The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 3 · March 1919
62printed page
scan 10 of 28

TWO HISTORIC DOCUMENTS

EXPLANATION OF THE VARIOUS GUARANTIES ADVOCATED

It will be observed that in none of these provisions is there any reference to any particular race, nationality, or creed. They are intended to apply, without discrimination, to all men and women who live within the State, so that the American ideal may prevail in the strictest sense of the term in Eastern Europe, where hitherto the idea of equality before the law has been unknown. We shall briefly refer to the most striking features of these provisions:

(1) Citizenship is not left to be defined by the new or enlarged States arbitrarily or capriciously. The Peace Conference is to define the term. The test is inhabitancy of the State. Owing to the disturbed conditions which have prevailed there during the past four years, it is to include such persons, together with their families, who subsequent to August 1, 1914, fled, removed or were expelled therefrom, and who within a specified period after the adoption of the treaty shall return thereto. It contains the proviso that such persons as have heretofore been subjects of other States who desire to retain their allegiance to such States or to assume allegiance to their successor States, may do so by a formal declaration to be made within a specified period. So far as Roumania is concerned this will protect the residents of Bessarabia and Transylvania, who, if they desire, may retain their allegiance to Russia or Austria-Hungary. In the case of Poland the residents of Galicia, Silesia and Prussia may retin their former allegiance.

(2) For a fixed period subsequent to the enactment of the treaty no law shall be enacted which shall restrict any former inhabitant of the new State from taking up his residence therein and thereby acquiring citizenship thereof. This is obviously just, the only question being as to what period of time should be specified.

(3) The third provision is a practical adoption of the time-honored principles of liberty and equality enshrined in the Constitution of the United States and the Amendments thereto. Attention should, however, be called to the fact that, in addition to providing for equality of civil, political and religious rights, it is also asked that national rights shall be guaranteed. This calls for an explanation. By "national rights" are meant those which may be accorded in the respective States to the several racial groups which compose the population. Nothing is further removed from our purpose than to countenance the establishment of an imperium in imperio, nor do the racial groups to which we refer entertain such an idea. It is to be borne in mind that we are dealing with Eastern European conditions, not those which prevail in the United States or in England, France and Italy, where the populations are practically homogeneous and where the term "national" has reference to a political, as distinguished from an ethnic, unit. For the sake of illustration let us instance Galicia. Among other of the "national groups" of that territory, using the phrase according to its meaning in Galicia, are Poles, Ruthenians and Jews. It is contended by some of these groups that they are entitled to certain rights, which may be called cultural or communal for want of a better term. It is their belief that the welfare of the State and the happiness of its people will be best promoted by the stimulation of the several racial cultures. It is not for us in the United States to determine the wisdom of that conception. It is one that has entered deeply into the consciousness of these several groups. If any of them is accorded national rights in the sense indicated, then every other group should be equally entitled to enjoy the same character of national rights. Hence were the Ruthenians, for instance, given such rights, then should the Jews desire similar rights they should have them.

Account must be taken of the newly formulated and intense desire of all of the various ethnic minorities in Eastern Europe to preserve their cultural identity. Lord Bryce has referred to that phenomenon. Pactically all of the new and enlarged States which are to be organized will possess a number of such minorities. In the new Poland one-third of the population will be composed of Jews, Ruthenians, Lithuanians, Letts and Russians. The same is true of Ukrainia, Lithuania and Roumania. Most of the Jews of these lands share with their fellow-countrymen the desire for cultural autonomy, and the most advanced statesmen in these lands sympathize with this feeling and favor the granting of these rights.

(4) The principle of minority representation is incorporated in the Constitutions of several of the States of the Union, and is to be found in the charters of many of our cities. In the new States to be formed in Eastern Europe the adoption of such a principle is important for the protection of the rights of minorities, which might otherwise be invaded by one of the preponderating groups, which, by reason of its strength, might be tempted to disregard the rights of what would otherwise be a voiceless minority.

(5) The remaining provisions are self-explanatory. They are called for by the conditions which prevail in Eastern Europe, where many nationalities are intermingled, where religion and life are interwoven and traditions are regarded as sacred, and where, as a natural consequence, the utmost care must be exercised lest there be an invasion of what the several parts of the population look upon as essential to their existence. Whilst we recognize the principle that it

Sixty-two
March, 1919