Jewish Education and American Democracy
By DR. MAX RADIN
THE problems of Jewish education are first of all the problems that confront education everywhere—and particularly in America. They are in a sense new; that is, it is new that we are so profoundly conscious of being faced with problems. Former ages found difficulties and perplexities enough in these questions, but they were spared the doubts and confusion that beset us, for the simple reason that the goal or end of education was a simple and definite thing to them, and has ceased to be so to us.
Dass Fine ‘ Its indefiniteness is not due to a lack of discussion. The educational literature annually put out in the United States alone is stupendous in quantity, and most of it stupefying in content. And a great deal of it is concerned precisely with this matter: ihe goal or end of education. It is most generally phrased that the goal is life, or citizenship, or some such general and lofty aim, and the generality and loftiness of the aim seem to preclude all doubt that it is a proper and essential one.
Unfortunately noble and rotund phrases are as likely to harm as to help us in such discussions as these. Those who use them are prone to forget that, after all, life and citizenship are not processes comparable to—let us say—the manipulation of a linotype machine, the stages of which can be isolated and specially drilled for, reproduced in miniature and tested in detail. We do not speak of elementary and advanced living. It is highly desirable that there shall be good men and good citizens. But the process of transforming the young of the human species into men and citizens, goes on without any set system on our part, by the mere pouring in upon them of influences from the entire environment. It is idle to suppose that education could exercise a direction on more than a small part of these influences; and no educational system has succeeded which has not sharply limited its scope.
In primitive society the limitation is clearly understood. There are certain definite military and religious functions that a full-grown male must fulfil. Adeptness in these was painfully acquired by the society as a whole. The process of acquisition is shortened for each individual at each stage of the society's development by omitting the errors and experiments through which the society has passed, and thus enabling the individual to gain in a few years what took the whole community generations to obtain. These functions were, as a matter of fact, processes comparable to the manipulation of a machine. The stages could be isolated and drilled for, and that is precisely the form that the earliest education took.
Our own society contains a number of functions many times as numerous as the military and ritual preoccupations of our primitive forefathers. And education until recently consisted in a specialized drill in every one of these manifold functions. Because of their number, each one was inevitably small and petty, and the resulting education was a small and petty thing, when compared with that which the adolescent Bororo or Botocudo receives at the hands of the warriors of his clan. Education made good master-bakers and good professors of theology, and if they were of the proper stuff and subjected to the right influences, these master-bakers and professors might be, and often were, admirable citizens and men as well.
Now the sort of education that trains master-bakers and professors we cannot dispense with. As long as these functions exist those who seek to perform them must be trained to do so by methods that will not essentially differ from those in use some ten or twenty thousand years ago. But the more specialized the functions become, the more limited each one is, the thinner the sector of life each one occupies, the less important becomes the education that trains for it. the occupation for which we are designed is the manipulation of a single tool, or even the part of a tool, it does not take long to learn to do so, and education has by its very complication devoured itself. We have reached the stage where a man aims at becoming a highly skillful “polisher of round hrass Na. 49 nnts
For that reason, we seek a broader basis, a higher aim for the educative processes. We cannot make life as undifferentiated as it may have been for the Habiri that burst over the Jordan upon the flourishing cities of Canaan. And we cannot really train men in living as a whole. Yet, when we attempt to limit the elements we train for, we are in the grip of tendencies that seem to hurry us to that specialization which makes skillful polishers of No. 42 nuts.
The point is simply that the one thing which is common to the specialized function of the individual in his society and to his general function as a member of that society is his mind. Can education train the mind as such?
The question is not an easy one to answer. It was answered with a decided "Yes" by certain naive psychologists of the past, and it is being answered now with a decided "No" by certain equally naive psychological statisticians of the present. We are not called upon to answer it here. But one thing may be mentioned that has often been forgotten.
We are, and have been for many generations, a highly literate community. Ever since the Renaissance—indefinite as that term is—it has been recognized that over and above the functions which characterize and classify each person, there were other functions that dealt somewhat more generally with the human spirit, and consisted in practise of dealing with the commonest forms in which the work of the human spirit has been embodied—that is, in books. It was therefore in obedience to a sound instinct, if in pursuance of an educational theory, that Renaissance education was so markedly literary.
Until recently the Renaissance tradition was accepted unqualifiedliy. It was not challenged until the last generation, but those who challenge it today lose sight of the fact that we are still, just as was the case in the early Renaissance, a literate community, and that the only difference is that the spiritual heritage which the Renaissance confined to a small selected group, is claimed for all mankind.
Now, those who despise books, and the literary tradition in general, will do well to remember that the democracy in whose name they act is saturated with literature and smacks of folios, that every new symbol of the newest social movements is compacted of elements that have a long history of print and writing behind them, and, alas, almost surely an interminable history of print ahead of them. If, as we earnestly believe, democracy is the culmination of the spiritual heritage of the race, those will deal with it best who
