The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 2 · February 1919
40printed page
scan 12 of 24

Jew, Arab and ArmenianFrom the New Statesman (England)

We are Zionists—not only Zionists for ourselves, but also for the Arabs. and Armenians, as well. Zionism means faithfulness to one’s own country, to one’s own old home. Zionism means consciousness: of a’nation. . . . Is not the co-operation between the Arabs, and ourselves, the Jew, in the middle ages for civilisation and for true culture written in our hearts and deep-rooted in our consciences? ... In the principle of nationality lies the certainty of our justice. There lies also the certainty of our brotherhood with. the Arabs and the Armenians. We look most hopefully to the happy days when these three nations will create—in fact, they have already created in. the consciousness of. some of their leaders—an Entente Ye u Be le a an az SE En R

LUIWERMEND Adi LiIIV UUVUIILLIUD VI LI I1\DAL Zudsle Fr The foregoing passage, taken from a speech by M. Nahum Sokolow, the Russian Jew, who has been in England during the past four years as the head of the International Zionist Organization, delivered in the flush of the excitement that followed the Declaration of the British Government 'in favor of the Zionist cause, represents the Zionist attitude towards the two nations that it is hoped will be the neighbors of the future Jewish Palestine.e An Entenie cordiale is the Zionist solution of the problem of their mutual relationship. This policy of close co-operation with the Arab and Armenian nations was not elaborated on the spur of the moment amid the excitement aroused by the oflicial British espousal of the Zionist cause. It is the deliberate policy of the Zionist leaders, repeated and emphasized whenever the opportunity occurs, an expression of the belief that the Zionist, the Arab and the Armenian causes are in fact one. The three international questions to which these causes have given rise all relate to Turkey. They have all three been born of the Turkish system of government: they can be solved only by the destruction of that system, by its expulsion from the lands in which those three causes center. Palestine, the Arab lands, Armenia must all be freed before the Zionist, the Arab, and the Armenian, ideals can be realized. Mr. Sokolow’s definition of the relationship between the Zionist and the other two peoples was not invented for the occasion on which it was first uttered. It has been reiterated time and again, the most recently only a few weeks ago at a dinner given to Major Ormsby Gore, the political oflicer attached to the Zionist Commission in Palestine. “Zionism means the establishment of the Jewish National Home in the old land. But really there is more than one Palestine. There is one Palestine for the Jews. That is the home of the Jewish nation. But there is a Palestine for the Armenians; it is Armenia. There is a Palestine for -the Arabians; it is Arabia.”

The Zionist attitude is therefore quite clear. That of the Armenians is also simple. But that of the Arabs is more complicated, for there are two Arab questions vis-4-vis the Zionists. The one relates to the relations between the Jews in Palestine and the Arab Kingdom outside, in Arabia, in the Hedjaz, in Damascus. The other is the question of relationship between the Jew and Arab inside Palestine. Given. good will and statesmanship there should be no difieulty in arriving at a satisfactory agreement on a permanent basis between the future Jewish Commonwealth in Palestine and its neighbor, the Kingdom of the Hedjaz or by whatever name or names the Arab state or states bordering on Palestine may be known. The boundaries of Palestine are fairly well defined, although those who seera more eager for dissension than for agreement deny this. The Zionists have very definite ideas of what Palestine comprises. They make no exaggerated claims. They demand no debatable lands. They do not look forward for

Forty

Comment on Future Zionism

PRINCE EMIR FEISULISON,

room for expansion in some more or less remote period. On the other hand they wish to draw the boundaries in such a manner as to create no problem of a Palestine Irredenta. The Zionists want Palestine and nothing more. Arabia, the Hedjaz, Damascus are definitely outside of the boundaries of the Jewish Land. The Zionists welcome the prospect of the creation of a strong, well-ordered state comprising all these lands. Such a state would be their closest neighbor. And it is to their interest to have a neighbor who would have no justification for unfriendliness, between whom there could be no cause for grievance, no seeds of dispute. This is the Zionist point of view.

The Zionist pronouncement regarding its attitude towards the Arab state did not have to wait for a response. Within a few weeks of the British official pronouncement in favor of Zionism, a demonstration of thanks was held in London, and prominent among the speakers was a representative of the Arab people who as a mufti stood side by side with his Zionist friends in their expression of thanks to the British Government for having adopted as their own the cause of an Allied people. And Mr. Sokolow immediately responded with a reaffirmation of the solidarity of the Jewish and Arab interests:

We believe that the present hour of crisis and the opening of the large perspective for epoch-making developments offer a fruitful opportunity for a broad basis of permanent cordial relations between

February, 1919