The Maccabaean
The chairman was Louis Marshall who conducted the meeting with great tact and impartiality. The representatives of assimilation, the descendants of those “Sanhedrin,” Claude Montifiore, Bigar, Lucien Wolf, Cyrus Adler, Solomon Rheinach, did not even argue. They only pointed with fear to the danger of bringing forward the claim for national righis or the proclamation of a Jewish nation. It was a living demonstration of the “Bondage in Freedom” in which the powerful, the educated, the rich and fully emancipated Western Jews are sunk: civil equality but no recognition of Jewish nationality, just as the great-grandfathers of the “Sanhedrin” legislated about themselves in their smug obsequiousness, This is what they proposed. And they heard the voice of the Jewish people under the strange protection of the historic “Sonharlrin” nintırea
Sokolow spoke and Ussyshkin, and Dr. Thon, Dr. Reich, Schechter of Roumania, Motzkin, Bentwich, Barondess, Judge Mack and others. The rich and powerful brethren of the West were told what the popular mind is thinking and feeling. They were not asked for sympathy, they were being offered inner dignity and freedom. Jewish nationalism, not the Jewish synagogue is the life nerve of the Jewish people at the present time. The fear of the danger in which the Jews might be put by the claim for national rights was a fear without any moral justification, a fear which borders on crime. The' Jewish people throw off this ancient fear and stand on the sround of its history, its hope, its individuality.
The Reconstruction of the Near East
THE reconstruction of the Near East is engaging the space of a number of periodicals in America. Most of the articles published are not without a propagandistic axe to grind. The most objective of them appears to be one entitled “The New Map of Asia,” in the April “Review of Reviews,” by Major E. Alexander Powell, former American Vice-Consul-General in Syria. The forecasts, however, which this writer makes are very general, and the various allotments of territory which he makes to Greece, Italy, France and England will probably not all be validated by the Treaty with Turkey. Under the subheading, “The Hebrew State of Palestine,” Major Powell says:
Since Lord Robert Cecil, in his speech of December 2, 1917, solemnly declared Palestine for the Jews, it has been assumed that a portion of the ancient Kingdom of Judaea would be erected into an autonomous state, though under European or American protection, with Jerusalem as its capital. But just how much, or how little of Palestine will be allotted to the Jews, there is no telling. Though the modern subdivisions of Turkey do not afford a boundary by which Palestine can be separated exactly from the rest of Syria in the north, from the Desert of Sinai in the south, or the Arabian Desert in the east, Palestine may be said generally to denote the southern third of the province of Syria—a region about 140 miles long, from twenty-five to eighty miles in width, in area about one-sixth the size of England. It is very doubtful, however, if any Hebrew state which may be formed will include the whole of Palestine, for England has quite frankly announced that she intends to retain possession of the ports of Acre and Haifa, the latter being of great commercial importance because of the extensive harbor-works built by the Germans and because it is the terminus of a railway which, running through Samaria and crossing the Jordan, connects at Der’at with the Damascus-Medina system.
