The London Zionist Conference
By BERNARD A. ROSENBLATT
Delegate to the London Conference
THE London Zionist Conference (February 24-March 12, 1919) achieved but little of concrete value, but it will prove to be an important episode in Zionist activity, because of the opportunity that it offered for an examination of the Zionist leaders who have done great work in the past, and who will be important factors in the history of a Jewish Palestine. The Conference, as such, did very little—and in the nature of the case, could do almost nothing. It was an improvised meeting, without a definite program and even without a definite object. It was evident that the real reason for its convocation was a negative one—the avoidance of criticism on the part of the rank and file, that important political steps must not be taken without ascertaining the opinions of the various factions within the Zionist Movement. The opinions of the Conference, moreover, were of little consequence in the political work that was being done in London and Paris. It soon came to be regarded by the delegates as a minor place, beside the great political work that was being carried on in London and Paris.
In that situation, it was perhaps fortunate that the Conference had no definite set of rules of procedure, and “Every man did that which was good in his own eyes.” I was particularly impressed by the fact that most of the delegates who were not trained in English and American rules of procedure, were more anxious for the right of an expression of opinion, rather than for the right to have any particular resolution adopted. It is true that the Conference finally passed several important resolutions, notably: one on Jewish national rights; one on the Palestine Land Problem; and a third, on Jewish Colonization, in Palestine. These resolutions, however, were adopted, largely because they were pressing matters, which could not be disposed of in any other way.
I would like to lay stress on the acceptance of the land resolutions, because these represent a point of view on which the American delegation differed, in some respects, from the others. The Palestinian Delegation was split into two distinct factions: the Poale Zion, who presented a Socialist Program, with Land Nationalization as the first principle; and the representatives of the older Jewish colonists who supported a bourgeois policy, totally oblivious of the fact that revolutions had taken place in Russia, Austria, and Germany, and that there are strong labor movements in America and England. The Russian Delegation, fresh from the excess of Bolshevism, supported, generally, the bourgeois attitude of the Palestinian colenists. The English Zionists took no distinct attitude on social questions, and it seemed that they had been so engrossed in the important political work of Zionism during the last few years, that they were willing to let the other Zionist. organizations devote their attention to the social and ecor/omic problems within Zionism. The Zionists of neutral countries, generally, took the attitude that they wer& interested in the economic problem insofar as it was involved in a rapid Jewish colonization of Palestind” but that they were not inter-
ested in the social phases or implications of such policies. This difference in attitude can best be illustrated by the difference in point of view of the land question. On behalf of the American Delegation, I urged the acceptance of a resolution recommending the taxation of land values, to the end that all increases in land values since August 1, 1914, should become the property of the Palestinian Government. The other delegations, however, with the exception of the Poale Zion, were interested only in securing cheap land for Jewish colonization purposes, and, therefore, supported a resolution that all lands, above a certain maximum (of the large land owners of Palestine) should be appropriated by the Jewish Governing Body in Palestine, at the pre-war prices. In the end, we “compromised” by accepting both propositions, so that while the Conference actually adopted only the policy of compulsory purchase from the large land owners, we also inserted the principle of land taxation, in the mandate prepared in Paris.
. EEE NEE Eine The Conference, likewise, adopted a resolution that land once acquired for Jewish purposes shall never be alienated, sd that we have prepared the ground for an effective program of land nationalization. In short, with the valuable help of the Poale Zion of Palestine, the American Zionists will have to carry the burden of a radical policy that shall make Palestine more than a mere copy of the usual bourgeois State—that shall transform Eretz Yisroel into a modern commonwealth for the gradual evolution of a nation bent upon social justice.e We must frankly face the opposition of those who would leave the solution of all social problems to the Jews of Palestine—because that would almost certainly result in a disastrous struggle between the Poale Zion and the older colonists. Furthermore, those of us who expect to become residents of Palestine certainly have the right to help in shaping the social conditions under which we shall live. And above all, the Jewish Commonwealth in Palestine is the achievement of all Jewry—and all of us, no matter where we may live, have the right not only to contribute funds toward the redemption of Zion, but also to contribute ideas and ideals.. That does not mean that we are to make of Palestine an experiment station for every crank reformer; but it must mean that we shall endeavor to apply to Palestine those social measures that recommend themselves to us on “the path of social justice.”
Finally, the Zionist Conference was important for introducing American Zionism into Europe. Our card of introduction was the Pittsburgh Platform. We are the recognized social force in Zionism to-day. And I firmly believe that our supreme task in the future will be to mediate between the Poale Zion and the older Palestinian colonists, to the end that our Jewish Commonwealth may prove to be both progressive, and in line with the Jewish tradition of growth and development—and in opposition to any mere destructive radicalism. The Zionists of Europe and Palestine will look to us to furnish, in a large measure, the administrative ability that shall work out this problem of “Progress with Sanity.”
