The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 6 · June 1919
67printed page
scan 28 of 40
Facsimile · scan 28 of 40
Scan of p. 67
Text · transcribed from the scan

Books-New and Old

A Chronicle of Our Own People

A History of the Jews in Modern Times. By Max Raısın, B.A., LL.D. Ilustrated. New York. Hehbrew Puhlishinso Co. Pn. 466.

\ 7 HOSOEVER sets himself the task of gathering into one sheaf the annals of the Jews, from the days of our great-grandfathers to ours, may fail egregiously in creating a history, but he can scarcely fail in producing an interesting volume, if only he brings ordinary diligenee and a modicum of honest enthusiasm to his task. Dr. Raisin’s endowments as an annalist exceed these rudimentary prerequisites. He is known to the community, and appears in his book, as an able journalist, an eloquent Zionist and equipped with more than ordinary industry in the gathering and sifting of facts. His work is a fairly comprehensive fascicle of the Chronicles of the Jews from French Revolutionary Days to ours. The author informs us that it is intended as a companion volume to a projected translation of Graetz’s “Volksthuemliche Geschichte der Juden.” As such, it will do good service in bringing Graetz up to date, until both Graetz and it are superseded by a really modern and critical history of the Eternal people. Farther than this, a candid commendation of Dr. Raisin’s effort cannot go. His volume is a history only in the sense wherein the works of Froissart and Phillip de Comines were histories—in other words, it is in the main a chronicle of events and a roster of notabilities rather than a Novum Organon based upon any set of critical principles. Not to misrepresent the book, let me hasten to add that it is a chronicle of movements as well as of men and events. But the movements dealt with are not illumined by any explanatory principles brought to bear upon their analysis. Dr. Raisin does not analyze—he records like a fairly competent compiler and comments like a skillful journalist, but he does not explain and illumine an epoch and its main features like a creative historian. For such an ambitious undertaking he lacks, as will be presently shown, both the mental equipment and the necessary knowledge of economics, sociology and other realistic disciplines as applied to the explanation of historical phenomena. A few instances, briefly adduced, will render plain his limitations:

The struggle between Reformism and Orthodoxy, Anti-semitism in all its phases, and Zionism as an effective movement are inevitably taking up the major part of the space at the author’s disposal. It is to be presumed that the first-named item must have occupied for years the thoughts of a reform-rabbi of national reputation like Dr. Raisin. Yet it seems that he has not the slightest suspicion of the social currents underneath this century-old contention. In the consciousness of the parties to the struggle between Reform and Orthodoxy, and in its outward manifestations, the contest is a purely theological one, dealing with the admitted or disputed permanency, divinely ordained, of ritual and religious prescript. As a transparent matter of fact, the whole dispute on the European continent and in America, though theological in form and subject matter, was at bottom a class-struggle between a minority of arrivistes newly admitted, on humiliating terms, to the fold of western civilization, and a vast Jewish proletariat of non-conformers, chiefly of Eastern habitat. (I

say advisedly “on the European continent and in America,” because in England, curiously enough, militant orthodoxy, for a long time, was the privilege of a proud and unyielding community of sephardim sufficiently well-to-do to scorn any social recognition among Gentiles made dependent upon religious compromise.) The entire contention is a wonderfully interesting tragi-comedy full of valuable lessons for those capable of being taught. Let us hope that its history will be written one day by a true historian, capable of that insight into human mass-motives whereof Dr. Raisin’s account shows few traces. He contents himself with a faithful and lively relation of surface-events and with such biographical scraps of information as he can manage to crowd into his scanty space.

The same lack of true historical insight manifests itself in Dr. Raisin’s treatment of Antisemitism. Take, for instance, an utterance like this: “In its vindictive malice, Antisemitism knows no distinction of time and space. In this Apion was one with Drumont, Tacitus, and Pobyedonostseff.” Such a huddling together of widely disparate phenomena won’t do in a serious history. Of the four, only Apion, in all probability, was a hired bravo of the pen. The Jew-hatred of Tacitus was simply the hatred of a Roman against the enemies-in-arms of his country and, therefore, at worst, a macula levis upon the fame of this lofty and heroic soul. The Antisemitism of Drumont— undoubtedly a genuine conviction—comes straight within the firing line of Dr. Kronawetter’s epigram about “the Socialism of the Idiot” (“Der Sozialismus des Dummen Kerls”). As for Pobyedonostseff, he and his Russian Court accomplices simply prove that a government may be below the poor ethical level of Antisemitism as well as above it. In his wholesale condemnation of Jews, as a socially noxious element, Drumont, a typically “Idiot-Socialist,” makes no exception in favor of rich and highly-cultured Jews as against poor and unenlightened ones. Per contra, Pobyedonostseff and his autocratic backers, whenever it suited their purpose, did not hesitate to pamper a few wealthy and influential Jews at the expense of the frightfully oppressed and persecuted rest of the nation. I have adduced this instance of indiscriminate “bunching” only to show what journalistic superficialities go here and there into the making of a useful volume, written by a diligent and conscientious recorder, whenever he attempts anything ultra vires.

The history of the origin of Zionism as a movement in the early nineties is the deeply moving story of the reconciliation between the emancipated Jewish West and the Ostjuden of its former scorn, brought about in the main by two factors: the recognized impossibility of frictionless assimilation in the West, and our racial misfortunes in the East. It is a wonderful and tragic story, intense and glowing with human interest. To this day it awaits the treatment of a great poet-historian—a searcher of the human heart. Such a writer, some future day, will draw tears and happy laughter from a Jewish generation living under better stars, by telling them the tale of a literary dandy of Vienna and Paris, who abandoned the salons of alien high-life to revivify, by the magic touch of genius, a moribund nation. It is here where Dr. Raisin’s good intent cannot cover a