The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 5 · May 1919
24printed page
scan 19 of 34
Facsimile · scan 19 of 34
Scan of p. 24
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

remembered that the Temple service in ancient days was probably all music, that the Psalms were written as songs not recitations, and that the whole Hebrew Bible is set to music with a system as elaborate as the letters, and is always chanted, never merely read. If that music had been preserved in its ancient beauty it might have been as great a gift to the religious music of the world as the Bible to its religious literature.

The Jews are still a musical people because the Jewish genius is musical. All art is religious in its origin and essence, and the greatest art of all ages and nations has been religious art. But music goes deepest into the spirit. It is the direct expression of the cosmic order; it is the least intellectualized of the arts. Its very appreciation is a mystery.

Why, then, though the Jews are still musical, are they interpreters rather than creators? Most of the great composers have not been Jews; almost all the great performers are Jews.

And I thought of Palestine, and of the Jewish children there singing Hebrew folk songs on the hills and in the vineyards. I remembered what every traveler has told me, that in the new Jewish Palestine one hears singing, singing, all day long. In Palestine, I wondered, will the Jews create music? Then I thought of that fact true in all other fields of art, that the Jew today is a middleman and an interpreter but no great artist. The reason is clear. Great artists are never imitators, they draw from their "ancestral memory," from the well of their people. Only an undivided personality can create. But the Jew is everywhere a divided personality, never wholly Jewish, never wholly anything else.

That is equally true whether he be a member of the Ethical Culture Society or of the Orthodox Synagogue. Only in a free Palestine can the Jew again be freely himself, and only there can he create.

But not only in music is the Jew uncreative; in religion also. His musical genius is a religious genius. It takes a Jew—it takes Heifetz—rightly to play the Ave Maria. In his own Judaism, as it exists today, he finds the formulas of ancient mysticism, he finds Hebrew prayers of wonderful beauty that he can interpret in the terms of his own life. However, he needs new prayers, a modern expression of the mystic that underlies all faith. But he cannot find it. Mysticism is creative religion. Many a Jew seeks for creative religion in Christian Science or theosophy and interprets them in terms of his Jewish soul—even as Heifetz plays Ave Maria. There is no great modern mystic among the Jews. There is no modern Jewish literature to hold the seeker after truth. Our mystic faith is inchoate, personal. That is because today Judaism is uncreative. It cannot grow save in its own soil. It is an uprooted plant.

Mysticisms and mystics there have been even among the Jews in dispersion. The Kaballah grew in an unfree Palestine. But their growth has been unwholesome, diverted, a vision that turned into a bad dream.

The true Jewish mystics were Moses, Isaiah, Ezekiel, the authors of Daniel and the Psalms. That authentic vision is living today. The Presence hovers over the hill of Zion, waiting for those who shall be born with whole souls. As I listen to the music which I can hear by listening, above the discords welded into vast harmony I hear the overtones of that passion which is peace, the Jewish passion for God.

J U D E A

By BEN JOSEPHJewish Legionary in Palestine.

Judea, when first I saw thee,Thy Judean hills before me,Rearing stately in their gloryFrom their rich and fertile clay,Mounting, rolling ever onward,Winding as the path of lifeWhich beginning low and lonelyTo the summit finds its way.Then I saw where to the westwardCrimson touched the clouded sky,Which, becoming red and redder,Burned beyond the hills, on high.

There I stood, my soul enraptured, Brow in heat of fevered joy, For I saw the soul of heaven In the crimson flush on high, As it rose above the hilltops O'er Judea's wonder sky. Lo, it spoke to me of glory, Of the men who fought and bled, Brought to me the ancient story Of the heroes Judah led; And before me rose a vision, Not a scene of battle's gore, But the noble deeds ideal Wrought by those who came before.