The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 7 · July 1919
84printed page
scan 5 of 36

The Maccabaean

without to that extent denying him a right as natural as his right to liberty and life.

Ownership

Yet there must be some kind of ownership of natural resources—some kind of tenure, holding or control—for the sake of securing the best utilization and the most generally distributed benefits of the resources which nature lavishly offers us.

Some natural resources may be utilized best and most beneficially to all as an open common. The sea is of this type. But with most natural resources the authority of some kind of ownership is necessary, in an advanced civilization, to any beneficial use at all. Farming areas and building lots are illustrative. What is really important is not that there shall be no ownership of natural resources, nor any private tenures, but that the ownership shall be by all and that private tenures shall be regulated for the benefit of all.

In earlier times this principle of common ownership with private tenure was secured to the Jews by Jubilee-year reversions. But in periods of intense specialization and world-wide industrial activity, exquisitely interrelated and furiously speeded up, such as this age in which Palestine is expected to revert to the Jewish people as their national home, the Jubilee custom is inadequate as a corrective of land monopoly. Its principle is as sound today as it was three thousand years ago. All principles are from everlasting unto everlasting. But the method is obsolete.

Some system harmonizing with the Jubilee reversions in principle, but better adapted in method to modern industrial conditions, is necessary in order to secure to all the people of Palestine a substantial equality of rights with reference to natural resources, and to each a share in the industrial output approximately in proportion to his usefulness.

Such is the system proposed by the American Zionists at Pittsburgh. Since this system would vest the ownership and control of all natural resources in the whole people, its primary tenure of natural resources would be ownership in common. But its secondary tenure would be private possession under lease “on such conditions as will insure the fullest opportunity for development and continuity of possession.” Every benefit which private ownership of natural resources gives, except what it gives to land monopolists and land speculators, would thus be preserved. Its only variation from existing systems resides in the control which under this system all the people would have over all their natural resources all the time.

That control would doubtless be improved by a progressively fairer and better administration of the natural resources of the Commonwealth, due to an advancing popular realization of the truth that while artificial resources are the individual property of the producer, his heirs and assigns, natural resources are of sacred right forever the common property of all the people. The psychological influence of that improving social consciousness would in itself be civilizing.

Concurrently, the people as owners would have equitable powers of control over occupancy for use. No occupant would be arbitrarily ejected from land which he was putting to its proper use, nor would he have any of his improvements or other artificial resources confiscated. Neither would any occupant be long left in obstructive control of natural resources which had become shifted in function from

one kind of use to a more profitable use, such as agricultural uses to mineral or urban uses. Nor would any occupant be long allowed to profit by high rentals from actual users while himself paying low rentals to the people.

Development

Yet the natural resources, whatever their kind—agricultural, silvicultural, mineral or urban—would be developed and operated under the spur of individual enterprise. A sharper spur, it would be, than if the individuals responsible for development and operation could shift their duty of development and operation while profiting by the special value of ownership or control of the natural resource, as is so notable a fact where natural resources are monopolized by individual or corporation owners. Still sharper would be the spur to beneficial use where monopolized natural resources would otherwise be barred from use by prohibitive terms imposed by monopolizers. To keep needed natural resources out of use for any but the common benefit would be impossible.

Ownership of the natural resources of the Jewish Commonwealth in Palestine by all the people with equitable leasing for use would secure the beneficial operation of every such resource for the common good. There could be no "dog in the manger" contrary to the public welfare. No parasitical interests could infest the body politic through monopolization of natural resources. As the Commonwealth flourished, all the people and not merely a favored or fortunate few would flourish with it.

Exemption from Taxation

This program would not only operate beneficially to all the inhabitants in respect of their industrial interests, but it would also relieve the Commonwealth of every necessity for taxing any of the people.

As the Commonwealth flourished, demands for access to its natural resources would increase and these demands would increase the money value of those resources. It is always so everywhere. If, then, the people as owners regulated their leases equitably, those money values would go to the whole people instead of going into private bank accounts. There would consequently be no need for taxes.

Nor would the public income from that source burden anybody. Advancing rentals paid to the people would certainly add no burden to the occupant. He would pay out of the increased value of his tenure. They would add nothing to prices paid by the consuming public, for production would cost less rather than more under those circumstances. Under this system of natural-resource tenure, then, the Jewish Commonwealth could be not only a prosperous nation, a true commonwealth—that is to say a community in which the prosperity of all is prosperity for each. It could also be a commonwealth untaxed.

Existing Rights

And the fact must not be ignored that this land tenure program makes a reservation in favor of existing rights. There is, of course, no essential equity in compensating monopolists of natural resources for loss of monopoly profits through a policy of revesting all natural resources in all the people. Equity does not require compensation in such cases. If this were not so, equal rights to natural resources would be postponed perpetually unless those rights were ransomed.

July, 1919

One Eighty-three