The Maccabaean
attained, where there is a group of a certain extent, that rightly or wrongly feels itself the bearer of a common culture, this national consciousness ought not to be destroyed or refused reasonable assistance in maintaining itself. Sometimes that may necessitate the creation of a new political unit. Sometimes means can be found of doing so, within existing political schemes. Mr. Zimmern thinks—so do the Zionists—that in the case of the Jews, the creation of a political entity, however safeguarded in its international relations, is a necessity. But the essential thing is the maintenance of the spirit. As he says again (p. 100), "Nationalism, thwarted, perverted, unsatisfied, is one of the festering sores of our time. But Nationalism—cherished—is a great uplifting and life-giving force, a bulwark alike against chauvinism and materialism."
The essential character of a national home for the specific case of the Jews, Mr. Zimmern takes as a matter of course. All Jews cannot live in Palestine, precisely as, he points out, all good Etonians cannot spend their lives at Eton. But as long as the fountain-head exists, they know where they may come to be refreshed. But the fountain-head must be one of living water, not a stagnant pool. Whatever be the particular politic organization of the Jewish polity —and Mr. Zimmern shows how indifferent that matter
is—the vital thing is that there be a polity, and that it be Jewish.
uUrmidiis The book was written during the war. There is, in consequence, a deal of polemizing against Germany and Prussian methods. It is a curious fact that these statements already seem to “date”—so quickly do events move in the epoch of soviets and Leagues of Nations. Much of what he says of German Kultur and the Prussian spirit are as true now as when written, but it seems so little worth saying, when the man of blood is a despised fugitive in Amerongen, and a German congress has elected a stolid saddler as the Dracilant nf ıha “Rairh ”
The war, in Mr. Zimmern’s opinion, has brought its peculiar temptations and its peculiar responsibilities. Mr. Zimmern, in whom there is a marked strain of devoutness, is not ashamed to pray for guidance in both. The peace that lay still distant when the book was written, has proven the validity of all that Mr. Zimmern has to say of Nationalism, and it brings into bold relief the fact that these temptations and responsibilities are much less those of the war as such, than of the new world into which the war has violently hurled humanity. There are men in several capitals of the old world and the new, who might with advantage imitate the honesty of purpose and the sobriety of spirit of this aggressive and eloquent volume.
The Jewish National Councils in Austria*
F all the nationalities which composed the defunct Austrian Empire, the Jews were the least prepared for the break-up of the Imperial fabric, for the simple reason that in them the consciousness of forming a distinct ethnic group was least fully developed. They had, as an Austrian Jewish soldier expressed it, “remained themselves colorless under the protecting title of a nationally colorless Austria.” It is true that the idea of regarding the Jews of any country as a separate national group first took root in Austria, and found energetic spokesmen in the Reichsrat; but on the whole it remained an exotic among ihe Jews of that country, and led to no national organization among them at all comparable to that of the Austrian Germans or the Czecho-Slovaks. The political crash has, however, given an enormous impetus to this tendency, and one of its first consequences has been the formation by the Zionist organizations of Jewish National Councils in the newly created German-Austrian and Czecho-Slovak commonwealths, with headquarters at Vienna and Prague respectively. These National Councils seem to be receiving enthusiastic support from the Jewish soldiers of the Austrian army, to judge by the reports of two meetings published in the Jüdische Rundschau of November 22d. One of these was held at Prague on November 2d and the other at Vienna on November 3d, i. e., shortly after the formal establishment of the new German-Austrian state, which took place on October 21st.
The meeting at Prague, though called together at a few hours' notice, was attended by 500 or 600 Jewish soldiers and officers. The chief speech was made by Captain Dr. Hugo Bergmann, author of the remark quoted above. He said that the first task of the Jews in Austria was to decide what attitude they were going to take up to meet the new political
situation. Jewish soldiers, he said, although they had not been able to check the profiteers, whom non-Jews, wrongfully regarded as representative of the Jewish people, were determined that in the future the Jewish people should be purified and organized on a democratic basis, and should be represented to the outside world by men who were in touch with the spirit of the age. The Jewish National Council of Bohemia, he said, was composed from the two democratic ‚Jewish parties of that country. Loud applause greeted his remark that the Council had done right in not seeking the approval of the Jewish notables, for there were no Jewish notables any more. The meeting was also addressed by Dr. Ludwig Singer, President of the National Council, who received an ovation, and of the ten speakers who took part in the debate every one adopted the Jewish nationalist standpoint.
The Vienna meeting was called together by the Jewish National Council of German-Austria, and was attended by thousands of Jewish soldiers and ofhicers, wearing blue and white cockades. The chair was taken by the well-known Jewish nationalist deputy, Robert Stricker. A resolution containing the following notable points was carried by an overwhelming majority: GENUG NE ee 9 SET En SE See en en A an ann nn a de a an er
"We Jewish soldiers of German-Austria greet the formation of the Jewish National Council. We recognize it as the only properly constituted representative body of all the Jews of German-Austria. . . .
"We Jews demand from the Peace Conference the fulfilment of the promise given to us by the Powers of the creation of a home for the Jewish people in Palestine secured by public law, and of the recognition of our National Council and the granting of national minority rights here in this country. We expect support of these just demands also from the freely elected representatives of German-Austria.
*Zionist Review (London).
