The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 1 · January 1919
28scan
of 28
Facsimile · scan 28 of 28
Scan of scan 28
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

vicious circle of small circumference. We are plannıng for a few—not for ourselves, but for the other Jew—hence, we do not ask much of the world. Because we do not ask much, because our plans and ambitions are so humble and so limited, we wonder, how can Palestine suflice for the Jewish people? And also, how many would care to emigrate thither? Palestine can never be seriously regarded as offering a solution for the Jewish question as long as the inspiration for our Zionist policy proceeds from those, whether in the ranks or among our leaders, to whom it does not matter how small a Palestine we may get, nor whether we shall have sovereignty SL nn

siehe Fi I have already spoken here and elsewhere of the broadmindedness and generosity of British political conceptions in relation to the ‘Jewish question in Palestine. But how about the conception of certain of the British Jews? In the fervor of their patriotism, are they not apt to lose sight of the political interests of non-British Jews and try to jog the British government along a course not originally contemplated by it? We American Zionists are privileged t0 be citizens of the best country on earth—the United States of America; nevertheless, we are not seeking to compromise the Jewish political entity in Palestine by the introduction of a form of tutelage that the Jewish people must outgrow. It was not so very long ago that some German Jews tried to evince their German patriotism by sacrificing Jewish interests in Palestine in the interest of the German “drang nach Osten.” Surely the lesson of that little dispute in Palestine concerning the Hebrew Technicum will not so soon be forgotten by our brethren overseas. It was only a little minor prelude to that great symphony which might be called “The War For the Liberation of the World.”

One of the English “cultural Zionists” writes fervidly that a Jewish political state would be a calamity, because it might lead the Jewish people into the sinfulness of other independent states. Let us not pretend to such an excess of virtue. Let us rather confess that the ghetto-spirit is still strong within us, and the reality of self-determination in all its implications frightens us because it has remained nothing but an ideal these many, many years. But this is a time of trumpet-calls, and though we must needs tremble a little—because we are but flesh—we must claim our rightful place among the nations or be forever overlooked. We have nothing but a moral claim to Palestine.e But a moral claim—as th’: great war has proven—is not nothing. But, unless we make this moral claim, we shall have nothing. Moreover, what we do not now claim, we shall lose the right to claim hereafter by default.

I repeat, at this of all times, we must beware of ihe ghetto habit of mind; the habit of furtively seeking privilege without responsibility; meeting fortune while Iying down instead of standing up; dumbly accepting whatever may fall to our share. Our own leaders cannot serve us well unless we speak up. How then can we expect the alien world to interpret our wishes, save we rouse ourselves and become audible? Our needs are national. We must speak in the language of national requirement. This time the world is keyed to listen.

Let us stake our claims at the Peace Conference through Zionist of the Herzian

school only. Let us not be afraid to make our claims as inclusive as our needs. There is no place on earth where the Jewish nation can subsist as such save in Palestine. All other places —even if we desired them—are denied us. We have had two thousand years in which to relinquish our identity had we desired to do so or had the world been able to compel us to do so. We have therefore the right to demand the return of that Homeland of which the Jewish people was so bloodily despoiled.

447 MUOUVELVUNE But we neither think nor act nationally. If we did, we would not allow our philanthropists and political dilettants to continually foment large, wasteful, benevolent movements of international scope without reference to our national commitments nor regard to their points of conflict with or reduplication of Jewish national measures. We do not think nationally. Our collective mind is as detached as our body politic—some of it here, — some of-it in Russia, some in Weissnichtwo. The clearness and unity of vision which is of the essence of statesmanship is still wanting; or, if present, is not functioning. The simplest peasant of the most backward of nations, with his one insistence upon the essentials of life, can see more truly in this field that all the learned sophists that the most intellectual of peoples can muster. And yet, as I have said elsewhere, in the new era of inflamed national determinism which has been ushered into existence ihe Jew will be more homeless and exposed than ever, unless we are able to obtain concession in Palestine broad enough in extent and content, and inaugurate a national policy in dispersion adeauate to the whole Jewish problem.

Before the war we did a deal of pandering to the susceptibilities of the soft-footed Zionists of limited interest, and kept carefully combing out of our program all political. suggestion, as the price of their ever-questionable alleiancee. Are we to continue with this kind of statecraft at this time?

Before the war we had an international alignment as regards Palestine which presented obstacles to our national aims that were well-nigh insuperable. To begin with, there was Turkey herself, jealously watchful lest one tittle of her sovereignty in the land be undermined and, therefore, barring its settlement by any considerable number of Jews, and preventing the alienation of land upon a legal basis. It was this that urged the political Zionists to oppose the investment of national funds upon the hair-line security that was left us, and to insist that all energies be directed to the winning of national rights in the land. The question that now presents itself is, shall we assent to a program by which we must build for the aggrandizement of a polyglot population, the back-waslı of other lands, to whom Palestine does not mean national life as it does to the Jew?

Before the war we had Russia at the height of her imperialism offering the grim promise of Greek Orthodox claims. Under the Capitulations, all the other Powers magnified their pretensions. But the situation has quite changed. The Turkish and Russian Empires no longer stand in our way. The imperialism of all nations is on trial and can only be justified in those instances where the backwardness of local nopulations has made it possible for nature to stunt and overcome them. The great peoples of the world are actively

bent upon reconstituting the smaller nations upon a harmonious basis and are patently willing to spare no eflort to this end. They want no seductive litter of bloody bait lying around. The voice of the older chauvinism is not yet completely stilled and there are a few professional Christians skurrying around on missions all their own and not timed to this age. But the face of the world has changed. Nothing remains ihe same, except, perhaps, the ghetto outlook of those that have learned the lesson of the dispersion too well and have prospered in it after a fashion. All har Aacacııd

Will our delegates at the Peace Conference set our position before the world wholly, unflinchingly and like statesmen?

BBSBRUERERIRT mass ZU GEBE ULOESENESE The Jewish people do not want an international protectorate in Palestine. It wants a national home, not an international corridor nor a cock-pit. It is quite content with the original offer as made by Great Britain and would gladly invest the British Empire with the trusteeship of sovereignty in Palestine, confident that no obstacles will be placed in the way öf redeeming its Jewish character, and upon the definite understanding that the government of the country revert to the Jewish people just as soon as it is in a position to naecııma Jt

We not only ask for Palestine, but we ask the active co-operation of the nations, wherever necessary, in reconstituting ourselves in Palestine. This is not a demand of little moment. It is instinct with the feasibility and effectiveness of the whole solution. Thus, we ask of France such an accommodation of her Near East policy as will help in the solution of the tragic problem of a nation of fifteen millions of people. Of the Poles we ask that they stay their hands and not try to solve the Jewish question in their own grim fashion. They can and must be made to understand that there are other ways of solving the Jewi question and that the Jewish people are more than willing to work with them along lines that are consonant with the interests of both peoples. We must draw Rumania into the light and compel her to utterancee—whether she belongs to the dark ages or to this year of liberation. We must have the active good will of all nations and their co-operation, wherever possible, on the broad grounds of humanity and the debt which nations, of right, owe to one another. Without this co-operation—in the peculiar position in which the Tewislı people, through no fault of its own, finds itself among the nations—the Zionist movement is bound to be seriously retarded, if not stunted and crushed, by the tremendous handicaps under which it would have to labor. TrL._ 1L.-An. ılıa2 2 nr Is Haan Auen