish Palestine was a discouraging factor. The position was, and is, such that no large group, without private capital, can hope to be independent of some organization which should take them under its wing and tide them over until better days. Individuals might possibly find agricultural or technical employment. But what opportunities offered themselves for several hundred when, with nearly a thousand of Palestine's young Jews in the service, there was, and is an aggravated problem of unemployment, rendered more acute by the arrival of scores of dauntless, sturdy young Polish Jews, willing to do anything anywhere in Palestine, not scorning even the fever-ravaged swamps? The spectacle of the Roumanian immigrants opening cafés in the towns and watering places with a view of saving up for the return passage shook the very foundations of the determination of those even who meant it.
While the new Jewish Palestine fascinated most of those who meant it, who felt clasped and warmed by its contact, the social fabric of the old Yishub did not prove so attractive. Jerusalem, "the desolate, poor darling whom the grey-beard Rabbi loves" is adored, not less tenderly, by the beardless, khaki-clad Jew. Not so the ancient dwellers of Jerusalem, Haifa, Tiberias, Safed, etc. There is not, luckily, much about them and their cities to appeal to the tastes of the metropolitan young man, accustomed to theatres of a sort, moderately-priced restaurants and the rest of American urban pleasures.
The uncertainty of the status and future of battalions was in itself a cause of demoralization. I am speaking here only of that large number of men who regarded the battalions as flesh of their flesh and bone of their bone. To