The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 1 · January 1919
17printed page
scan 17 of 28

The Maccabaean

tial—we had to support the schools, to provide books, to set up a printing press.

RELIEF

“As regards the problem of relief and of the community in Jerusalem I would like to say a few words on Haluka. Please remember that the relief monies which came in were not Zionist monies, and that we were only trustees of funds which were given to us by Zionists and non-Zionists alike, and had no right whatsoever to employ those monies for Zionist purposes. Therefore we strictly kept it aside. Our Zionist Fund was the Preparation Fund, which was given to the Zionist Organisation, and which was employed for purposes which we consider Zionist, and for which we shall account to you. As to the question of relief, we had to follow the wishes and the will of the donors, and we were not free agents. Our purpose was to try and distribute the money as fairly and squarely as we could, and I think that in that respect we can answer before the Jewish population. I do not think we made the slightest difference between the Sephardim and the Ashkenazi. The best proof is that the Sephardim complained that we gave more to the Ashkenazi, and the Ashkenazi complained that we gave more to the Sephardim. But it is only right to say, that we were always conscious of the fact that we were still maintaining the old system of Haluka. We were conscious of the fact that we were maintaining this system in a somewhat better organised form, but we were still maintaining it; but we were powerless to change it, powerless to change it until we come to the Jewish public and say: “This is a system which we condemn. We offer you another system, and if you will empower us to carry out this other system, we shall be the first people to do it; but until this mandate is given to us we have no other choice but to continue the system which we condemn.’ We spent in Jerusalem alone monthly an amount of £10,000 to £12,000. Out of this money we could say that about half is money spent on simple, unorganised, unproductive charity; which I would classify as non-constructive building— as, to speak harshly perhaps, money wasted.

CONSTRUCTIVE RELIEF

“The other half was money spent on constructive relief work. That is a very rough estimate, and our endeavor was to shift this proportion as much as possible on to the side of constructive building; but that could only be done very carefully and very slowly, because you must not forget that the old men had to be fed because starvation was rampant in Jerusalem. The orphans had to be fed and had to be housed, and until you could organise in a more rational form one had to continue the old system. The establishment of rational forms of relief under military administration, where transport is difficult, and where the import of foodstuffs is very difficult, was not an easy matter. It is very easy to go to Jerusalem and make sweeping reforms, but they will not last more than a week. One has to tread slowly in Jerusalem, because it is an exceedingly complicated place.

EDUCATION

“One of the important items of relief in Jerusalem was the question of education—of traditional education, of religious education—I mean the support of the Yeshiboth and the Talmud Torah, which are non-Zionist centres. I have already dealt with Zionist schools. We spent on

January, 1919

these schools—we are spending on these schools in Jerusalem, including also Hebron, which is only a very small community, the amount of £3,700 per month, roughly about £50,000 a year, and we have practically satisfied the budget of the institutions as they were presented to us. We did it for three months because we felt, first of all, that it was not for us to starve all the complicated institutions of the public at the very beginning. People had to be fed first of all. They had to recover from the hard times they had lived through, and, before one could think of any reforms in these institutions, one had first of all to maintain them and try to strengthen them a little. But I cannot say in all conscience that we are satisfied that this amount of money is spent properly. We are not satisfied that the return from the schools stands in anything like a proper relation to the efforts spent. I wish you to follow me most attentively on this subject, because I consider the subject one of primary importance. All in Jerusalem, the whole organisation of the Jerusalem community hinges on this particular question; and, as long as this particular question is not settled it is almost impossible to speak of an organised Jewish community in Jerusalem, and we are in duty bound and in honour bound to pay very great attention to Jerusalem. Both my colleagues and myself devoted a very great deal of time and attention to this question. We discussed it with the various Jewish communities there, with the various Jewish institutions, with the various representatives of the Institutions, charitable and educational. We have tried to evolve some sort of system out of the chaos. I cannot honestly say that we have succeeded fully, but I think we have made an honest beginning. It is a very modest one, but it is made. It is only right to say that the Commission has not had enough capable of dealinge with a complex problem like this.

“The only persons capable of dealing with that problem are orthodox Jews, but liberal minded—and until Jerusalem has one central figure in the form of a worthy Rabbi, worthy of the post which he has got to occupy, things in Jerusalem and schools in Jerusalem will fare badly. We tried to cure the body of those schools, and God only knows it is a difficult enough task. As for the soul of the schools, it was very difficult for us to penetrate into it. My own impression is that amongst the material which formed the Jerusalem schools, about 343 were Yeshivoth, about 135 were what is called Bachurim, about 1,600 were Talmudism in Talmud Torahs; altogether about 2,034 people who took part in, who formed the whole educational system, besides the free Melamdim, Roshi Yeshivoth, and so on. There is—and I shall have to be pardoned for a somewhat harsh statement—there is about 25 per cent of this material which is without the slightest value; which ought to be cleared out of the schools as soon as possible, and ought not to fall as a burden on the heavy budget which I gave you. It may sound harsh, but we have tested the case very, very conscientiously. I have before made a report on this particular subject, and we were careful to prepare a report specially on the subject; because I know that when the War will be over there will be a considerable amount of complaints and knocks on the Zionist Commission, but we are quite prepared and armed to receive these complaints, and they will receive the proper answer.

“But in eliminating that you have not done everything; you have only done something negative. The only possible course which appears to me the only possible solution

Seventeen