The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 6 · June 1919
45printed page
scan 6 of 40
Facsimile · scan 6 of 40
Scan of p. 45
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Jewish Question in Poland

A Reasoned Solution

By ISRAEL COHEN

Author of "Jewish Life in Modern Times," Etc.

To the writer of this article fell the lot to go through the “cities of slaughter,” and witness the inhuman and cowardly murder of innocent Jews in Poland and Galicia. He went there as special commissioner of the Zionist Organization, and his first report of conditions in Poland, printed in the London “Times” of February 8 and subsequently in the daily press of this country, aroused the indignation of the whole of the civilized world against the savagery and ruthlessness of the Poles. Through his investigations the wall of silence which had been built around Polish atrocities by the British as well as the American press was broken through. Mr. Israel Cohen is better able, we believe, than any other individual to speak authoritatively on the Jewish question in Poland. In the following article he treats the subject dispassionately and with unexampled calmness.—THE EDITOR.

HE Supreme Council of the Peace Conference has been T engaged for the last few months, among its multifari“" ous tasks, in devising conditions calculated to assure the development of a happy and prosperous Poland. This consummation, which is devoutly to be wished, cannot be achieved unless, in addition to the establishment of friendly relations between Poland and all her neighbors, there is also a feeling of amity among the different sections of her population. External harmony with internal discord affords an insuflicient basis for the success of the new republic, and the labors of the Peace Conference will prove to be vain if the aid of the League of Nations has afterwards to be invoked to compose domestic disputes. The most serious internal problem is that constituted by the Jews, who, since the proclamation of the independence of Poland, have been the victims of pogroms and other outrages in various parts of Congress Poland and Galicia. This orgy of persecution, committed by those who have just liberated themselves from a century-old oppression, has naturally aroused universal condemnation, which, it is hoped, will produce its proper effect upon the Polish Government and people. But a continuance of protests can hardly serve as an effective means of improving the position of the Jews: a more constructive policy must be devised and applied, especially as the healing that Zionism will bring on its wings will only gradually be accessible to large numbers. The Polish Government has steadily grasped this elementary truth, and the Polish Parliament has appointed a special commission of nineteen members, including four Jews, to study the Jewish question and make recommendations. There are also Jewish Delegations now in Paris from England and America, and from Poland itself, who are working for a satisfactory solution of the question.

It might be urged that as the Jews in Poland have been granted civil equality, there cannot be any Jewish question in that country. But the events of the last few months have shown that this equality, which does not include immunity from racial hostility, scarcely meets the needs of the situation. Anybody who visits Poland today cannot help observing the antagonism against the Jews that prevails in all classes of society and in nearly all sections of the press. This condition is in striking contrast with the friendly treatment accorded to the Jews in Poland when it was an independent State, and when, for nearly two hundred years, they enjoyed a form of national autonomy and were able to foster all phases of their traditional life. Their gratitude to Poland was manifested by their participation in the Kosciuszko insurrection in 1794, when they flocked to the banner of ihe Jewish hero Berek Josselowicz, and also in the revolt of 1863, when much Jewish blood was shed on the battlefield.

The relations between Jews and Poles continued tolerable until about twenty years ago, when an active anti-Semitic policy was initiated and propagated by the political leaders, notably M. Roman Dmowski, who preached the gospel of economic boycott. This change of attitude was based upon the erroneous idea that the Jews stood in the way of the acquisition of Polish independence, because they had not become assimilated to the Polish nation. It was the liberalism of independent Poland that had helped the Jews to preserve their traditional life, and this was afterwards regarded by the intolerance of oppressed Poland as an obstacle to the regaining of her freedom. That the politicians were utterly mistaken in their reading of their country’s destiny has been amply proven by the events of the last few months. Poland has secured her independence once more as a result of the triumph of the Allies, who championed the cause of the small nations and enunciated the principle of national self-determination. It therefore behooves her to allow a weaker people in her midst to enjoy, at least in a small measure, the blessing that has been conferred by the greater Powers upon herself. The independent Poland of the twentieth century should not follow in the footsteps of her Russian or Prussian oppressors, but revert to her own liberal traditions of previous centuries. The prestige of the New Poland, as the creation of a Liberal Alliance, requires this; the laws of humanity and the principles of civilization demand it.

When I discussed the question a little while ago in Warsaw with Professor Grabski, one of the intellectual leaders of the National Democratic party, he frankly admitted that he had formerly been an anti-Semite, and declared that now he was. no longer one. He said that he had been opposed to all elements which, in his opinion, weakened the Polish struggle for independence; but that now that the Poles were masters in their own country they could be hospitable and wished everybody in their midst to feel comfortable. This sentiment is echoed most sincerely by the Jews, who long to feel comfortable in their native country, whilst fully prepared to share in all the tasks of her reconstruction. But they: will not feel comfortable as long as the present policy of anti-Semitism prevails, and they are denied the right of cultivating their own traditional life. Quite apart from attacks upon persons and property I came across numerous instances of injustice towards Jews during my recent tour of investigation in Poland. I found that the economic boycott of the Jews was maintained with unabated vigor; that Poles who sold houses or property to Jews were branded as traitors; that Jews were excluded, as a rule, from Government service; that at Javorzno all the nine Jewish members of the Town Council were compelled to resign; that at Tarnow the speaking of Yiddish was forbidden; that at Cracow a