The Maccabaean
But by permitting owners of natural resources to own also their respective differential values, we generate and foster speculation in land. There is thus an incentive to extend the area of unproductive ownership of natural resources, which reduces the supply in advance of demand for use. Consequently, when the demand for use comes, it faces speculative prices so high as to menace the possibilities of profitable use.
Nor is land speculation limited to market places or to groups of land gamblers. “We all do it.” Let any of us have a title to natural resources—a building lot, a farm, a hillside plot in a mineral region, no matter what—and we hold to it with a death grip. Why? Because we hope that the lot may be boomed by the city’s growth, or the farm may be taken over for building lots, or be brought nearer to market.by a new railway or a better highway, or that minerals may be uncovered near by, or that something else may happen to enable us to exact, through commercial channels, a choice share of labor products which we do not earn but get in exchange for mere permission, to fellow voyagers on this “good ship Earth,” to build or till or mine or otherwise utilize that little domain of ours. Others get rich by thus exacting tribute, and why not we?
If the tribute were all, the system would be bad enough. It means that huge shares in the products of human industry are diverted from industrial to parasitical interests, from persons who produce to persons who permit them to produce. But the tribute is comparatively a trifle. Beyond the tribute is the fact that much needed natural resources are kept out of use because industrial interests cannot afford the exorbitant tribute which speculation in future values exacts. This tribute is exorbitant because calculated not upon what the needed natural resource will yield now, but upon what it may be expected to yield when industry shall have been driven to natural resources of lower productiveness, or invention and population shall have brought out new capabilities in old places. The tribute demanded discounts the future.
Cities again offer illustrative facts.
The present normal value of a city lot would afford a certain tribute to its monopolizer for permission to use it. He refuses permission on those terms, because he observes that the city is growing so as probably to enable him to exact a higher tribute a few years hence. He therefore exacts the higher tribute now. If the user submits, he carries an unprofitable and possibly a bankrupting load; if he does not submit, the building lot remains out of use. It may pass from one speculator to another, gathering speculative value as it goes, and thereby adding to the value of lots in use until industry can no longer bear the load and the land-value bubble bursts.
What is thus true of building lots, is true of all other natural resources. Speculation in natural resources, with their tendency to rise in value as population increases and improvement goes on, is a universal evil. The traceable results of this simple but effective robber of industry and check upon production are appalling. As a string bound tightly around a finger will disease the whole physical body if left there, so this natural-resource ligature diseases the whole social body.
To those evils every social benefit contributes.
The fact that social benefits have a tendency to increase the values of the natural resources which they bring into the field of use or of greater use, is a business commonplace.
The intelligent business man knows it and the unintelligent one feels it. Both realize that the discovery and opening of a mineral deposit give to its site a land value it did not have. They realize that the settlement and improvement of an agricultural area give to that area a land value which it did not have. They realize that building operations in a city add to the land value of its location. They realize that better roads, better streets, railway extensions, improved transit in cities, larger populations, all add to the value of the natural resources which have consequently come into greater demand. They also realize that wherever such progress is manifest or even probable, an expectation of still higher values of the natural resources it needs or otherwise affects, is a reasonable expectation. And because they realize those things they join the army of speculators in the future values of natural resources, thereby contributing to the arbitrary lessening of the supply and the consequent robbing of producers and check upon production.
The extent to which this speculation has lessened the supply of natural resources in the United States may be somewhat appreciated if we consider that with a population of hardly more than 100,000,000—less than seven families to the square mile, cities included—the United States is already crowded to the point of industrial suffocation.
The Fiscal Remedy
Since differential values of natural resources result from a natural social law, and since its perversion through making those values proprietary is the cause of the evils of land speculation, the remedy is obvious. It is to turn the annual differential values of natural resources into the common treasury.
This would be just, because the natural resources to which such values attach are a common heritage and the values themselves are expressions of social activities. It would be practicable, because such values are easily and fairly assessable, and could be collected through existing mechanisms of taxation. It would speed up production by relieving industry of taxation. And by taking away all incentive to land speculation—for the forestaller of natural resources could hope for no profit if the public treasury took over land values—it would still further speed up production by freeing the necessary natural opportunities.
The Zionist purpose of ownership of all the natural resources of Palestine by all the people is one way of abolishing land speculation. Its purpose of so framing its fiscal policy as to protect the people from the evils of land speculation is another.
The two purposes might well be made to co-operate to the general good. Through ownership by the whole people of such natural resources as mineral deposits and forest areas, common rights could be secured. Through annual taxation, a reasonable percentage of the values of private ownership of such natural resources as farms and home sites, coupled with exemption of all improvements, the same security of common rights could be achieved. In all probability land value taxation alone, improvements and operation being exempt, would achieve the desired result with reference to all kinds of natural resources.
This fiscal proposal is the one to which Henry George gave vogue some forty years ago, and which since then has progressively increased its hold upon the thought of conservatively progressive people everywhere. Its essential
(Concluded on page 244)