The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 5 · May 1919
8scan
of 34

When Zionism and Reform Meet

SOME writer or other in a Jewish journal of Zionist tendency wondered, a year or so ago, how the Zionist Reform rabbis could remain within the Reform pale. If the Zionist Reform rabbi manages to figure as an oddity, in Zionist convention as well as in Reform Conference, he is certainly treated with an air of resentment, tempered with occasional good-natured railery, by his professional colleagues, where his Zionist co-workers may barely, now and then, wonder at his presence. Of course, in the Reform convention, he is a marked traitor against an article of creed, where, in the Zionist convention he is simply one out of a number of fanciful combinations. In Zionist paper and Zionist gathering he may, now and then, read or hear slurs cast upon the Reform movement, not serious criticism, just testy slurs; in the rabbinical convention he is treated to an incessant harping on the rasping Anti-Zionist string and subjected to every species of unfairness and discrimination on the part of a more or less unconsciously factious majority.

In the Central Conference of American Rabbis which met in Cincinnati, April 2-7, in honor of the centenary of Dr. Isaac M. Wise, there are, among some two hundred and seventy odd members, at least five avowed Zionists (I am not counting recent converts) who minister, each, to the largest congregation of one of the largest cities (New York, Philadelphia, Cleveland, San Francisco, New Orleans), besides some forty or fifty Zionists in charge of smaller congregations. (I do not mean to draw snobbish distinctions of pulpit or salary; among the latter are many highly able men.) Yet not one solitary Zionist was elected, last year, on the Executive Committee of seventeen men; nor was a single Zionist appointed on the important committee which is revising the prayer-book (a committee of eleven) : among the thirty committees of all kinds (1918-19) I find that just one, the last on the list, had a Zionist Chairman.

There are other similar coincidences of Anti-Zionist forgetfulness in these same quarters, showing that the progressive principle of minority representation has no place on the platform of “progressive” Judaism. A program is made up for the reverential observance of the centennial anniversary of the birth of a great teacher. One would imagine that care would be taken to make every reputable alumnus who comes from a distance for a pious family observance of that sort, at home with his schoolmates, co-alumni and co-workers. Instead of which a program is prepared which, on the very surface, forbodes one constant waving of the bloody Anti-Zionist shirt. Who would be so innocent as not to know that the “Mission of Judaism” is the bone of contention between Zionist and Anti-Zionist interpretations of Judaism? Who is so ignorant as not to be aware that the President of the Hebrew Union College is the dougbhtiest and most “entete” protagonist of that Reform dogma in its most offensively one-sided form? Theme and appointment, at such a time, might have been palliated by the fact that the paper had been promised and prepared, I am informed, a considerable time ago; but then the official formal discussion of the paper to which a most liberal allowance of time was granted, should have been assigned, not to another rabid Anti-Zionist, but, on the principle of hearing both sides, to some one who would have presented the other face

One Hundred Twelve

of the shield. As it was, the Anti-Zionist position was allowed two matadors, who consumed between them about an hour and a half, while, thereafter, any one who cared might have five minutes in which both to handle all the mass of Anti-Zionist bias and to set forth his own interpretation; it was a precious privilege of impossible condensation; a homeopathic offer from an unsportsmanlike adversary of which no one in his senses would have cared to avail himself.

It would lead too far to specify in what subtle way other papers, such as the “Program for Judaism in America,” “Dr. Wise as an American” invited the Anti-Zionists who were appointed to them, to indulge their vein for denunciation; suffice it to say that, with one or two exceptions, sermon, paper and sketch, even memorial eulogy in cemetery chapel, even an occasional invocation, were, all of them, fish that came to the Anti-Zionist net. As might have been expected, on the other hand, the three Zionists who delivered addresses of one kind or another never gave a thought to any temptation to drag in Zionism; it was noteworthy, too, that where other speakers paid grudging tributes to such externals as the Zionist publicity bureau, the son of the great organizer of Reform Judaism had the courage to denounce vigorously what he called the Ghetto of a stagnant Reform Judaism, as a far greater menace than any Ghetto, Zionism could ever lead to. Yet at least one of the Anti-Zionists of the milder variety was naive enough to claim that the Zionists disturbed the calm of the convention by “carrying a chip on their shoulder,”” meaning that they were looking for grievances; it is always the lamb that is troubling the wolf’s private drinking-pool.

The Zionists, of course, had their inning; but it had to be outside of the convention. A meeting had been arranged, at the beautiful Orchestra Hall, principally for Dr. Stephen S. Wise, under the chairmanship of Mr. S. Marcus Fechheimer. Despite inclement weather the attendance was excellent; it was gratifying, in a way, that the non-Zionist element seemed to predominate; the lay public, even in Cincinnati, where rabbinical Anti-Zionism is most truculent and intransient, where pulpit and journal and big business sound the most shrieking notes of Anti-Zionist alarm, even in that stronghold of non-possumus bourbonism as regards homeland, renaissance, Jewish Congress—the lay public still furnished numbers of open-minded people who have not yet renounced all hospitality to new ideas, who want to hear the other side. Which, by the way, reminds of a ludicrous plea which was innocently advanced by an unsophisticated Anti, when some one proposed that one Zionist, at any rate, might be given ten minutes in which to set forth his opposite view on the Mission of Judaism. Said the naive young partisan: We don’t want to hear the opposite side, we are familiar with that. We want to hear our own side, so as to gain weapons for our armory, or something to that effect. It sounds extremely practical and reasonable, once we assume that such a thing as a change of mind is among the congenital impossibilities.

The Orchestra Hall meeting, as far as one could judge, was a complete success. The Mayor was most flattering in his introduction of our always magnetic, always powerful Dr. Wise, whose strong address was followed with breathless attention and punctuated with rapturous applause. Dr.

May, 1919