The Maccabaean
Education Department: DR. LURIE, Director. (1) Schools. (2) Literature. MR. SZOLD, Political Department, with DR. FRIEDENWALD. OFFICE ADMINISTRATION Finance Committee, with Treasurer. DR. EDER, Agricul- } MR. ETTINGER ture Dept. } Director Engin'ring and } MR. WILBUSHEV- Public Works } ITZ, Director (1) Jewish Battalions. (2) Immigration and Labor. Mr. Lewin-Epstein, Treas. Dept. Finance Committee: (1) Budget. (2) Accounts. (3) Relations with Anglo-Palestine Co. (4) Business Transactions of Z. C. MR. MOSSERI: Departments: (1) Haifa Office. (2) Egypt. (3) Syria and Near East. (4) Work with Sephardic Communities. (5) Paris Bureau. DR. POOL: Jerusalem Dept.: (1) Relief. (2) Finance Committee. (3) Relations with Institutions and Population of Jerusalem. (4) Publicity.
Mr. Van Vriessland: Acting Treasurer (assumed the duties of Mr. Lewin-Epstein, whose health had suffered greatly).
The "Palestine Office" (Mizrad) continued its activity under the tireless and devoted direction of Dr. Thon, but its functions were greatly curtailed. It continued its supervision of the work of relief outside of Jerusalem, and Dr. Thon acted as a member of the Committee on Finance. But financial management and accounting, which had been entirely in the hands of the "Palestine Office," were gradually and in the end almost entirely taken over by the Commission, and other activities, as is seen in the scheme of departments described above, were likewise placed under the control of the Commission. It was evident that the multiplicity of separate Zionist agencies (such as Palestine Office, National Fund) working independently is a serious drawback to the proper working of the organization in Palestine.
Under the system of departments, gradually strengthened and perfected, the activities of the Commission will be continuous, even though individual members of the Commission are replaced from time to time by others; there will be permanence of the work, though not in the composition of the Commission, in a manner similar to the activity of the Departments of the United States Government, even though the members of the Cabinet are changed from time to time. The political relations of the Commission brought conviction to the Commission that its central office should
be in Jerusalem. The change was made in spite of serious objections on the part of the prominent persons in Jaffa who feared that the Commission would be "swallowed up" by the local affairs of Jerusalem. Several members remained in Jaffa and close relations were maintained with Jaffa. Comfortable quarters were obtained in the "Mizrad" Building in Jerusalem. As a consequence, the change proved very satisfactory and all objections that had been raised proved to be groundless. The question of establishing proper relations with Palestinian Jewry was considered seriously by the Commission, and in his opening address to the Vaad Hazmani (a committee representing the various parties and groups of Palestine Jewry) the writer, as acting chairman of the Commission, invited the Vaad to meet with the Commission every two weeks (or oftener if necessary) to discuss the questions of the hour and take counsel together. These meetings proved very helpful to the Commission. But they did not satisfy the Vaad Hazmani, which felt that it should have a determining voice in the acts of the Commission. Efforts on the part of the Commission to obtain the aid of the Vaad Hazmani in the appointment of active advisory committees for the different departments failed for the same reason that the Commission found itself unable to divide the responsibilities placed upon it by the Zionist Organization with any but those appointed by the Organization. The writer is convinced that this attitude of the Vaad is mistaken. He agrees with the Vaad that active co-operation is essential and that the participation of Palestinians in the work of the Commission is valuable and necessary. But he is also convinced that nothing would lead so surely to proper co-operation as the services rendered by advisory committees, as suggested. The isolation of Palestine Jewry during the long years of the war, their sufferings and anxieties, have led to a reaction following the occupation —a reaction which has expressed itself in excessive political discussion and polemics, in excessive political division and in stressing political "principles." One of these "principles" is that of "representation." The writer has pointed out that the American dictum, "No taxation without representation," is transformed in Palestine into "Representation without taxation." The Commission will require men of ability in various directions and must secure these men where they can be found,—if in Palestine, so much the