The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 4 · April 1919
83printed page
scan 3 of 22

The Pope and Zionism

By MAX RADIN

IT will be readily recalled that, when the Balfour declaration was issued, the other nations associated with England acceded to the principles involved with a celerity that had all the marks of eager haste. It seemed almost as if they all feared to be anticipated in expressing their full concurrence with the project of a Jewish Palestine. The military situation may have helped. At that time the conquest of southern Palestine was the one notable and outstanding success of the Entente, and it was natural that any suggestion of England as to the ultimate destiny of Palestine should be granted immediate acceptance. Among others, the Pope in his much discussed interview with Mr. Sokolow stated that he viewed the plans of the Zionists with entire sympathy and was sure that in respect to the holy places, the Jews and the Church would be good neighbors.

Now, the Pope occupies a unique position in the western European world. He is the religious head of the largest group of organized Christians. His claim to a certain precedence among all Christian bishops is admitted even by Anglicans who admit no other claim of his. His own countrymen speak of him as "il capo del cristianismo," "the head of Christendom," and he himself a little more guardedly asserts a solicitude for the spiritual welfare of all baptized persons. Whether all these claims are fully acknowledged or not, the Pope in his spiritual capacity, has every right to demand from all men of every faith that respect with which right-thinking men view the religious institutions of their fellows.

But there are men living who recall that once the Pope was the actual political sovereign of a definite territorial state, and that further he has never acceded to the settlement that deprived him of that sovereignty. Indeed in strict technical law, he has never been completely deprived of it, since the Vatican and Lateran are minutely small units, quite detached from the political control of the Italian state. In consequence, the Pope may claim to have another interest in any political adjustments that will or may be made at Versailles. We must note, in addition, that the Church has always maintained that political man can never be completely dissociated from moral or spiritual man, and that the Pope’s position as head of a great international or supranational religious organization gives him an indubitable right to be heard in any extensive political adjustment that must affect the moral and spiritual interests of Catholies.

And, even from his “prison” in the Vatican, the Pope has found the means of making these grandiose pretensions really effective. If a good Catholic like Daniel O’Connell could announce that he took his faith from Rome but not his politics, many millions of other men made no such discriminations The Parnell incident, the Kultur-kampf in Germany and in France, showed at least two, and perhaps three notable victories for the Papal political position. “We will not go to Canossa,” said Bismarck haughtily; but that is precisely where the hard-jowled Junker did go, despite his big words and sweeping gesture. Throughout the eighties and nineties, no European statesman ventured to leave out of calculation the formidable political power centred at the dome of St. Peter.

But with the passing of Leo XIII and of Rampolla a change was immediately noticed. The marked intellectual limitations of Pius X, the almost incredible political incompetence of Merry del Val quickly destroyed the powerful edifice erected by their predecessors.. The Vatican found itself almost at once confronted with the second French struggle about the Congregations and where Rampolla had fought Ferry and Waddington to a truce, Pius and Merry del Val were completely and ignominiously routed, by Clemenceau, Combes and Briand. The Concordat was abolished and the Papal summons to the faithful to resist the godless aggressor was received with derision or with stıll more chillino indifference.

It must in all fairness be admitted that Pius had a very different group of antagonists from those of Leo. The temper of the people had changed from an uncertain republicanism, easily unbalanced by Boulanger incidents, into a determined radicalism. The Dreyfus affair had intervened. But it is none the less true that in the eleven years of the reign of Pius, the political prestige of the Vatican dwindled almost to nothing.

In personal character and mental attainments, there seems no doubt, Pope Benedict XV nobly maintains the best traditions of his great oflice. Whether he will rank with the great Popes is a matter that only the future can decide. But it will hardly be asserted by candid observers that he has given unmistakable evidences of that political sagacity which will always be one of the chief titles of Leo XIII to the recollection of posterity. Doubtless no man was ever confronted with a political situation so delicate and difficult as that which faced Pope Benedict almost immediately upon his accession. With both sides crying out that he who was not for them was against them, with millions of nominal Catholics on both sides of a hundred-mile-long battle-line, it may have been beyond human wisdom to maintain wholly the ofhicial neutrality that was certain to satisfy neither side and was passionately denounced by one side as worse than open hostility. Rightly or wrongly,—and authoritative sources say with emphasis that it wrongly so imputed,— the Vatican has been charged with pro-Germanism, and the charge of pro-Germanism is a taint that is not purged by official or even documentated denials.. And while there is no real evidence that the charge was true, Berlin and Vienna certainly had the appearance of a closer and more intimate relationship with the Vatican than their enemies, and the sympathies of the clerical press in Spain, — where alone they could speak freely,—were openly pro-German.

Whether or not the Vatican committed the unforgivable mistake of misjudging the outcome of the great conflict now over, it is undoubted that on the tremendous events of the last four years, it exercised no influence whatever. That was not for lack of attempting to do so. The notable Christmas proposal of a truce of God was rejected out of hand. The suggestion of negotiations ‚looking toward peace was barely dignified by a reply. If Pius left to his successor a prestige sadly shrunken, nothing has as yet been done to rehabilitate the Pope on the political councils of Europe. The American papal envoy, Archbishop Ceretti, spoke with regret and resentment of the fact that Pope Benedict had