The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 9 · September 1919
292printed page
scan 38 of 44
Facsimile · scan 38 of 44
Scan of p. 292
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

as the rest. To win a marriage portion he pretends to be a Zionist—his father-in-law, an ardent Zionist, is the only gentleman in the book. He becomes an employer, grinds the faces of his employees, stoops to trickery, towards the end forgets his faithful wife and makes love to a chance acquaintance on a steamer crossing the Atlantic. By a failure of his plans he is ruined, and only then realizes the goodness and love of his wife.

To be sure, Miss Lowe tries to portray Saul as one with a hunger for beauty, a creator of lovely things in women's garments, a yearning soul. But the reader will be inclined to agree with the artist who has prepared the jacket to the book, in which Saul is shown as an unattractive young person with a retreating forehead.

If anyone wants to realize how completely Miss Lowe has failed to understand the tragedy of the garment operator's life, let him read her book and then turn to the poems of Morris Rosenfeld on the same subject. The only trouble will be that after reading Rosenfeld he will despise this Saul more than ever for hard-heartedness and callousness.

Fictitious Jewish Fiction

Under the Sabbath Lamp. By ABRAM S. ISAACS.Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society ofAmerica.

A BOOK which is sub-titled "Stories of our Time for Old and Young," and published by the Jewish Publication Society, will immediately arrest the attention of many Jews, Zionists especially, who are interested in English literature dealing with contemporary Jewish life. Goodness knows that the artistic interpretation of this life by means of fiction has been sadly lacking both in quantity and quality. We have, of course, always been impatient with that type of Jewish-English fiction which regards Jewish life as an exotic curiosity, as a source of burlesque entertainment. We are also repelled by the other class of English-Jewish fiction, which is patronizingly maudlin and utterly untrue. And what with the fact that the Jewish Publication Society has steered clear of fiction dealing with contemporary Jewish life; what with the fact that the Jewish Publication Society has dealt mainly with Jewish archaeology, so to speak; what with the fact that its attitude towards Jewish life has been that of a Sunday school teacher in a Reform Temple, the appearance of a book, titled as above stated, is bound to arouse pleasant hopes and expectations.

But these hopes and expectations, sad to relate, are dashed to the ground. Reading

these stories which purport to deal with Jewish life, one is positively seized with a sense of despair —despair of ever obtaining from the Jewish Publication Society anything which faces the facts of Jewish life honestly and courageously. The atmosphere which breathes from this book is the atmosphere of an arid sermon in a Reform Temple. The characters are all benevolent, charming and so amiable! The things that happen are all so very perfectly lovely. And if there should be something regrettable it moves in the deep background and is not permitted to ruffle our complacent and self-righteous Sabbath calm. The people are all so well provided with the comforts of life, and when the poor and unfortunate are sometimes introduced, it is clear that they have been conveniently brought into existence by an all-wise Providence in order to afford an opportunity for the charming exercise of the touching virtues of the amiable nincompoops who move through these stories.

Not a single one of the characters has any life or reality. In one of the stories, "The Trendelé," a certain youth is beginning to interest you. He is mischievous and clever, and the Rabbi's daughter is smitten with him. Then follow these sentences, and you naturally lose all interest in the poor young man.

“Now, if his heart had contained a single atom of malice, the student would not have been so universal a favorite. Had he been petty, selfish, covetous, lying, the maidens of K— would never have bowed so gracefully to him, and the eyes of the Rabbi’s daughter would never have sparkled so brightly when he passed.”

That young man, it appears, had virtue enough to cram every Reform Sunday school with holiness and the Rabbi's daughter was in love with his virtue.

If an Eskimo should read this book on contemporary Jewish life, he would come to the conclusion that the Jewish social complex consists first and foremost, of wonderfully virtuous and wise Rabbis; second, of plump, beautiful and charming Rabbis' wives; third, of beautiful Rabbis' daughters; fourth, of exemplary young men who have been brought into the world for the purpose of marrying the Rabbis' daughters; and fifth, of the children of the members of the reform congregations who are beautiful, charming and entirely given over to deeds of benevolence.

And this is the interpretation which the Jewish Publication Society gives us of the grim and glorious drama of contemporary Jewish life! R. L.

History of the Lewis

A History of the Jews. BY PAUL GOODMAN,New York & P Dunton & Co pp 164

AIMING to impress on the public the reliability of the book, the publishers paraphrase a passage in the preface and tell us that the author "writes from a point of view which is neither attack nor defense, and has confined himself to the marshalling and statement of facts." The book is really better than that. The author, while maintaining the attitude of impartiality that it behooves the historian to adopt, has not contented himself with performing the task of the mechanical and second-hand chronicler. To him events have relations that gives them meaning. And he evidently believes that the meaning of Israel's history has not yet been fully established by events, and that the purpose that runs through that history is still an increasing one, for the last sentence of the book reads: "But whatever the future may bring in its train, the Jewish past has shown us the remarkable morale of the world-wide people, which, without an inch of soil to call its own, without a common mother-tongue, without a secular government or even a religious hierarchy, actually participates in the shaping of world events, and manifests a vitality that goes from strength to strength."

But the fact that the history of the Jews is not yet completed is no excuse for this book not being complete. We are told on the reverse of the title-page that the volume was published in 1919, hence, on glancing over the table of contents, we are startled by the last chapter being named “The Era of Assimilation”; and when we come to read that last chapter we wonder where the writer has kept himself during the momentous five years just past. In our perplexity we go hunting for an explanation and discover that the preface was written in 1909, and pre sently we read (on page 133) that “now” means 1911. Therefore, the last chapter wants revision and the book wants an additional chapter; and we regret that the publishers did not see fit to supply these in an edition dated this year. Our quarrel is with them and not with the author. The book, as far as it goes, is an excellent one. To have covered the vast field in so satisfactory and interesting a manner within the limits of 164 pages is a creditable achievement; and to those who have not the time or the inclination to go through more voluminous works and yet who seek an intelligible survey of Jewish history, the book is to be recommended. D.K.

D. K.