The Maccabaean
was only accredited correspondent with the British army in Egypt, representing all the London newspapers in that capacity, and accompanied the troops to the frontier and into Palestine. His account falls into two sections—"The Canal Campaign" and "In the Libyan Desert," and is made clearer by useful maps.
Mr. Massey tells us that he was prompted to write his book by a sentence in a letter that he received from a col‚league on the Western Front, a thinking man he assures us, who some months ago expressed the hope that the war in Egypt would soon be over, for then “the good boys out your way will be able to come to France to see what war is.” This statement, Mr. Massey feels, and his book goes ‚far to bear out his conviction, betrayed a lack of knowledge of the work of the British Army in Palestine, and from what he heard from other sources, he was inclined to believe that it echoed a general opinion. He maintains that the campaigns in Egypt were of deep importance and had a far-reaching effect. Among the results of’ the campaigns were the checking of some dangerous elements in the East and the prevention of possible defection of peoples and tribes. Since the completion of Mr. Massey’s book a whole series of events, of course, has taken place, with their conclusion in the debacle of the Turkish empire. To Jews at any rate the importance of his volume will not need to be enforced.
En EEE Mr. Massey tells how the troops first caught sight of Palestine, “rich and bright and beautiful, as good to think about as it was to see, and glorious to fight for. As these brave, clean-minded boys marched up to that ridge, battalion after battalion, on different days, they spontaneously burst into cheers. In front of them was a country worth fighting for. Their eyes told them that, and the last 2,000 years of its history was so engraven on their hearts that if they had only seen rock and sand before them they. would still have cheered. Here was the Promised Land on which the Maker had bounteously scattered His gifts, and this hallowed ground they were to deliver from the unclean, unhealthy rule which oppressed the people and was a clog in the wheel of cilivization. Even where the troops were it was a fair country, but beyond it appeared richer, the rolling downs, not unlike our Berkshire Downs in spring, were greener, the cornfields wider in area and brighter in color, and the flowers—words could not describe the delight they gave to the troops.”
* * *
My Mother and I
For some reason not altogether apparent, books telling how Jewish girls descending from Russian immigrants have fared in America seems especially popular. Within the past six months three such books, more or less in the style of Mary Antin’s well-known account, have been published. The latest of ihem, Elizabeth G. Stern’s “My Mother and I” (Macmillan, $1.00), with a foreword by Theodore Roosevelt, will make a mixed impression on Jewish readers. The book will appeal to them for its clever pictures of Jewish surroundings and customs, for the memories it will call up of quaint ceremonies.and quaint figures. But there is something-hard and materialistic in the book, and that aspect is likely to repel them. Mrs. Stern tells how gradually she managed to get rid of her Jewishness, to put it bluntly. Her growth in Americanism means merely a disgust with the ghetto and all its inhabitants. Her mother represents the ghetto spirit, and although she claims that it
Ninety-eight
was hard to break with her mother, she seems to have done so calmly enough. So far as one can gather, she puts forth a claim in this book for the admiration of all true Americans because she and her mother no longer have anything to do with each other. One is inclined to call hers a growth, not in Americanism, but towards snobbishness.
From the beginning of her adolescent life, Mrs. Stern tells us, her mother was “a buffer in our family life. I cannot think of mother except as one who always stood between us and some unhappiness, or father. It was she who made it her task to explain us to father, to soften him to our desires.” Her mother even “tried breathlessly, as it were, to catch up with us, with the new, and yet not to lose the old, to be American for us, and still not to leave her husband behind. She tried to speak English, broken sentences that ended in her cheerful little laugh, as she would admit defeat and relapse into comfortable jargon. She even struggled with the English alphabet.” This is the mother Mrs. Stern has not seen for vears. as she tells us.
To Mr. Roosevelt the narrative of how Mrs. Stern sloughed off her environment “is a really noteworthy story —-a profoundly touching story—of the Americanization of a young girl, who between babyhood and young womanhood leaps over a space which in all cultural and humanizing essentials is far more important than the distance painfully traversed by her forefathers during the preceding thousand years”—the italics are mine. One wonders just how carefully and painstakingly Mr. Roosevelt has investigated the past thousand years of Jewish culture that he speaks so confidently. One would never guess from his statement how profound Jewish influence, direct and indirect, has been on American institutions, or suppose that possibly there may perhaps still be something which Jews may contribute out of their past. To Mrs. Stern the process of Americanization implies a complete severence from the past, a complete transformation and metamorphosis. To most other observers Americanization seems rather a process of amalgamation, in which the best of all races and nations is mingled in this magnificent land of opportunity.
* * *
The Mirthful Lyre
Arthur Guiterman, that cleverest of American versifiers of today, displays the Ghetto in a flash of beauty in one of the poems in his entertaining new volume of verses, “The Mirthful Lyre” (Harper, $1.25). I will quote this poem in full, for it throws light on the lowly beginnings not only of Jews, but of other races:
PUSH-CARTS
Push-carts, hand-carts, heaped with ends and orts,Dodging under motor-truck, dray, and market van—They are pompous galleons that sail for stated ports,You are furtive caravels that trade where best you can.
They are mighty merchantmen that bowl before the breeze, Bound for humming harbor towns where bales are bought and sold; You’re the little pinnaces that rove uncharted seas, Bartering with savages for emeralds and gold.
Push-carts, hand-carts, lined along the curbs, Bargaining and chaffering, what have you to sell? Oranges and cabbages and aromatic herbs, Fennel, spinach, celery, and artichokes as well,
