The Maccabaean
The bond cannot be nationality. Let them seek it in common work. . . When Jewish workers are admitted to every factory and to the civil service, when the separate trade unions and the separate socialist workers' parties fuse, the Jewish problem will be solved in Poland.
Mr. Brailsford believes that the Jews should of course have all the rights of a minority, especially the rights to cultural autonomy, but he has little confidence that the League of Nations will enforce the obligations with respect to minorities which Poland has officially assumed. This is true, Mr. Brailsford thinks, because the league is in reality an Alliance, and no alliance ever attempted to control an ally. He finally makes a plea for the exclusion from the new Polish domain of certain territories on the east, which includes thickly populated Jewish centers, and he finishes with the following highly significant little story.
I know a town in the Pale which had lived under Tsarist Russian, German, Ukrainian, Bolshevist and Polish rule. I asked the local Jews which, from their standpoint, was the best and worst. They had nothing, as Jews, against Germans or Bolsheviki. Neither persecuted. They all agreed that Polish rule was decidedly worse than that of Tsardom. The leaders of the Ukrainians, I imagine, would have said the same thing if I could have questioned them, but they were all in prison.
The Legal and Moral Status of the Legionaires
In the Palestinean daily newspaper "Ha-arez" of July 16, 1919, a well-known Jewish Russian journalist and Zionist worker, under the pseudonym, "Altalena," discusses the present situation of the Jewish legionaries in Palestine. He considers the subject first from the legal and then from the moral point of view. He makes it clear that legally the Legionaries have volunteered to serve in the British Army until "the cessation of hostilities," and that the interpretation of this phrase is to the effect that it is equivalent to the "end of the war." In other words, the legionaries are obligated to serve until the actual signing of peace with Turkey. It is true that the British Government has already been demobilizing some of its forces in Asia, but it was not legally bound to do so and it applied this demobilization first of all, to those who had enlisted at the beginning of the war, second, to those over 36 years of age, and thirdly, to those who had been wounded more than twice. But even this procedure has not been followed out in all instances, the difficulties in the problem of demobilization being very great, and being aggravated, moreover, by the shortage of shipping facilities.
The moral considerations are even more cogent and we will let the writer speak for himself:
I am not going to touch upon the duty of the legionaries to the Jewish people or to Palestine. I speak about a fundamental ethical principle. The majority of our legionaries enlisted in 1918. It was not their fault because they were only then permitted to join the Jewish Legion. . . . At any rate, it is a fact that they enlisted last year, whereas, there are in the country thousands of English soldiers who took part in the desert campaigns and have not seen their families in England for two or three years. There are even some who belong to the year 1915, and there are hundreds of them if not thousands. They are all anxious to go home, but they are obliged to wait because the English soldiers will perceive that the Jewish legionaries, who had been here for only a year or less, and who for the most part had no share in the sacrifices which the British soldiers made for the liberation of Palestine, demand that the government give them, the new ones, a thousand or two thousand berths on the ships and thus keep out an equal number of soldiers who fought at Gaza and participated in the capture of Jerusalem—then these Englishmen will come to the conclusion that the Jewish demand is without any justice and without any feeling of human brotherhood.
Every Jewish legionary must reflect on these facts, whether he is a Zionist or not, because even if he does not wish to listen to the voice of his people and land, he must respect the right of his brother, Jew or non-Jew, who suffered and sacrificed more than he.
Jewish Labor and a Jewish Peasantry in Palestine
The London Zionist Review of August contains an illuminating statement of the Labor Problem in Palestine. The writer, who is at present in Palestine, discusses first, the failure of the colonists to employ Jewish labor despite the fact that they are being assisted by the Zionist Organization; and second, the general problem of creating a Jewish peasantry in Palestine. Concerning the first he writes:
The colonists, t0 whom we owe so much for our progress in Erez Israel, were and are helped financially to a large extent by the Zionist movement, the Jewish National Fund’s easy long-term loans being a vital factor in the development of the colonies. The J. N. F., however, has never intervened in the determination of labour conditions in the colonies it has helped to finance. This preliminary stage has now passed, and our colonies are flourishing indications of Jewish enterprise, but not entirely of Jewish labour. In two of the largest, Petach Tikvah and Rechoboth, the non-Jewish workers are a big majority. From the farmer’s point of view it is essential to employ unskilled cheap labour if he is to succeed, and the Jewish worker demands a bigger wage because of his higher standard of living. On the other hand, Hapoel Hazair urges that Palestine will only become Erez Israel through Jewish labour on the land. Thus they press for the nationalization of the land, not as a Socialistic measure, but as a national necessity, for if the colonists cannot afford to employ Jewish labour (though it prove more economical in the long run) then the Jewish people must bear the cost. Whether our farmers should sacrifice the present material position for the national future is the question at issue. Recently it was decided to place some unemployed Jews of Jerusalem in the colonies. The farmers agreed to employ them if their wages were supplemented by the Zionist Organization.
On the question of creating a Jewish peasantry in Palestine he brings forward the following considerations:
The question is thus raised: How is a Jewish peasantry, the supposed backbone of a healthy national life, to be created? Hapoel Hazair replies: Only by employing Jewish labour, which in its turn must be prepared to make sacrifices for the national future. Others have urged, however, that to attempt to create a Jewish rural proletariat is to misunderstand the Jewish nature, which constantly strives to be independent. They therefore suggest that our efforts should be directed to creating small holdings, where the farmer and his sons may work for themselves. The co-operative schemes that have been essayed are also directed towards this end. Small holdings would not, however, solve the Jewish labour problem in districts where much unskilled labour is required, as in plantations. There is to-day a large body of opinion in the Zionist world which favours the giving of as much authority and control as possible in the Jewish Palestine to the Zionist Organization, as the representative of the Jewish people, and it would appear that this question will be satisfactorily solved only by such a procedure, resulting in the restriction of private enterprise to a minimum. The ownership of large tracts of land by the Organization, adequately supported on the financial side by the Jewish people, is one solution of a problem that might provoke fruitful discussion in Zionist circles.
According to a report of the Copenhagen Zionist Bureau, the Province of Bukowina witnessed a remarkable Zionist ferment after the dissolution of the Austro-Hungarian Empire in November, 1918, and the occupation of this Province by Rumania. Owing to the administrative regulations which the Rumanians introduced, no authentic news could reach the people and in consequence the most exaggerated rumors concerning Jewish resettlement in Palestine became current.
