The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 5 · May 1919
9scan
of 34
Facsimile · scan 9 of 34
Scan of scan 9
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

Martin A. Meyer of San Francisco, who preceded him, had his audience with him in his impetuously eloquent presentation of the Zionist plea. The following day, report has it, Dr. Wise was given the opportunity to meet some of the brightest representatives of the community in parlor conference on questions of Zionism; by many it is claimed that a breach has been opened in the Anti-Zionist ramparts which will not be speedily repaired again. Dr. Wise also, complying with their invitation, addressed the students of the Hebrew Union College in the library, explaining, in frank and informal terms, the aspirations and working methods of the Free Synagog. While, in these words, he made no reference whatever to Zionism, there is little doubt but that his were felt to be the most stimulating suggestions that had been offered to them in the course of the convention.

The piece de resistance among the papers and addresses of the gathering, was Dr. Kohler's disquisition on the "Mission." From the scholarly point of view it was the Big Bertha of Anti-Zionism, an elaborate, laborious effort to prove from Jewish history and literature, with a huge apparatus of quotation, reinforced by modern Christian testimonial, that the real meaning of "ye shall be unto me a kingdom of priests and a holy nation" is, undoubtedly, something like this: "Ye shall be unto me a dispersion of missionaries and a holy denomination." I am travestying, of course; but it amounts to that, in the end.

Dr. Kohler started out, most promisingly, by dubbing our friend Dr. Kallen an atheist and our greatest living Jewish thinker, Achad Haam, an imitator of Nietzsche; the slender basis on which he builds these compliments consists, I presume, in a Menorah Journal statement of the former, three or four years ago, to the effect (I am quoting from memory) that he "was the follower of no existing religion"; and in the latter case, upon Achad Haam's designating Israel as the supernation and accounting for Israel's providential role by natural causes. One cannot rank very high the scholarly conscience that justifies the calling of hard names on insufficient grounds; one looks from that sort of furious obsession and rash inference for biased treatment.

Dr. Kohler has, in arguments of this kind, the formidable advantages of authoritative scholarship, international reputation and venerable age. Dr. Kohler, too, must be conceded not only the absolute sincerity of life-long deep conviction, but he wins admiration by the intense fervor with which he advances his theses, by his utter devotion and loyalty to the world of Jewish thought. Yet, even to one whose intimacy with Jewish literature cannot bear the remotest comparison with Dr. Kohler’s huge apparatus, it ought not to be difhicult to demolish the real force and application of the master’s reasoning. Intense temperaments like his run to a blind partisanship which, without any conscious dishonesty whatever, completely overlooks the other side; it is not the judiciously balanced statement of which such mentalities are in quest, but the striking confirmation of preconceived views.

A paper of this sort ought to be refuted, point for point, by some ‘professional scholar who will have studied it, and who can dissect it, at leisure; even had the opportunity been afforded to anyone from our side to discuss it at reasonable length, he would have been at an unconscionable disadvantage (apart from all considerations of comparative scholarship) in having to deal, extemporaneously, with a lengthy argument of much detail, which he had only, at the moment, been following by ear. The writer did attempt,

being requested by the students to address them, while they awaited Dr. Wise, to present such parts of his dissent as it seemed proper to place, in Dr. Kohler’s absence, before his students; but principally to show, as he had intended to explain at the convention, that Zionism by no means flouts the “Mission,” that, on the contrary, it sees it as the spiritual culmination of a righteous nation of a pattern commonwealth in which the elimination of all inequities and maladjustments shall enable the individual to rise to unimagined heights of spiritual living.

Yet these episodes, together with other incidents of discussion, are far from yielding an adequate idea of the role Zionism played at the convention. When it is recalled that the President's message had not one syllable of reference to such momentous happenings as the conquest of Palestine, Mr. Wilson's letter to Dr. Wise, the American Jewish Congress, the appearance of the Zionists before the Peace Council, as if these and other things had no meaning for American Jews or American Judaism, one beholds the Zionist skeleton at the Reform feast, the Banquo ghost whom they vainly pretend not to notice; when two prominent rabbis confess their conversion to Zionism, while the story goes of a young graduate who cynically declares that he doesn't know whether he is Zionist or Anti, not having as yet secured a pulpit, one begins to discern something like an approaching panic in the Anti-Zionist phalanx. Occasionally, admissions are heard that Zionism has had a rejuvenating influence; in the same breath in which Reform is contrasted with Zionism, as if the former were born out of a sense of power, while the latter arose out of the despendency of failure, in the same breath the unvitality and the impotence of Reform Judaism is bitterly deplored.

No attempt is made, in these hasty sketches, to touch upon more than just the Zionist aspects of the gathering. Were any one to endeavor to deal with the Convention as symptomatic of the status of Reform Judaism, one would have to attend to more than those inaptitudes, vacillations, timidies and unfairness in which uneasiness, on the one hand, and helpless fury, on the other, betrayed their sense of inevitable defeat. One would have to admit that there was a noticeable reduction of that unending succession of peddling reports from unnecessary and unbearably iterative committees which made previous conventions so incredibly tedious and futile; that a number of intensely earnest notes were sounded by younger men, such as Jonah B. Wise, Martin A. Meyer and Horace J. Wolf; the paper of Dr. Morgenstern, among many inaccuracies and shallow diagnoses, contained much that was distinctly helpful and arousing. The best men are painfully aware that Reform Judaism is unvital and has no hold, not only on the masses, but even on its own people; it is only the irredeemably commonplace mind. whose worship of externalities beholds religious triumph in fine buildings and prosperous budgets; the better men take alarm at the drift of indifference, at the disintegrating effects of passive assimilation, at the inroads of Christian Science, at the dejudaization of synagog and home. Some appreciate that Jewish religious agencies have not come out with flying colors from the searching tests of the war; others are aware that we are not spiritually ready to meet the higher demands of our returning boys; still others see that complicated and urgent social problems are pressing for radical remedies, that moral courage and high standards of civic manliness will be needed by the rabbinate, if it is to measure up to impervious exigencies.