The Maccabaean
tionalisms that had been held down for centuries, likely to have upon the Jewish elements encased within them? Will they, or will they not, demand that the Jew assimilate himself, completely and unreservedly, to each national culture, be it ever so crude? Will they, or will they not, repeat the old experience that nativism always deprecates the Jew as an intruder, that chauvinism always scents in him its natural enemy? Will each of these nations produce its ultra-loyal nationals of the Jewish persuasion, corresponding to our own Jewish Americans of the flamboyant variety, to be more catholic than the pope in frowning down, as disloyal, every Jewish aspiration for the maintenance of Jewish identity, for the preservation of Jewish culture?
How long will our guaranteed minority rights maintain themselves as substance, rather than shadow, as a reality of practical worth, rather than an empty pretense? Will the Polish and Roumanian paper constitutions prove themselves educational factors, will they revolutionize their people's moral viewpoints and standards, or will these nations set about, after a decent interval of respectful hesitation, to circumvent and annul them by the many expedients which are subject neither to the control of statutory law nor to penalties from a supervisory League of Nations?
They have before them abundant precedents of illiberal liberals, of unsocial socialists who knew how to place the Jew upon an exceptional plane, where principles of justice and equality failed of application to him. They have heard of the annulment of civic equality in the realms of appointment, "auf Administrationswege"; they cannot be supposed to dragoon courts and juries into unprejudiced decisions; they cannot so censor platform and stage, press and school as to stifle expressions of prejudice. With the best of will they would be helpless in the face either of economic boycott or social ostracism, if these had public opinion and aroused public feeling on their side.
One great problem of the near Jewish future may be the attempt at a mass-migration. The war has uprooted uncounted Jewish homes, entire Jewish communities; such ties of cradleland attachment and livelihood advantage as bound many people to their homes have been loosened considerably. While a great majority will be constrained to remain by the lack of means and strength, many others will make any sacrifice to leave the countries where their patriotism has met with scant appreciation; the young and strong especially will feel impelled to look for pastures new. What part of the world will open its doors to these people? May they not constitute a particular danger or embarrassment to the delicate and arduous tasks of foundation-laying and pioneering in the national homeland?
There are other dangers in the train of the intolerable and interminable chain of wrongs of which the Eastern Jew has been a victim at a time when he had hoped for the blessings of peace. Among the many sensational reports of the last few weeks whose extravagance was difficult to credit and which, yet, in a time of so many wild vagaries, one could not confidently reject, was one to the effect that as many as sixty thousand Hungarian Jews had embraced Christianity, to escape the odium of their race. The report may and, again, may not be true; but that all these disorders and violences are bound to lead to much moral disintegration, especially among those of the highly assimilated whose hold upon Jewish faith and Jewish brotherhood was feeble at best, who shall question? Nor, at the other end, is it in the least unlikely that the same factors of bottomless destitution which, in Eastern lands, have led, not infrequently, to the
lowest abysses of moral degeneracy will operate in the same direction under the still deeper depths of poverty and wretchedness to which our Eastern masses have now been reduced.
However justly we might rejoice over the happy fact that at last the representatives of the great Jewish communities have succeeded in meeting a great emergency in the spirit of harmony and co-operation, we must not forget that differences have only been compromised, not put aside. Today, as ever, the Jewish world, especially that part of it which has entered into modern civilization, continues divided between the assimilationists and the nationalists. Between the two there is gradually forming a middle-of-the-road party which, guided by practical considerations, largely of philanthropy, partly of Jewish sentiment, consents, more or less passively, to the creation of the national homeland; but the antagonism maintains its keenness with regard to those national rights of the Jews in the half-civilized European East without which their minority rights would soon lose all substance. We are told, even now, by those who cannot appreciate the world-wide difference between American atmosphere and Polish atmosphere that the Polish Jew must be content to merge his Jewish identity in his Polish citizenship; as if the decades of Jewish experience with Polish unfairness had had no lesson of any value to teach!
Even such unity of action as has now been reached between the great Jewish communities, and as is likely to continue, at least with regard to philanthropic emergency work, is not without its dangers to the constructive statesmanship which will be called for by our immediate future. One such danger consists just in those stupendous demands for relief which are bound to grow, on the one hand, out of the appalling situation, on the other hand, out of the gratifying success of the great war-relief drives of our country. If a mere stop-gap charity, contenting itself with the bare first-aid of food and clothing, is to be our method of coping with this gigantic problem, we shall have neglected a great opportunity for permanent upbuilding. Possibly it may be at the very time when our resources ought to be devoted to the task of laying a strong foundation for the homeland that we may dissipate our energies on futile attempts at rehabilitating our impoverished brothers where they can never live at peace.
Nor can the Zionist regard without a measure of apprehension and distrust the project of a Jewish World-Congress, no matter under what friendly auspices such an assembly may come into being. Its formation may not come to pass in the near future; yet, again, there are no insuperable difficulties in the way of its materialization in the next few years. A World-Congress may exercise an imposing authority in directions which may materially interfere with the rise of the Jewish commonwealth, with the plans and objects that have been nurtured by the Zionists at the cost of so many sacrifices.
It is time for the uniting of resources, but not for the compromise of principle, for co-operation towards immediate ends, but, at the same time, for a steady envisagement of more distant and abiding aims. The next few decades cannot but be a critical period in Jewish history; they will largely determine the nature and the scope of our contribution to the reborn world. They will abound with opportunities, with wide vistas and open doors; but they will also be fraught with heavy responsibilities, with perplexities and complications of every kind.
