The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 5 · May 1919
4scan
of 34

The Maccabaean

The reduction on the other hand was not in claims, but in the appreciation of the truth that the course of Jewish history and therefore the character of the Jewish claims were not so unique as to confound the world with an unprecedented idea. If, to quote only one instance of this kind, the Armenians could count their dead, in making out their case, numerically, the Jews assuredly had the right to count the potential as well as the actual Jewish population Palestine in forecasting their geographical and political needs. Better too for the future for which the whole effort is really being made, was the verdict of friend and opponent that we had put our case “moderately and modestly” than that in an arrogant expression of the “will-to-be” we had claimed so much as to be practically laughed out of court,

Equally important was it, so it seemed to those thinking of permanent achievement, that we should not claim justice from the world, in a spirit of barter. Let it therefore be set down in the record that in its practical application the Zionist idea never lost the quality of high idealism during all the straining days in Paris. On the contrary every revision of that which was said to the representatives of the Powers, and each revision of what it was desired the powers should say by way of answer—the form of recognition and the substance of the rights to be accorded to the Jews, moved always to a higher and better expression of the ideal, and if in the end the great world speaks to all the lesser nationalities in the thoughts of the prophets, the Zionists will have rendered that service to the world in seeking to serve their own cause. To have concluded that only the ideal is the practical is to have been thoroughly loyal to the whole inward process of age-long Jewish thought—and this conclusion will probably shine thru the declarations of the Peace Congress concerning the Jewish future confined to Palestine.

But the practical was at no moment lost sight of. The requests put forward were for an economic self-sustaining Palestine, and for the creation of conditions under which there could not only be a large Jewish settlement in Palestine in the remote future, but to make it possible for the Jews to enter the land in considerable numbers and develop it in the immediate future. The touchstone of the problem very often was this:

How many Jews are willing to settle in Palestine? How soon could they go? How soon will they go? And the answer had to be limited by the thought that no heedless mass immigration, using the term in the largest sense, would have other than dramatic value. The thinking out in legislative terms of a well-ordered and properly developed settlement to be completed soon enough to be entirely effective, and yet so conducted that there will take place a natural instead of an artificial development, was not the lightest task that was thrust upon those responsible for the drafting of the Zionist claims. Here, too, in the future, we shall have to balance between the wisdom of experience and the foresight or lack of it displayed in our estimates as to what can be done and the measure of response that can be readily obtained.

Let us put a bookmark right here and turn over a chapter or two.

The establishment of the Jewish Homeland is a process,

One Hundred Eight

not an end in itself; it is to lead in the creation of the Jewish Commonwealth in Palestine. The process and its limitations are the immediate issues that confront Jewry. The Zionists of America have defined the character of the process to be adopted. They dream of a “modern state, incarnation of all the great principles won by the travail of the ages.” This description applies assuredly to the Pittsburgh platform. Statehood is not yet, but the conditions to be created in Palestine require courage, determination, and above all selflessness. Jewry, all of it, is summoned to this great adventure which in a measure is to win back the past and at the same time project itself considerably into the future. Will Jewry respond? More practically and more locally, will the Zionists of America step forward in serried ranks and enter into the self-denying service of their own people—the Jewish people. It was this nractical anmestion that nroved nivotal in Paris.

The paper bridge which legend said must stretch between Galuth and Geulah has been made. Will we pass over it in orderly fashion—many of us? This is no fanciful question, no whimsy. The real big day is ahead of us—the day of the real beginning of things. The Jewish Homeland must begin with well ordered quickly reacting, willing accommodating life. Stone must be quarried; cement made— houses built; land must be cleared, irrigated, fertilizedl— planted; machinery must be imported, factories built and the hum of manufacture must be heard—so roughly men and women are provided with food, shelter, and clothing. It is a crude picture of settlement in process. And it is not a private individual task—but a national undertaking into which man or woman, expert, scientist, laborer and farmer must sink his personality and his means so that the totality of the effort can be successful. The greatest patriotism of which humanity is capable—daily sacrifice for the commonweal must be called out and it must prove uninter- mittently responsive if we are to reach out to that success— the commonwealth whereof we have so gladly dreamed.

The American Zionist slogan—men, money, discipline, must find new and positive expression. For on these three things depend the future. The men, and women to make the Homeland, and at first the pioneers must be regulated in accordance with their fitness for the positive tasks.ahead; the money by gift and in national investment on an unprecedented scale; and lastly the double dose of discipline— here in planning and preparation; “over there” in the full yielding of the individual to co-operative effort. This problem had to be thought of in Paris, and now we have to take the next step, and seriously think it out in all its detail in the United States. Not that the rest of the Zionist world is not as anxious as we are to plan and carry out the plans. The issue is a compelling one in Central and Eastern Europe. There the desire to go, and to risk everything in the going is the tragedy of modern history. But for the present the way is blocked for the hosts of willing emigrants from all lands East of the Rhine. The task of pioneering falls largely upon the Zionists of the American continent because they are blessed with freedom of movement, they can not only freely raise the capital sums needed but can amply protect their investments, and lastly but most important, they have in these lands of opportunity gained that experience of great enterprise which is the most valuable asset that we can bring to this undertaking.

May, 1919