The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 7 · July 1919
83printed page
scan 4 of 36

The Maccabaean

Moreover, it continues to be an artificial resource until, from decay or having been worn out or abandoned, it loses its artificial utility and passes back into the reservoir of natural resources whence it came.

Still less obvious may it be that live stock is an artificial resource. But is it not clear, upon reflection, that an animal artificially adapted to human uses is as truly artificial as a machine is? Though both are natural in origin, each is artificial in its adaptation to human use.

The reasonable test as to any industrial resource is whether it is in its natural condition or not. If its natural condition has been altered in character or place by human agency so as to adapt it the better to human uses, it is incontestably an artificial resource to the extent of that alteration.

Natural Resources

Natural resources, on the other hand, owe nothing to human agency. They are in no respect from man; they are altogether for man.

It may, indeed, not be easy always to distinguish natural from artificial resources, where advanced civilization has found its way. The same cloudiness of judgment that would make agricultural clearings or coal pits seem to be natural resources because they are functionally blended with agricultural soil or with deposits of coal, is quite likely to reverse itself by making the soil and the deposits seem to be artificial resources be-

cause they are functionally blended with agricultural clearings or coal pits. But the difference between nature and art remains and the distinction must be made.

Some natural resources may be altered by human art so completely as to lose their identity as natural resources while their artificial status continues. This is the case when trees and ores are transmuted into machines. But without some such complete transmutation, natural resources never lose their identity as such even temporarily.

One Eighty-two

it rears a house upon a building site. In market value even when not in physical form, the natural soil and site of the farm are distinguishable and separable from its improvements; the natural mineral deposit from artificial mining EN TR a ee I a FR ER CN ES LING We Bee

As to primitive forests, natural streams, undeveloped mineral deposits, unimproved agricultural areas and the vacant building lots of towns and cities, the identity of natural resources is not only not lost in artificial alterations, it is not even obscured.

The Essential Difference

Between natural and artificial resources the essential difference must be clearly understood in order to appreciate the land tenure policy proposed for the Jewish homeland under the Jewish Commanwaalth.

For the Zionist program, in its demand for ownership and control by the whole people, does not include artificial resources. These resources, produced from natural resources by human art and industry, are assumed to be the rightful property of their producers or of honest purchasers from their producers.

What that program does include, and all that it includes with reference to the land of Palestine, is that the whole people of Palestine shall own and control the natural resources of that historic country. This is both wise and just. Natural resources are the sole source of artificial resources. They are

the sole source of all industrial production, the imperative condition of every human art, the absolute prerequisite and continuous support of human life. To leave them in the ownership and control of some of the people is to maintain privileges for those favored ones at the expense of the rights of the rest. It is to obstruct the production and utilization of artificial resources; it is to give to one class most of the advantages of improvement in the industrial arts; it is to condemn the disinherited to underpaid labor for life for the profit of those who own or control the common birthright. We cannot bar anyone from an equal share in the benefits which natural resources offer to all the people,

July, 1919