Books New and Old
An Estimate of Jewish Influence
Jewish Contributions to Civilization: An Estimate. By JOSEPH JACOBS, Jewish Publ. Soc. of America, 1919. Pp. 334.
IT is not an easy matter to present an adequate account of this book by the late Dr. Jacobs. Those who, like the present reviewer, knew him and experienced his personal charm, will find it difficult to examine his posthumously published work, otherwise than with an affectionate partiality. Secondly, it is, as the introduction shows, an incomplete work, left unreviewed at the author's death. It does not quite fairly represent what he would like to have given to the world as the result of his long continued studies on this subject. It is none the less a notable book, putting together material difficult to find, and criticizing with vigor and success a number of commonly accepted dicta on the subject. It will not convert Herr Chamberlain to Mr. Belloc. But it is not likely to be primarily to Jews, he presents a clear and sober account of the part played by them in Western Christian Europe, between the establishment of Christianity and the present time.
Dr. Jacobs was in an unusually favorable position to discuss the points of contact between Jews and the non-Jewish world. He possessed great intellectual versatility and wide reading. He enjoyed the personal friendship of many non-Jewish intellectual leaders, particularly in England—a fact to which he refers at several points, with pardonable satisfaction. He was a loyal Jew and a fair-minded man. It would be hard to discover a better preparation for such a task as that of this volume.
And yet, it is impossible to say that he has been altogether successful. It may be that complete success in such‘ a task is not to be expected. No estimate of this kind can be other than a subjective one and, for that reason, will not commend itself to an investigator who starts with a different formula. It will be well, further, to remember the limitations consciously set himself by the writer. It is not really an account of Jewish contributions to civilization but ‘ merely to the phase of civilization that was developed in the last dozen centuries in Western Europe and its colonies. The Byzantine empire and the Moslem empires that succeeded it are only slightly referred to, and then from a distinctly occidental point of view. And of the other great civilizations of Asia there is almost no mention. Yet much of the most recent historical research has gone for nothing, if we have not learned that the civilization of Western Europe is only the possible manifestation of cultural activity, that other civilizations were developed in other sites, different indeed in concrete forms, but not as inferior as our school-books have tried to make us believe. In one at least of these developments, Jews played a part, only imperfectly estimated as yet, but thoroughly noteworthy.
Then again, the contributions which Dr. Jacobs has put together are of a curious kind. They give the impression of being produced by a sort of inadvertence. They are not the outgrowth of the Jewish soul dealing with Jewish matters and producing a cultural group-product. On the contrary, they are the results of the activity of individual Jews,
who have temporarily divested themselves of their Judaism and thrown their energies into the furtherance of group interests other than Jewish. Or else these contributions are the outgrowth of the methods used by medieval Christian communities to adjust themselves to the presence among them of an unassimilable group of Jews. As in the case of English law, it was not Jewish law as such that left its trace in the body of English jurisprudence but the laws concerning Jews, ley de Jwerye, that did so. That fact is thoroughly realized by Dr. Jacobs, though not specifically stated, and must be kent in mind in readıno hie hnnk.
Probably the most valuable portion of the little volume is Chapter VII, on the Jews and Capitalism, together with Chapter VII a, the excursus on Sombart (pp. 218-267). Dr. Jacobs makes the capital point that the Jews followed trade, that they did not lead it, that the institutions of the present capitalistic and financial system were in every case created without the least influence of Jews, and that the common statement that the worst manifestations of the capitalistic system are the natural outgrowth of its Jewish origin, is demonstrably false—that is, it would be demonstrable if those who made it were susceptible to argument. Dr. Jacobs leaves very little of the fantastic structure reared by Sombart. And he correctly points out that Sombart’s perversion of economic history—in which field he might be supposed to speak with some authority—makes it unnecessary to refute his absurd racial and historical theories on the subject. It is unfortunate that Dr. Jacob’s zeal has tempted him into an almost equally indefensible theory (p. 260) which makes the Jews Armenians from Ararat, or to lay stress on the fact that for the first five thousand years of Israelite national existence, before the Maccabaean (p. 190) there was no coined money. In the last period of national existence that preceded the Maccabees, i.e., before 586 B. C. E., coinage anywhere in the world had only just begun to spread from Lydia, where it seems to have been invented, to the immediately neighboring countries.
If Chapter VII is the strongest chapter in Dr. Jacobs’ book, it must be admitted that Chapter III is the weakest. Dr. Jacobs is at some pains to re-establish the contention he has often urged that the Jews in the countries of Western Europe had a definite legal status as members of the state in which they resided—that they were not in contemplation of law, aliens. He refers to Mr. Frank Schechter’s short essay in the Jewish Quarterly Review (N. S. iv, pp. 121-151) as an “ingenious essay” to prove the contrary. It is, however, his own views that constitute an ingenious and somewhat labored paradox. Surely it is not “a patent fact—that alienage is not a heritable quality” (p. 115). That is exactly what alienage always was and still is everywhere, except in those jurisdictions that, like the United States, have statu- torily declared the opposite. It may be absurd to call Moses of Oxford, who sold to Walter de Merton the site of Merton College, an alien, but it is regrettably true that Walter and his contemporaries so called their grantor. And when Dr. Jacobs tries to show that the special legislation that covered the Jews in England can be paralleled by special legislation applying to other groups (p. 117) he forgets certain marked differences. There was indeed a canon law for priests and