The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 7 · July 1919
93printed page
scan 14 of 36

The Maccabaean

every twenty-four hours for the next ten to fifteen years, since our average centers are going to be very small. As to highways and longitudinal railways the centers must first be determined. And since the building of 150-300 miles of railroad does not involve considerable time, why provide the carriers before providing for the goods which is to be carried? This matter of roads is here dwelt upon at such length in order to demonstrate the indispensability of thinking in Palestinian, and not American or English terms, when making proposals for Palestine.

Another characteristic of the laissez fairist is to make a fetich of so-called individual initiative. He is inclined to rejoice over any and every economic undertaking or project in and for Palestine without regard to its bearing upon the needs of the development of the country as a whole.

The establishment of a machine shop, for example, in Palestine will arouse his satisfaction despite the fact that. the size of the particular shop, its location and the possible scope of its operations are wholly inferior to the needs of the country as a whole for that particular undertaking as determined by a careful analysis of all the other industries directly or indirectiy related to and affected by it, and despite the fact that the existence of this inadequate undertaking will militate against the establishment of a similar undertaking in the right plase and proportions. Let it be understood that our quarrel with the laissez fairist is not on the score of his indifference to certain principles of social justice but solely because of his disregard of an efhicient economic order for the country. For, while the small and inadequate shop may pay for itself in the beginning while the larger and suitable”undertaking may suffer a deficit in the beginning, the establishment of the small shop would cause the retardation of general economic progress.

Another consideration which should serve to check the indiscriminate optimism of the laissez fairist, is involved in the fact that his estimate of the individuals or even groups of individuals who come forward with all kinds of proposals for Palestine takes too much for granted. These individual initiators who find a good field for the investment of their capital in America, for example, and who think for Palestine in terms of American conditions and their own acquired habits, frequently vanish from the scene the moment they are brought face to face with Palestinian difficulties. To them it is not a solution of a personal problem; it is only for the most part a more or less platonic interest. Individual initiators, as a matter of fact, may be impossible to find in order to build up some of the basic industries of Palestine.

The Correct Approach

The correct method of approach in formulating a policy for the economic development of Palestine lies neither in austere and deductive social righteousness nor in lack-daisical laissez fairism. It lies in a responsible analysis of all the factors involved in the various basic industries which must minister to the self-support of the Jewish Commonwealth. First we must see to it that our analysis is of Palestinian factors and not of Chicago factors. And second, our analysis must comprehend every factor involved.

Furthermore, such an analysis, in its final meaning, is not qualitative but quantitative. For while we may talk about the quality of Jewish labor, for instance, our ultimate interest in Jewish labor is in the quantity of consumable goods it is capable of producing. Now a quantitative analysis involves the use of units of measurement. But

One Ninety-two

even a unit of measurement, although it is an arbitrary thing, is also a relative thing. A square foot of ground on Wall Street does not mean the same thing as a square foot in a Jersey swamp. A pound of bread to a mujik means something quite different from what the same unit means to a middle-class American family. So that in our quantitative analysis our units must be wholly Palestinian.

In a quantitative analysis of the various factors involved in the establishment of any industry in Palestine, we have already at our command or are in a position to ascertain, all the factors involved with the exception of one. We may familiarize ourselves with the sources of raw material, of power and labor, facilities for transportation, the comparative merits of the various locations, strength of the foreign competitor and so forth. All of these factors, but still another, are needed in order to determine what shall be the tentative given output of the industry in question or its physical proportions. What is the other? In a sense it is the basic one. It is the raison d'etre of the industry. It is the consumption norm of the population. For it is to be clearly understood that our industry is established not to afford an income to capital, though that may be one of its by-products, but in order to supply the wants of our people as consumers.

The Unit of 100,000

The statement that the population factor is absent will at once be challenged. Have we not already a population in Palestine? Do we not know what its consumption norm or standard of living is? Why then is this a missing factor? The answer is: This population exists but for the sake of our safety. We must refuse to recognize it in this connection. For should we accept the consumption norm of the present population and build our industries upon it, we are laying the ground not for a Jewish Commonwealth but for a Jewish Common pauperism. Besides we must concern ourselves with the incoming population, its habits and standards. In addition, we expect the newcomers to overshadow in numbers the present population in ten to fifteen years.

A quantitative analysis of all the factors involved in establishing a given industry on the basis of the accepted units in each of these factors must result in a unit for the given industry. Since this final unit must be the outgrowth of an analysis of all the factors, it is essential that the population factor be quantitatively considered. And since this population factor is still missing, what we shall do, simply, is to assume it. In other words, we will endeavor to arrive at a unit on the basis of an arbitrary population, say a population of 100,000 souls. The choice of 100,000 souls as a unit is not as arbitrary as it looks. For in the first place a population of 100,000 is big enough to make itself self-sustaining. And in the second place that number is likely to be the unit of increment in the course of the growth of the population in general.

These considerations make it clear why the Zionist Society of Engineers and Agriculturists in their approach to an investigation of basic industries, which will have to be established in Palestine, have chosen a population of 100,000 souls as the unit for which they are planning and budgeting. Following is a statement of the plan of procedure based on these considerations as adopted by the Zionist Society of Engineers and Agriculturists:

PROBLEM OF MASS COLONIZATION IN PALESTINE

The method of Mass-Colonization in Palestine must be based upon the analysis of the essential needs of the consumption and

July, 1919