The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 7 · July 1919
86printed page
scan 7 of 36
Facsimile · scan 7 of 36
Scan of p. 86
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

letter announcing this as the policy of the British Government is the preamble of the charter of Jewish nationhood in Palestine. We shall see presently what the precise significance of the promise then made by Mr. Balfour was; but apart from these reasons for Jewish preference for Great Britain as the mandatory for Palestine, there are political reasons of great weight. Great Britain understands the meaning of the mandatory system. The quarrel which lost us English our first empire in America taught us a great deal, and the second empire built up to replace the first embodies the lessons made in America. Chief amongst them is the truth that no country should be the appanage of another, and that the highest duty of a protecting state is to make a nation of its ward and to bring out its individuality to the fullest. The practice of that lesson is the cement that binds the British Commonwealth of nations and the moment it ceases to be true that the better Canadian or Australian a man is, the better subject he is of the British Empire, that Empire loses its characteristic savour and its political union its justification. It is precisely that characteristic of the British Empire that makes membership of it so attractive to those like the Jews who want to found a nation of their own and not to sink their individuality in that of the protecting state. Others than Great Britain would make equally loyal protectors, but only Great Britain has the secret of preserving unity by the fullest development of the different nationalities within the union. The theory of the British Commonwealth is in fact the mandatory theory of the League of Nations.

The second consideration in the choice of a mandatory is its "resources." Of the resources of Great Britain, the best proof is the fact that she has borne the chief burden of the war against Turkey. Russia before her breakdown did great service by her campaigns in the Caucasus and Armenia, but it was the British army that broke the back of Turkey's resistance.

Nor was the part of the British army in the war with Turkey a selfish one. The Dardanelles campaign, in some ways the most glorious if the most disastrous of British overseas expeditions, was fought not for our own political ends, but under an agreement that would have handed over their possession to Russia. And the final campaign in Palestine, perhaps the most brilliant of the war, was not begun with any designs of conquest but grew out of the Turkish invasion of Egypt. There can be no question of the resources of a country which carried to success the campaigns in Palestine and Mesopotamia, while at the same time playing an equal part on the battlefields of France. Moreover, the adequate defence of Palestine can only be conducted by a nation which has command of the sea.

The third qualification of a mandatory is "experience." Here Great Britain is without rival. Not only has she the long traditions of administrative experience in the East, but she possesses a Colonial civil service which is generally acknowledged to be without rival. When we come to the fourth qualification of "geographical position" the claims of Great Britain are equally indisputable. A strong and prosperous Palestine would preserve the peace of the world between the Mediterranean and the Indian frontiers, and the connection between Palestine, Mesopotamia and Egypt is so old and so intimate that a unity of policy over all this region such as one mandatory alone can ensure, is necessary to its full and harmonious development. England is already in Egypt, she will be mandatory in Mesopotamia,

and those two facts are the strongest of arguments for the same mandatory in Palestine. The history of Jewish Palestine in the days of its independence was tragic because the country lay in the track of the old rivalry between the Mesopotamian and Nile civilizations, and to make an ally of either was to secure the enmity of the other. But with England holding Egypt and acting as mandatory over the revived Arab civilization Palestine will lie within the fold of two protecting armies. Of no other mandatory than England could that be said.

Lastly, England is willing to accept the mandate. Her chief interest in the Middle East is peace. The chief weakness of her position in Egypt is that there the main artery of her imperial system—the Suez Canal—comes to the surface and is most liable to injury. Palestine would cover that artery, and for that reason if there were no others, England would be willing to accept the mandate of the League.

Two conditions may be laid down for the successful discharge of the mandate by Great Britain. The first is that Palestine should be given her natural frontiers—natural both in the military and economic sense. Under any other mandatory than England Palestine would be divided and distracted. She wants peace with the Arabs and the Arabs on their side will look to her people for assistance in the task of developing her new heritage, which is beyond her own unaided abilities. Palestine, with France as mandatory, would be at issue with the Arabs; or if the mandate were divided between England and France she would be in danger sooner or later of partition. Moreover, the most valuable part of Palestine is east of the Jordan, and there is no chance of Palestine getting her just economic frontiers there unless her mandatory is the same as that of the new Arab States. Otherwise, the international rivalries which the League of Nations wishes to exorcise would spring up again and the natural development of the country would be ruined by artificial political division. Only England can ensure the full extension of Palestine to her natural frontiers.

One more point that has a very direct bearing on the position of Great Britain as mandatory. Mr. Balfour promised Palestine to the Jews as their "national home." To promise Palestine to the Jews already in Palestine as a national home would have been to promise something that was quite meaningless. The promise was to Jews all over the world. The "community of Palestine," therefore, whose wishes have to be consulted in the choice of a mandatory is something larger than the community in Palestine; and its wishes with regard to the future cannot be ascertained by merely local inquiry as to the wishes of the population now in Palestine. The Commission, therefore, which is about to leave for Syria, though it may find plenty of room for inquiry with regard to Damascus, Aleppo and other districts of Syria, has no field of inquiry in Palestine. Its wishes are already known; the only wishes that are still to be ascertained are those of the Jews in the world outside Palestine. In becoming mandatory in Palestine, Great Britain will be the trustee for Jewish heirs, expected, but as yet unborn; and that fact must govern the trust deed which has still to be drafted. One of the first duties of a trustee is to prevent waste and to preserve the estate intact for the future heirs, who are the body of Jewish emigrants ready to come to Palestine as the conditions of the country warrant their arrival.