The Maccabaean
lieved that a Jewish state would be created overnight by the fiat of any government. It was Herzl’s idea, as well as the thought of every succeeding Zionist administration, that the Jewish home in Palestine was something the Jewish people themselves would have to establish. What was asked of the governments of the world was a recognition of the Jewish right to Palestine and a free opportunity to develop the homeland.
That the affairs of Palestine were to be turned over to some Jewish organization other than the Zionist, is a thought which Dr. Weizmann may be pardoned in expressing, and it is a thought that has a great deal of support in Zionist circles; but obviously until such an organization is created, the responsibility remains the responsibility of the Zionist Organization, which is ceaselessly being called upon from day to day to meet all sorts of material and other obligations. We have not got the time, with events pressing close upon one another, to divert our attention to the tremendous task of forming a new universal Jewish organization, and there is no other organization that has shown the slightest willingness to aid the Zionists in meeting their obligations.
Any attempt to distort the facts in order to make black appear white, to give comfort to individuals or groups who lack knowledge of the rudiments of international law and of Zionist policy by mendaciously reiterating statements that have no basis in fact, should meet with universal condemnation. The Zionist task is heavy enough. Backbiting and lying reports on the part of persons who have not been known to make any sacrifices for Palestine, and who now come forward to interfere with the great work that confronts the Jewish people, are beneath criticism.
It is with no intention of belittling the Congress that the writer speaks of his disappointment. Four years had been spent in the education of the Jewish people in the democratic control of their own affairs. We have been speaking of the Congress as the Jewish Parliament. We were thinking of an assembly that would put in the shade every other Jewish assembly ever held. The three hundred elected delegates were to come to the Congress conscious of the fact that they were the first democratically elected representatives of the Jews of America, and the Congress was to reflect this elevated spirit.
It cannot be said that the Congress measured up to these expectations. It was not as deliberative as it should have been. There was too evident haste, as if the business had to be disposed of as quickly as possible. ‘The discussions were to a large extent superficial and not illuminating. The discussion on national rights, which resulted in an overwhelming vote in favor of national rights, lacked weight, because it was felt that the stupid arguments of two delegates had to be overcome by invective and the expenditure of elementary educational effort. Mr. Marshall’s resolution or bill of rights was not discussed at all, but was immediately put to a vote. Mr. Marshall’s address on the Polish situation was introduced to fill up a gap in the Congress proceedings; in fact, was out of order, and, thus, views that in all probability did not meet with general approval were passed by without comment. The incident of Dr.
Schitlowsky was an unfortunate breach of decorum, and the avalanche of speakers who consumed the whole of Monday evening was certainly not in place before the Congress had concluded its business. So, too, the resolution favoring a Universal Jewish Congress was badly prepared, and when subsequently introduced in revised form was so framed that it was felt that a discussion would be futile.
framed that it was felt that a discussion would be futile. The tone of a number of the addresses was not in keeping with parliamentary form. The opening session was a mass meeting with the usual addresses of welcome and replies, and there was a lack of consciousness that the Congress was indeed a Parliament, where the dignity of the assembly involved a definite method of discussion, procedure, etc. The delegates did not feel a sense of continuing responsibility, a responsibility to their constituency and a responsibility to the Congress itself. The difficulties of getting the delegates together and of holding them were indicative of this lack of individual interest.
In nothing was this shown more glaringly than in the abortive attempt to have the Congress elect an executive committee. The Congress as such was intended to be the spokesman of the Jews of America. Its resolutions were the laws that were to bind its officers, and no one could have a right to speak for the Congress except by direct enactment. And yet the insurgent movement at the Congress centered itself upon the proposal to elect an executive committee, which, if it had any power, would have to usurp it, for all authority in so far as the Congress had acted would be given to the Delegation going to Europe. In fact, the election of an executive committee would have destroyed the Congress, transforming the ideal into the usual organization that meets once a year and hands over full power to an executive committee.
Luckily, the delegates were soon convinced of the dangers of the proposal, and the plan was abandoned. A few delegates moved about the Congress hall until the last day, muttering, and threatening to bring in a resolution about the executive committee, and probably went away with the feeling that, because an executive committee had not been elected, a great wrong had been done to the Congress.
: The personnel of the delegation going to Europe amply reflects the various elements and parties represented in the Congress. Critics of the quality of the delegates indulge in the same arguments that are used by all Bourbons who are against representative government. In all probability there could not be gotten a better set of men to set forth the vari-colored American Jewry than those selected.
The delegation will go to 'Europe and return to report to the Congress. Upon them rests the responsibility for the future of the Congress. If they return with a report that involves support on the part of American Jewry of plans for clinching the political advantages gained at the Peace Conference, if they have recommendations to make bearing upon reconstruction or any other phases of Jewish life that needs the material or political co-operation of American Jewry, it will not be possible to prevent the establishment of the American Jewish Congress as a continuing power in Jewish life.
