The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 7 · July 1919
95printed page
scan 16 of 36

The Maccabaean

Costs of Settlement

What are the costs of settlement on such a scale? To be sure, they are large, but it would be a mistake to think them extravagantly high. According to Oettinger, we have to base our calculation upon 30,000 marks per family, making due allowance for the acquisition of arable soil, the construction of house and stable, the supplying of the inventory including live stock, the cost of planting and the provisional support of each family. Whether the requisite amounts will be supplied by national or private capital, is of no consequence for our present purpose. In either case, very large investments will be necessary for the effecting of the settlement and the development of Palestine.

Let us now look into the question of cost from the following points of view. First, let us get clarity as to the expense of individual settlement, then let us estimate the cost of the total colonization. "Total colonization," within our meaning, comprises the agricultural settlement of 100,000 families. According to Dr. Ruppin's schedule, this means the immigration of at least 300,000 families, and, making allowance for the natural increase, a Jewish minimum population of at least two million souls. Finally, let us calculate what sums are needed for a beginning, viz., the settlement of about 10,000 agriculturally active families, rendering possible the immigration of another 20,000 families. In reply to the first question—the cost of individual settlement—Ruppin and Oettinger have built upon the basis of a number of economic types.

Oettinger's types comprise a farmer, with a cattle-raising and agricultural outfit of 200 to 250 dunams, and a small plantation superadded; on the basis of family labor without hired help and of a penurious standard of life, an investment is necessary of 27,000 francs; a dairy farmer with 100 dunams, 22,000 francs; a tree-planter with 60-75 non-irrigated dunams, upward of 40,000 francs; and finally a vegetable gardener needing only about 20 dunams, 13,000 or 14,000 francs; for a workman's homestead of 20 dunams non-irrigated, or 5 dunams of irrigated soil, supposed to supplement a workman's wages, 5,000 francs will be required.

Dr. Ruppin starts from somewhat different assumptions. He posits five types of agricultural investors: 1. a planter on a big scale, cultivating 70 dunams, one-half irrigated, the other half non-irrigated, or else, 200 dunams of non-irrigated soil; requisite capital: 69,000 francs. 2. a planter with 50 dunams, 20 irrigated, or else 100 dunams non-irrigated; needed capital: 36,000 to 42,000 francs. 3. a farmer owning 100 dunams, of which 30 are under cultivation, 25,000 francs. 4. a farmer with 10 dunams of irrigated and 5 dunams of non-irrigated soil, 13,000 francs. 5. a cottager eking out his income through working for others, with a tree plantation on 5 dunams of irrigated soil, 6,000 francs.

Oettinger’s and Ruppin’s types are not absolute parallels, but allowing for the difference in methods of cultivation, the budget of investments is about the same. The initial capital that is requisite ranges with Oettinger’s six types between 5,000 and 41,000 francs, with Ruppin’s five types between 6,000 and 70,000 francs. Oettinger assumes that a substantial part of the capital will be furnished by the National Fund and other institutions. The net income under this scheme for each family, after part-payments of capital and the interest thereon are taken care of, is very small, just sufficient for family maintenance, only in the most prosperous instances a little more, though the self-furnished capi-

One Ninety-four

tal, under this reckoning, yields 9-12 per cent. annually. The anticipations of Ruppin are to about the same effect, only Ruppin presupposes a much larger share of self-furnished investments and the establishment of more extensive plantations, requiring the best situated types to employ hired labor.

If each of Oettinger's types were to be settled in equal numbers, the average investment per family would be 23,000 francs; if Ruppin's, 30,000 francs. To be sure, the actual settlement will not go along the lines of such an equipoise of types.

If we base our figures upon Ruppin's scheme, 30 or 40 years will be required for the agricultural settlement of 100,000 families, the estimated investments to be as follows:

7,143 planters on a big scale, at 69,000 frs492,867,000
frs.28,571 planters, at 36,650 to 42,300 frs1,127,840,225
frs.7,143 farmers, at 25,500 frs182,146,500
frs.14,286 farmers, at 12,900 frs184,289,400
frs.42,857 cottagers, at 6,350 frs272,141,950

100,000 settlers .....2,259,285,075 frs.

After settlement of 100,000 families, an estimated 296 millions in interest and amortisations would represent the returns on credits, which puts the total of investments roughly, at 1,963,000,000 francs. This total cost of settlement, according to Ruppin, would have to be raised in the manner following:

Through the Settlers Themselves, about,1,110,000,000
frs.Through a Land-bank or the National Fund600,000,000
frs.Through Organizations in Furtherance of Colonization (Aids and Grants not secured through Mortgage)253,000,000

Ruppin’s primary requisite is the acquisition of a culti- vable area of 380,000 hectares.

Oettinger's scheme provides more room for dairy and grain-farming, figures less with the more expensive tree-planting, but requires a larger area. He postulates the necessity of an investment of 1,730—1,780 million francs for the settlement. To both Ruppin's and Oettinger's figures, however, must be added the expenditure for public institutions, such as school-farms, hygienic bureaus, agricultural colleges, etc. Requisite total in the course of a generation, about two hundred million francs. This brings the total cost of settling 100,000 agricultural families up to two billions.

Our budget for the immediate future, based upon the foregoing, will, therefore, be about as follows:

For the settlement of 10,000 agricultural families within ten years about two hundred million francs are necessary. Of this amount the National Fund or an Agrarian Bank would have to furnish at least sixty millions. The other one hundred and forty millions would have to be raised, partly by the settlers themselves, partly through organizations in furtherance of the Yishub, and partly through a national loan. To this requisite amount must be added fifty-six millions, representing the working capital of agrarian and urban banks and corporations. Finally, the first ten years will require twenty to thirty millions for the establishment of cultural and national institutions in town and country—altogether about three hundred million francs are required for the settlement of 10,000 agricultural and 20,000 non-agricultural families within a decade. The auspicious auguries of our immediate national future make the raising of such a sum perfectly practicable.

July, 1919