The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 9 · September 1919
263printed page
scan 13 of 44

The Maccabaean

earnings instead of separating the two; if he is a wage earner the rent will be deducted in his contract of employment— probably without his knowing it. But the difference between earnings as the share of producers, and rent as the price of permission to use monopolized natural opportunities for production, is essentially the same in all indnstrial relatinnchine.

Beneficence of the Law of Rent

One’s first impression upon grasping the principle of rent may be that it is a shrewd “capitalistic device” for diverting products from producers to labor exploiters. That is indeed the way in which it operates when social institutions recognize abuses of land ownership as legitimate. But the law of rent is no such device. It is a beneficent natural law for distinguishing individual earnings from social earnings. When not perverted, it tends to enrich both individual producers and society as a whole, with every advance in productive power.

ne Feed ee dee His realization of that characteristic of the law of rent is what revived Henry George’s dead faith in a beneficent Creator. He saw that under the normal operation of that law material progress would augment the incomes of individual producers as absolute quantities even though reduc“ing them as proportions, while augmenting the income of society both absolutely and proportionally. For illustration: Suppose that any number of individuals are producing 20 units each, of which each retains 15 units as earnings and turns over for common purposes, under the normal operation of the law of rent, 5 units as rent for the natural resources he uses; suppose then that a labor-saving device is introduced by means of which, without any increased exertion or with even less exertion, the production of each individual is increased to 30 units; suppose also that under the normal operation of the law of rent each producer now retains 18 units instead of 15 as earnings, turning over as rent for social purposes 12 units instead of 5. In those circumstances material progress would have increased their respective shares as producers from 15 to 18, which, though a proportional increase of only 20 per cent, would be an absolute or actual enrichment of 3 units; at the same time the same material progress would have increased the share devoted to common uses (rent) from 5 units to 12 for each producer—a proportional increase of 140 per cent and an absolute increase of 7 units. In other terms, the results of advances in productive power, distributed by the normal operation of the law of rent, would go in increasing proportion as well as quantity to the common uses of producers as a whole, and in diminishing proportion but increasing quantity to individual producers.

The principle thus illustrated would constantly tend— improvements in the arts, increase of population and advances in general refinement continuing to make further and further demands upon natural resources—to enlarge social income for common uses in greater and greater proportion while substantially increasing the actual incomes of individual producers. Society would thus be able to do more and more for the improvement and comfort of all its members, and each individual would be able to do more and more for his own comfort and improvement. Poverty would no longer accompany progress.

There is, therefore, in the natural law of rent convincing evidence of an intelligence in the universe, which recognizes individual and social solidarity in human nature, each with a sphere of its own, and provides wisely and beneficently

for both. At any rate, Henry George found in this law of social progress that convincing proof of beneficent design of which other evidences had been to him unconvincing. For here he grasped a natural law which in its normal operations would stimulate individual faculties and reward the individual equitably according to his degree of usefulness, while providing for society a fund no part of which anyone could reasonably claim as his very own, but which would increasingly serve the social needs of all. He realized that in the normal operation of this beneficent natural law, “society would approach the ideal of Jeffersonian democracy, the promised land of Herbert Spencer, the abolition of government, but of government only as a directing and repressive power”; and that “at the same time and in the same degree . ... we should reach the ideal of the socialist, but not through government repression,” for “a government would change its character and would become the administration of a great co-operative society .. . the agency by which the common property was administered for the common benefit,” while individual property was left tö individual administration and eniovment.

It was to that natural law that George referred in the free trade and socialism chapter of his "Protection or Free Trade," where he said in a note: "I neither claim nor repudiate the name" of socialist; "and, realizing as I do the correlative truth of both principles, can no more call myself an individualist or a socialist than one who considers the forces by which the planets are held to their orbits could call himself a centrifugalist or a centripetalist."

Natural Law in the Social World

There have been social scientists who denied natural law in the social world, who limited the reign of natural law to the realm of physics. But surely no real scientist at this day holds to that discredited fad of German “kultur.” Man seeks the line of least resistance as persistently as the rifle-bullet does. It is his nature to. He acts according to a natural law, a law of human nature. And out of this human characteristic of the individual spring all the economic phenomena of human association. One of those phenomena is the law of rent. Using it, society prospers; permitting its abuse, society suffers.

Can one possibly reflect upon social phenomena without realizing that social life is governed no less by characteristics of human nature than by characteristics of physical nature and animal nature? With the one as with the other, like causes tend uniformly to produce like effects. No more true can it be that a column will tend to fall if it loses its center of gravity, than that social tendencies are generated by laws of human nature.

That physical hunger stimulates the will to apply intellectual and physical facilities to external objects in order to procure food is a law of all animal nature, human nature included. It is a natural law of the human animal. But man is more than an animal, and the boundaries of natural law do not end at the outer edges of his nature, leaving the interior areas lawless. In all the realm of human nature, social as well as physical, natural laws must hold sway.

It would not be reasonable to suppose that man’s social life is haphazard, while natural law reigns below that level all the way down to crystals. To reflect rationally upon the history of human experience is to infer that natural laws

(Continued on page 293)