The Maccabaean
may be cited: "I might add that from my personal knowledge of the Jews of America, their support of the Zionist movement will in no way affect their whole-hearted Americanism, their allegiance, or their loyalty."
icanism, their allegiance, or their loyalty. This volume makes fascinating reading—it is from a purely impersonal standpoint almost the picture of a civilization. It is curious to note how many of these Congressmen say that they have long studied the question of Zionism—and they give proof that they really have done so. Thus Representative McKeown of Oklahoma writes: “I have studied this question for a long while, have followed up the development of the idea since the first day when the Rothschilds started colonization in Palestine. I have watched the various plans of the territorialists, but I have always felt that the historic and logical place for a Jewish state is their ancient and beloved home, Palestine.” How many Jews can write on this point with as much cogency and sincerity as Mr. McKeown? Again and again it is apparent that to these men Zionism is a splendid dream, something that will justify and prove the progress of civilization. It appeals to their imagination, to their religious sentiment, to their economic and political principles.
Consisting (with few exceptions) of statements from Gentiles, the volume on the other hand is another testimony to the absolute lack of basis for the fear that many anti-Zionists ostensibly harbor—that Zionism will breed anti-Semitism. These men are more, not less, friendly to Jews because they are Zionists. Their statements show convincingly that this fear is largely psychopathic to the extent that it is sincere.
By a minor error Representative Dyer is spoken of on page 140 as Speaker of the House of Representatives, the item belonging on the previous page where Champ Clark states his adherence to the idea of Zionism. M. J. H.
Untermeyer on the New Poets
The New Era in American Poetry. By LOUIS UNTERMEYER, New York. Henry Holt & Company. pp. 364.
APPARENTLY no new poet, of whatever school, need complain nowadays as to lack of appreciation. On numerous towers throughout the land eager critics scan the countryside with vigilant and watchful telescopes, and when they descry a new poet, they lift up loud voices of jubilation.
There is Louis Untermeyer, for example. Himself a poet of considerable power and reputation, he is the most receptive and hospitable of critics, when it comes to his rivals (as one might suppose) in the field. Where Pope would have gathered his contemporaries into the inferno of the "Dunciad," or where Poe would have scarified them with biting censure, Mr. Untermeyer opens his arms wide and bids these tender fledglings whom the Muses rear today to take refuge with him, and he soothes them with tender assurances of their merits.
Such, at any rate, is the impression gathered from that volume of agile critiques, "The New Era in American Poetry," in which Mr. Untermeyer comments, at greater or less length, on about thirty poets, besides mentioning many others in briefer characterization. Here one may find Robert Frost, James Oppenheim, Vachel Lindsay, Carl Sandburg, Edwin Arlington Robinson, Amy Lowell, Edgar Lee Masters, Arturo Giovannitti, Ezra Pound, John Hall Wheelock, Charles Erkskine Scott Wood, William Rose Benet, Alter Brody, Witter Bynner, Sara Teasdale, Zoë Akins, John Gould Fletcher, Conrad Aiken—everyone, in short, that is, apparently, at all worth while considering. Mr. Untermeyer has made the most painstaking effort to avoid any reproach from
posterity that, after all, he missed the great genius of today. The writers he treats are not merely still living; many of them have just begun to fly, mere callow fledglings, as I have suggested. Authors, moreover, whose first books appeared a few weeks or a few months ago receive from him a careful and judicious examination, and in the case of one poet he even predicts that his poems "will" cause no little stir when they appear, Mr. Untermeyer apparently having had the privilege of looking over these verses before publication.
Mr. Untermeyer leaves a deep impression that American poetry today, chiefly under the stimulation of Walt Whitman, the centenary of whose birth [May 31] has been eliciting other testimonies to his greatness and power, is marked by astounding fertility and variety. On every side poetry flourishes, some of it more than strange, some perhaps a little repellent, much of it beautiful, much of it virile, and all of it authentically American in that it is an indubitable product of our soil.
Among all this brood of poets it is not always possible, just yet, to distinguish those in whom Jewish readers may perhaps take a little more than usual interest, as being of Jewish extraction or as writing on Jewish themes. James Oppenheim is, without very much question, the foremost writer of Jewish blood in America today, and to him Mr. Untermeyer devotes much space, writing with a high degree of enthusiasm. Besides Oppenheim he discusses, as has been mentioned, Alter Brody, and there is mention, too, of Babette Deutsch (with no characterization), Hortense Flexner (whose "lyric delicacy" is spoken of), and some others whose names appear Jewish—Max Michelson, Irwin Edman, and one or two besides. In addition, there is a full account of Lola Ridge's striking poem, "The Ghetto."
In connection with Oppenheim Mr. Untermeyer makes some striking remarks on the Jew as artist.
The opposition to art for art's sake, he says, "comes with particular force from Oppenheim as a Jew. Few Jews have ever lived that did not regard themselves as the bringer of a message and their art but lacked the instrument to make it heard. The Jew's business, ever since the days of Abraham, has been religion, and the art that embodied it has been correspondingly social. They have come to consider themselves not only a peculiarly favored race that persists through (and even thrives on) prejudice and persecution, but, with a naive faith in their destiny, have taken it for granted that they were sent abroad to be teachers, pathfinders, light bringers. Even so lyric a poet as Heine wrote, 'Poetry to me has always been a divine plaything . . . And if you would honor me, lay a sword rather than a wreath upon my coffin—for I was a fearless soldier in the war for the liberation of mankind.' What is all the stupendous music of the Old Testament but a glorification not so much of God but of what is godlike in man? It is the sublimation that David sought; it is in the angry thunders of Jeremiah; it prompts the rich and sensual imagery of the Song of Songs; it impels the lashing questions and the majectic answers in the Book of Job.
“And it is the spirit of Job,” he continues, “that is in the blood of the Jews today. It is this blend of fiery dissatisfaction, sublime assurance, and deep ironism that keeps them what they were; that makes them doubt and disbelieve all things and believe somehow in everything.”
Again he explains the failure on the part of readers to understand some of Oppenheim's later work. "It was once more the contradictory Semitic strain that misled them," he maintains; "the queer blend of delight and disillusion; the quality that hates the world with its shams and double-dealing and still loves it exuberantly,—loves it almost because of its stupidities." This same quality Mr. Untermeyer finds in the verse of Alter Brody, of whose verse he says that "what racial significance the poems have is usually unconscious. And yet even in the poems that do not deal directly
