The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 5 · May 1919
15scan
of 34

The Future of Jewish Industry in Palestine

By I. WILBUSCHEWITCH, Palestine

THE industrial development of Palestine depends mainly on a satisfactory solution of the labor problem. The prevalent idea in the country is that the Jewish workman is not in a position to compete with the native laborer, because the latter can work long hours for a low wage. There is some truth in this view, but at the present moment the Jewish laborer, who is physically not very strong, but has a great capacity for mental development, has not yet had an opportunity of making full use of the powers latent in him, because of the primitive appliances used in the country, which precluded him from utilizing his energies to advantage in competition with the native laborer.

It is a well-known fact that the work of a highly developed laborer, provided he is supplied with modern machinery, is much cheaper and better in the long run, for two reasons. First, he grasps more quickly modern methods of work; and secondly, he has a greater sense of responsibility. The United States, where the worker’s wage was before the war 4.5 times that of the worker in Russia and Palestine, while the necessities of life were cheaper than in Palestine, will serve as a good illustration for our purpose.

RER AN U DEE Re Ba a a GE a A a a > ra ah en ‘ We could bring scores of instances, but it is quite clear that the intelligent Jewish laborer, given suitable conditions for his physical and mental life, can be highly productive and need not fear competition, in spite of the high wage he demands.

As a potential reservoir of labor for future industry in Palestine, we must take into account the pre-war Jewish emigration from Poland, Western Russia, and Galicia. According to statistics, etc., collected in 1910, the occupational distribution of the Jews in Central and Eastern Europe was as follows:—

Agriculture37373
Industry555229
Transport520938
(private).125750
Professions175109
Occupations116338

From these figures we infer that over a third of the Jews in Russia, and over a quarter of the Jews in Austria, especially in Galicia, are engaged in industry. From other more detailed statistics it can be proved that 50 per cent of the Jewish population in Russia may be regarded as a productive element, taking an active part in all the industries of the land. From this reservoir we can surely draw sufficient labor for an industrial colonization in Palestine. This conviction will be reinforced by a consideration of Jewish characteristics in relation to adaptability to industrial labor, based on experience gathered from contact with a large number of laborers in Russia and Palestine.

The Russian Jewish workman is, generally speaking, of an individualistic character, and cares more for his future than for his present. His ultimate craving is for independence, and he performs his duty with diligence and assiduity, provided that he finds suflcient interest in the work to make his efforts seem worth while. If he is a day worker, and in addition sees no use in the work he is compelled to do by the struggle for life, then he will readily have recourse to the world of ideas and illusions to satisfy his hunger for something interesting. The pursuit of ideas and ideals is inborn in the Jew. The economic demands of the Jewish workman are high, and only in exceptional circumstances can he be satisfied with a low wage. In intellect and power of observation he is easily the equal of the Western laborer. He can probably compete with the Western worker also in understanding and capacity to learn a new trade; but in punctuality and patience he is inferior. He tries always to make his job easier, and yet to get out of it the maximum profit, and he is probably not sufficiently developed to become, a specialized worker. In Palestine he has learned the building trade from the Arab, but has not yet attained to the Arab’s standard of proficiencey. In Russia his position is practically no better; the gates of the great factories have been closed to the Jewish laborer, and he has had to acquire his knowledge in the small Jewish shops, where the most primitive appliances are used, and where he can learn to produce cheap but bad articles. And where he has the slightest opportunity to acquire independence he will hasten to set up a shop of his own and proceed to work according to the method he has learned. As a proof of this we may take the statistics of the Jews in the pale of settlement engaged in industry and handiwork collected by the Jewish Colonization Association in 1898. They include the Jews of 26 districts in Poland and Western Russia. ‚These figures show the high proportion of masters, laborers, and apprentices:

I.43655
II.84915
III.40522
IV.25653
V.13296
VI.12203
VII.2764
VIII.19791
IX.10589
X.5998
Per cent52

These figures show that 52 per cent of the Jewish working masses are masters. This state of affairs has changed for the better during the last twenty years. The war, on the other hand, has greatly hindered the specialized worker. For almost five years there was no industrial life in the pale of settlement, particularly among the Jews. Most of the youths were taken into the army, had no possibility of continuing their vocations, and their previous apprenticeship was wasted.