The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 6 · June 1919
68printed page
scan 29 of 40

The Maccabaean

deficit in power of psychological analysis and creative imagination. What good intent and tireless industry can do, he has done. His work, faut de mieux, ought to be on the book-shelf of’every American Zionist. It is a veritable cornucopia of correct information, apart from a few minor errata, such as, for instance, the mention of a Reichstag in 1851, and similar trifles. The typography is excellent, the binding handsome, but the illustrative material, in a prospective second edition, had better be overhauled. Some of the Portraits reproduced (especially those of Zangwill, Moses ess, Ferdinand Lassalle) are veritable caricatures, and all of the cuts are blurred in the imprint. The index is exceptionally well done, but the bibliography is far too short to be really serviceable to those especially interested in anyone of the multitudinous topics dealt with in the text.

J. F.

Congress and Zionism

The American War Congress and Zionism. Edited by REUBEN FINK, New York. Zionist Organization of America. Pp. 228.

WHAT may be described as the first "blue book" of Zionism is comprised in the volume, "The American War Congress and Zionism," a series of statements by members of the American Congress that terminated its existence last March as to their attitude on the movement to establish a Jewish national home in Palestine. Following the famous Balfour Declaration of November 2, 1917, confirmatory statements were secured from President Wilson on August 31, 1918; from Serbia, on December 27, 1917; from France, on February 12, 1918; from Italy, on February 25, 1918; from Greece, on March 14, 1918; from Holland, from Siam, from China, from Japan —the statements being all conveniently reproduced here.

On June 11, 1918, a letter was addressed to every member of Congress, in which the endeavor was made to secure a statement of his attitude towards the Balfour Declaration, towards the idea of a Jewish national home in Palestine, and towards the proposition to introduce a friendly resolution in Congress. Sixty-one senators from 43 states and 239 representatives from forty-four states and territories, or a total of 300, responded to the letter.

It is an extraordinary fact that, of these 300 Congressmen (including incidentally one “Congresswoman”—Miss Jeanette Rankin), only two senators showed themselves a little dubious as to the economic possibilities of Palestine, without definitely opposing Zionism, and only one representative placed himself in opposition to the Balfour Declaration, although he kept, as he stated, his “mind still open.”

Some of the letters are of great intrinsic interest.

Thus Senator Thomas of Colorado writes: “I believe that the status of the Jewish people would be improved the world over and their rights more fully recognized, if, like people of other races, they enjoyed a fixed national territory, possessing the attributes of a modern government and recognized as a member of the family of nations. The representation which this condition would give through the exchange of envoys and ministers to other countries, and the consciousness of the collective citizenship of the race, endowed with the attributes of a nation, could, not be otherwise than beneficial and elevating to the humblest member of the race. Such a movement would do for the Jews what the rehabilitation of Greece has accomplished for the Greeks within the short space of a century.”

In the opinion of Senator Guion of Louisiana, "We have before us, in our every-day life, constant evidence of the many achievements of the Jewish race in every line of human endeavor, and it is not too much to expect that, with all of their forceful characteristics brought into play, re-established Israel will become a model nation."

June, 1919

Senator Lodge of Massachusetts, whom many other Congressman refer to, states that he feels that “the effort of the Jewish people to establish a national home in Palestine is nant anlv natnral hut in all wave tn ha dasıraed ”

44V MARY SALULGE, wuL 111 Giı way LV DU MUOSLNUNe The idea of a Jewish nation in Palestine stirs Senator Vardaman of Mississippi deeply. “I can imagine,” he says, “the Republic of Palestine as being a lamp set upon a hill to guide and encourage the nations of the earth that are now struggling for independence. In spite of the prejudices, hatred, and persecution which the Jews as a race have suffered in all ages, that race has been a positive help and benefit to the peoples and governments that persecuted them. The Jews as a people are wise, conservative, patriotic, and provident. I am, therefore, in most hearty accord with the sentiment expressed by Mr. Balfour, and I trust that the Zionist movement may effectuate in the gratification of the aspirations ıf the brave men and women who have conceived and are pushing forward this great enter- nriısel

ER On the great conflict which has arisen in the excitable minds of certain anti-Zionists, Senator Smoot of Utah speaks some wise words: “Let me say to you that I emphasize this not only as a good American but also as a good Christian. I see every reason for the American Jews to give this movement their entire support. It is their duty as well as the duty of every good American. Aside from the international, economic, social, and religious aspect, I consider it very fascinating and inspiring. I should consider. it a pleasure to aid in my own way in the realization of the dream of the Jewish people for the last two thousand years.”

Representative Smith of Idaho regards the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine as “the most momentous event that has occurred since the beginning of the war. While the political effect is of the greatest significance to the world, this event, so unexpected, is attended with a religious significance of far-reaching results. The student of history must be blind who cannot recognize Divine interposition in the returning of God’s ancient people to the “promised land.’ The Ruler of the universe is demonstrating to the world that His word is something more than a ‘scrap of paper.’ ”

Representative Sabath holds strong opinions on certain points that have been raised in controversy. “All arguments to the contrary notwithstanding,” he maintains, “I believe that the re-establishment of Palestine as a home for the Jews will not only fail to prejudice the Jewish position, but in my opinion will help to dignify their station amongst all the peoples of the earth, and lend ennobling influence on the countless co-religionists who of necessity must remain in a good many countries, where they live under less advantageous conditions than we of America or England. I believe that in the realization of this venture, the Jewish nation will recover a position that has been denied it throughout centuries of oppression and captivity. . . - Thus will the'wondrous race that survived all methods of persecution throughout the weary centuries again emanate warmth of charity and light of justice for the guidance of all the world.”

"This cause for the establishment of a Jewish state in Palestine," states Representative Beakes of Michigan, "ought to be pleasing to Americans."

“Being full of my four weeks’ experience with the American forces at the front,” writes Representative Schall of Minnesota, “where I met with hundreds and hundreds of Jews, and realized the tremendous enthusiasm with which they are throughout the American line fighting the world’s battle, I am in proper tune to harmonize with the international anthem welling up in praise of this long-delayed justice.”

As another contribution to the controversy on Americanism the opinion of Representative Smith of New York

One Sixty-seven