The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 8 · August 1919
218printed page
scan 4 of 40
Facsimile · scan 4 of 40
Scan of p. 218
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

building lots is afforded by the site of New York City. That area is officially reported to be worth twice as much as all the buildings within its boundaries. Some of its most costly buildings, structures rising tower-like to the sky with foundations sunk deep down in the rock, have less value than the few feet of earth and air they occupy. This example illustrates the general principle that building sites have market values in highest degree where populations are large, where business activities are concentrated and vigorous, and where the comforts and enjoyments of life which the whole world offers are most accessible. In such places inherent qualities are almost negligible as a value factor. Let there be solid bottom somewhere below the surface, and whether the surface be swamp or rock makes comparatively little difference. It is location that counts.

But location is relative. If we compare the natural resources for building sites in New York City with one another, and with natural resources equally good or even better for that purpose as to their inherent qualities but situated in smaller cities, or in towns or villages or hamlets, or out on the open prairie, in primeval forests or on inaccessible mountain sides, we shall see that location is not only a highly influential factor in determining the value of building lots, but that the consequent values differ amazingly.

In money terms they differ in a sliding scale from $15,000,000 or more an acre in New York City all the way down to two or three dollars or less an acre in sparsely settled places. In terms of labor, those differential values of natural resources rise all the way per acre from one man's work for one day at very low wages, to 5,000 men's work for a year at very high wages.

What is thus true of natural resources for building sites, is true for like reasons of natural resources for every other purpose.

Prodigious market values go with ownership of mineral deposits. In varying degree values go with ownership of highway concessions, water fronts, water power, timber tracts and agricultural areas. And as to every kind the prime factors which differentiate values are inherent quality for one thing and convenience of location for another.

The value of a mining site depends upon the inherent richness of the mineral deposit modified by cost of transportation. The value of an agricultural tract depends upon its natural fertility modified by cost of marketing. The value of building sites depends but slightly upon anything but proximity to centers of business and social life.

With building sites, therefore, location is the principal factor of value; with mining sites, especially of the less bulky minerals relatively to their values when extracted, the principal factor of value is richness of the deposit; with agricultural areas both natural fertility and convenient location combine to determine value. With each of the three, however, and with every other natural resource as well, its differential value springs out of its relative usefulness and scarcity.

Of course the dependence of differential values upon relative usefulness and scarcity is not peculiar to natural resources. It is characteristic also of artificial resources.

But there is a difference of great import between the effect of demand for artificial resources and of demand for natural resources. Demand for artificial resources tends to decrease their scarcity by stimulating their production and thereby to diminish their value. But demand for natural resources operates in the other direction. It tends to in-

crease their scarcity and thereby to increase their value.

This difference is a simple matter of common observation. Everybody knows it if he observes business phenomena at all.

Is it not true that increased demand for artificial products—for houses, machinery and the like—stimulates their production? And does not this stimulation increase the supply and tend to an equilibrium of value at the level of production cost? And then, item for item and quality for quality, does not the value of products tend to be less than before?

On the other hand, is it not clear that increased demand for natural resources cannot stimulate their production? Their supply being limited by nature, they are not producible. All that increased demand for natural resources does or can do which at all resembles stimulating production, is to stimulate extension of use. It tends to bring into the field of use such unused natural resources as are inherently poorer than the poorest in use, or such as are less known or not known at all, or such as are less accessible than the least accessible in use.

This extension of use increases instead of diminishing the values of natural resources. Those that had no value because not in demand take on some value in response to an extension of demand. Concurrently, those that were in demand and continue in demand, take on additional value because they continue to be more desirable than the inferior locations to which demand has extended. It is to be considered also that while extension of production of artificial resources tends to lessen their value by increasing the supply, it contributes to extension of use of natural resources and so tends to increase their value by lessening the supply.

Ample material for study of those phenomena—as intensive a study as you please—may be found in the experience of the United States. Whereas artificial resources have increased in supply, and—item for item, quality for quality—have diminished miraculously in value since the foundation of our government, our natural resources have diminished in supply, and—item for item, quality for quality—have increased enormously in value. By value, it is not money but labor that is taken for the measure—money fluctuates.

The whole range of value phenomena with reference to natural resources is exhibited microscopically in the history of city-lot values. As a city grows, new areas come within the building zone; and as they come, former acreage values turn into front-foot values while former front-foot values rise. It is the same as to natural resources of every kind and everywhere.

Speculative Land Values

Those differential land values, those varying values of natural resources, fall within a law of human association as natural as the law of gravitation in physics. It is a beneficent law, too, as we are slowly learning that all natural laws are; for it offers a gauge for securing equal rights for each in the use of the natural resources of all. If some are driven from superior natural resources because those of that grade are all in use, the difference would be equalized if the excluded ones were compensated according to differential land values. In those circumstances the people as a whole would be enriched by the normal values of their natural resources. What is more, the values of natural resources would not be inflated. They would represent only the differences in usefulness between highly desirable natural resources and the less desirable down to the least.