The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 3 · March 1919
67printed page
scan 15 of 28

The Maccabaean

Mr. Kahn says: “The Jews of Palestine are a small minority of the population. Will the other people who live there consent to domination by this majority?”

“ Nobody intends to ask such consent. Palestine will be autonomous, with equal opportunity for all. The Jews believe their energy and aspirations and culture will give them the leadership. I have seen no request to the Powers for special favors to the Jewish population. I take it that if any other race wishes to found a university in any other language it will be free to do so, or in any other way to gain intellectual or political leadership. Numbers alone do not give the last word in a region like Palestine, where the component parts of the population are in such different states of development, but the Jews would certainly not try to force Jewish culture on other peoples, even if the whole matter were not under the supervision of the League of Nations. This is characteristic of the criticisms leveled at Zionism, in that it takes a purely imaginary view of the facts.

The objection that Mr. Kahn puts first is perhaps the one that has the easiest popular appeal. He says: . “It creates a divided allegiance, as between our country and .its Stars and Stripes and Zion with its white flag with the blue star. The Zionists, even in this country, are bent upon following their flag. The real American Jew knows but one flag, the Stars and Stripes. The American Jew sings “The Star‚Spangled Banner’ as his national anthem. The Zionist sings ‘The Hatikvah’ as his.” Now, as a matter of fact, the’citizenship of the Jews is constantly, although almost always un‘fairly, criticized today. Zionism promises to decreäse this eriticism, not to increase it. Who questions the Americanism of our friend Patrick because of his warm sentiment for Ireland? Was it wrong for Colonel Roosevelt to be proud of his Dutch blood? Is it wrong for me to be interested in my English tradition? Does Mr. Coudert’s French culture hurt his Americanism? No. Such backgrounds do not lessen patriotism. They enrich it. Between two Jews, one of whom takes no interest in the notable and exceptional qualities of his race, and the other of whom is alive with the beauties of Isaiah and with the vision of further services rendered to man by Jewish spiritual thought, do not tell me that the former will make a finer, more elevated, more contributive American than the latter. If three million idealists live in Palestine they will hold up a torch, needed in a world tending toward uniformity. They cannot possibly by the vision they portray tempt the American Jew away from devotion to the best in American civilization: the suggestion of such a danger is ridiculous enough to carry its refutation on its face.

Mr. Kahn’s remaining argument is that persecution, in

those countries where Jews are now persecuted, would be excused and increased by Zionism. In my opinion the exact opposite would happen. We hope to bring about a great spiritual broadening through the Covenant of the nations. Will the Americans want to throw out the Poles or the Chekhs because there are now to be a free Poland and a free Bohemia? Will these people be the worse for looking across the seas to a free homeland of their language and their peculiar culture? Why should the Jews alone be hurt by knowing that the country to which they trace their history is still there, aspiring and free?

Let me close with a word about the immediate method of securing and safeguarding this home of culture and of aspiration. I have been interested in Zionism for many years, but during the last four years my attention has been given particularly to the political aspect of it as affected by the world war, and during those four years I have been discussing it with influential Jews and non-Jews in different countries. It seems to me perfectly apparent that the safety of the Palestine State and its ability to develop in its own way depend on the creation of a successful League of Nations. It depends on the harmony of man. This is true of all small countries and indeed of all countries, great and small. If the countries are to put their energy into thinking about how they can protect themselves from onslaughts of force, they are not going to turn their principal energies to developing what is most beautiful and original in their intellectual and spiritual possibilities. If we have a League of Nations successful enough to remove this fear from mankind we may expect extremely interesting growths in art, literature, economics, religion, ethics, and political welfare in many different countries taking many different directions. In none of the new smaller States will this be more true than in Palestine. If Asia Minor is going to be a football of contending ambitions the ideal side of the Zionist movement is likely to be mostly swamped in complications that no one can foresee. If, however, the world proves equal to the task of introducing co-operation in place of fear and hate, then, under the protection of such co-operation, we may well hope for a renaissance of the human mind; with the vigor and variety implied in that word renaissance. Every Jew, therefore, who is a Jew in his idealism as well as in his race, should be one of the most intense workers for the success of the League. He ought not to be satisfied with a mere negative adherence. He ought to see that Jewish societies take an active part in the attempt to break down the factious opposition on the part of some members of the United States Senate. He ought to do his part to see that the outcome is one that will allow the highest hope for the noblest elements that have through the centuries marked his race.