The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 4 · April 1919
99printed page
scan 17 of 22

The Maccabaean

Calicoes and handkerchiefs, slippers, toys, and tins, Bedding, books, and cooking-pots, hats and chinaware, Music-sheets and jewelry, stockings, ties, and pins, "Ingrae far tha maidran’e tıhranat and han far bar he:2t

Push-carts, hand-carts, slowly trundling home, . Tell me who your captains are —captains, aye, and crews? Lively sons of Attica, swarthy sons of Rome, Syrians, Armenians, and heavy-bearded Jews.

Offspring of the mariners that sailed the purple fleets, Jostled by the reckless wheel and spattered by the mire, Hardy-souled adventurers, they cruise the city streets Seeking still their heritage, the heritage of Tyre!

A good book for a winter's evening at home is what Mr.Guiterman has provided. Let us hope for more studies likethe one quoted from his pen. MAX J. HERZBERG.

* * *

Isabel of Castile

TH is always great fascination even for the most cursory reader of history in the period of Isabel of Castile and Ferdinand of Aragon, King and Queen of the Spanish Nation. There is hardly a phase of study that does not lead into this period. [IREne L. PLunkET, New York & London. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. 1919. $1.90.1

The Catholic of today, while deploring the Inquisition, boasts of the loyalty of Isabel to the Church. The English child learns of the glories of Spain and the mightier glory of the England that a century later defeated the Armada. The Mohammedan revels in the splendor of the Moorish influence in Spain. The little American school boy connects Isabel with Columbus and with the discovery of his country. The Jew! To the Jew the days of Ferdinand and Isabel are a nightmare and a glory.

Volumes have been written about this period and volumes need yet to be written. One of the best tests of the value of any book that pretends to portray the days of Isabel lies in its treatment of the Jew.

Naturally, therefore, the reviewer first turned to the indexfor passages on—Jews:—Inquisition:—Columbus:—Luis deSantagael. Alas, the same fiction about Columbus persists.No reference to the Jews who made his voyage possible.

The author thus speaks of the Maranos, “Conversion affected neither their natural industry, nor their racial capacity for making money, the New Christians soon developed the wealth and power that have followed the foosteps of the Jew in all ages and countries, where he has been free to pursue them. From the collection of rents and taxes to the control of the King’s treasury, they invaded every corner of the financial and economic life of Spain, wringing from the carelessness of the Spaniard and their own foresight, the wealth that was one of the causes of their future ruin.”

After relating the horrors of the Inquisition she dismisses

it with this paragraph: “It is probable Ferdinand and Isabel realized their political folly in driving from their shores that most valuable of all national wealth, talent and industry. Fanaticism not policy had dictated their edict; and to their determination that one faith alone should be held within their dominions they were prepared to sacrifice even the economic welfare that they had next to heart. The Catholic falıh alnnae wac arknaulalral !:n Coactla

What is interesting in the book and extremely valuable for a young student is the characterization of Isabel herself. She is made neither the weak shadow of Ferdinand nor his master. She is made neither the instrument of the Church nor the power behind its throne.

EMI PUT MUATRENE IO OLILL VEN She is represented as having two distinct loves, the Monarchy and the Church. She set out to build up the reputation of the Monarchy on the broad lines of governmental reform maintaining for it the dignity and magnificence of royalty that aimed at the exhaltation of the Crown. As for the Church. she said “one neonle one faith

Pleasant as Miss Plunket's history is and well as it iswritten, she does not seem to have the broadness of visionnecessary to write true history. She has analyzed very wellthe problems that confronted Isabel and the contribution ofthis great Queen made to their solving, but she seems tohave completely missed the realization of some of the actualforces that were shaking Europe at the time the modernworld was about to be born.

In glancing through the appendix that lists the authorities for the life and times of Isabel of Castile there is no mention of any of the Jewish histories of the period. Surely these are important.

* * *

The Lost Ten Tribes

JEREMIAH and St. Patrick are one! About 585 B. C. E."a divine man landed at Ulster, having with him theKing's daughter, an ark, and many other wonderfulthings. The people of Ulster of Dan understood the oldadventurer."

This "old adventurer," according to Dr. Wild [A. A.Beauchamp, Boston, 1919. $1.60], was the prophetJeremiah, who later on becomes transformed intoSt. Patrick of Ireland. Jeremiah hid the ark of covenant,the Tables of the Law in Ireland and then instituted the nineark degrees of Masonry to keep in mind its hiding place.When the ark is found this peculiar ceremony will end, forthe ark has to be found and go before the Jews when theyreturn to their own land. Ulster is derived from the tribeof Dan. "It is the book's plea that Ulster should leadIreland away from the Church of Rome."

This book is one of the propaganda books against Catholicism and against England. It deserves notice only as it deserves to be thus classified. EMILY SOLIS-COHEN.

The Pope and Zionism (Continued from page 84)

selves Christian, and had been condemned as heretics by Pope or Council or both. The term used by the Pope,— if he used it,—may have no direct relation whatever with Zionism or Zionistic aspirations.

Who, then, might be meant? Can rumors have reached Rome of other attempts to organize religious enthusiasm with more solid interests? The Greeks (who might, it may be mentioned parenthetically, be inclined to dispute with the Pope the right of “patronage” over the Holy places),

have felt it necessary to make certain religious undertakings of America the subject of sharp political remonstrance. Can the Pope have wished to register similar objections to similar intrusions, in the veiled way reported from Rome? We do not know. But under all circumstances, it is plain that opposition in this quarter, if it really were to develop, is rather a. form of already noted and fully estimated antagonism, than a new danger to be met with new safeguards.