The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 10 · December 1919
308printed page
scan 10 of 82

The Maccabaean

Those countries have a rich soil, a fixed tradition, scientific institutions and a regular staff of instructors are all in process of formation.

The little knowledge which we acquired was sufficient for us as long as we did things on a small scale and as long as our unit was the dunam and the brush. But when we commence to do things on a large scale, when our unit becomes the square mile and the Frcs. 10,000, what will be the use to us of this handful of experiments? We have for instance three kinds of almonds which we have tested, and even in regard to these there were a hundred different opinions, whereas in Italy there are dozens of kinds of almonds. As long as our area was limited there was no harm in this, but if we commence to work on an extensive area, then the restriction of our plantings to isolate species will not merely ruin individual settlement but will jeopardize the picture of the whole country. There were days in the plantation settlements in Judea when the question of wholesale uprooting was most seriously deliberated, the records of the winepress in Rishon contain whole chapters on this subject. Vineyards were uprooted because there was no market for wine. If merely a few thousand dunam were uprooted there was no great harm done. But if hundreds of thousands dunam were to be uprooted the country would be shaken to its foundations.

A good year and a bad year in Palestine in regard to almonds do not depend only upon the success of the crop itself but also to a large extent upon the foreign markets. Some years were good because the cold weather in Italy spoiled the almonds there. It is all very well for individual settlements to live on accidents like this, but a country must live on its own success, not on the failures of other countries. And the state of things is the same in whichever direction we turn.

Rich and fertile soil, numerous kinds of products, numerous branches of farming, skilled agricultural laborers, scientific experts and competent instructors, ground fit for the workers and workers fit for the ground. These are the links out of which the chain of national prosperity must be forged; if one link is missing everything will relapse into the old groove; the old will be undermined, and the new will make no progress.

We Jews could not at the present moment raise the prices of agricultural produce to a higher level, not even if there were millions of us in the country; but we can extract from the soil four and five times as much as the Fellah, and from a dunam we can obtain ten times as much income. And when the European settlement with its peculiar requirements increases, we shall be able to fix our own prices for certain products in conformity with the needs of the Jewish workers.

It is experimental stations which must pave the way for us. It is in them that the first commencements must be made, since without them we shall be helpless and shall not know how and with what to begin. We require a new agricultural tradition adapted to our capabilities, to our nature and to the future in store for us. Not all the modern implements which we introduce with the European tradition are adapted to the nature of the country, while the existing tradition does not conform either to our nature or to the modern implements which to us are indispensable. Usually a tradition is the fruit of hundreds of years of experiment, but with the aid of science and technical instruments it can be created in a comparatively short period.

Our scientific institutions with their acclimatization garden, zootechnical institutes for cattle and birds, nurseries for plants and trees, and the hygienic institutes to combat cattle disease—these institutions have not the same task with us as in other countries. There, their task is to promote growth and vegetation, to increase existing possessions, and to alleviate the hardships of existence. With us they have to create the very germ of development, to make acquisition possible, to prepare the ground for the worker and the worker for the ground, and to establish suitable conditions for both. As long as the settlement goes on at a slow pace, one place can learn from the mistakes of another. But a national settlement, created practically in one effort is in danger of being ruined at the very outset, if these experiments are made on its "corpus vile," and not by means of institutions specially formed for the purpose, which can direct in the right path.

For thirty years we have been engaged in the work of settlement, and the land is still unexplored. Even the old settlement with its unambitious programme cannot continue any longer in the old track. Needless to say, therefore, that a settlement on a large scale which is to be self-supporting cannot be built up without preliminary investigations and without a knowledge of all the sources of livelihood which are stored up in the earth—accurate knowledge based upon reliable investigation and not upon conjecture and guesswork. Even a house nowadays is not built without a plan and without exact measurements. Yet we are attempting to build up a country without such precise measurements, without agronomical and topographical maps, and without knowledge of the water resources. Only on the basis of this data can economic independence be attained; and without exact maps the agricultural conquest of a country is just as impossible as the military conquest.

Palestine is not a level country, but a country of hills and dales. In the same way the Jewish nature is not a uniform one, but is full of varieties and undulations. The country is divided into zones, each one of which is adapted for one branch of produce but not for another. In the same way the Jewish people are divided into different classes each one of which is fitted to develop one branch and not another. These are fundamental facts which must not be ignored. We can as little reduce our people to a uniform type as we can make the country all of one level. It is of course possible to increase the area of cultivation by piling up dust on the flat roof of the houses and creating “garden cities” at a height of two stories. But this is not the way to achieve economic independence, and the creative power of the people cannot be increased by artificial means like these. A populous settlement cannot be built up unless both the treasures of nature and the energies of the people are turned to the very best possible account.

Only by adapting ourselves to the natural zones of the country and by placing every plant and worker in the zone for which they are best fitted can we extract from the ground the very best which it has to give and from the worker the best which he can perform. Only thus can we create the sound economic system which will give us a large and self-supporting population. If, however, we disregard the natural boundaries and sow where we ought to plant and plant where we ought to sow, then we shall have bad crops instead of good plantations and vice versa, and not only will the population not increase but the numbers which we have will dwindle. The boundaries of these zones must be estab-