The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 1 · January 1919
12printed page
scan 12 of 28
Facsimile · scan 12 of 28
Scan of p. 12
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

government. Indeed, in each of the two conspicuous examples of Commonwealths in American history—Massachusetts and Pennsylvania—a charter was issued by the King of Great Britain, whereby the rights and privileges of the population were safeguarded, just as in a written constitution. (It was only when the charter of Massachusetts was revoked that a royal governor was placed over the Bay State. Of the thirteen colonies in America, the crown colonies were never called Commonwealths, that name being applied, usually, to governments operating under charters and “Protectors.” So also in the case of the Commonwealth of Australia, the rights of the people are determined by the act of the Parliament of Great Britain, which established the Australian Commonwealth—which act may be construed as the fundamental law, the charter, or the constitution of Australia.

We may conclude, therefore, that a Commonwealth has at least two distinct characteristics:—

(1) It is a government in which the people, as a whole, in contradistinction to any single class or group, constitute the ultimate power in the state—a Democratic Republic.

(2) It embraces a system of fundamental laws or a constitution, sometimes called a charter, which protects all the people against any illegal acts of the constituted authorities and which safeguards the liberty of the individual citizen.

A "Protector" is, usually, the guardian of the charter of the Commonwealth. In the case of the English Commonwealth, Cromwell was the "Protector"; in the case of Pennsylvania, William Penn and his successors were the protectors; while in the case of the Commonwealth of Australia, the English Parliament is, necessarily, the "Protector."

In the resolution adopted by the American Jewish Congress, “trustee” is used in place of “Protector.” Now, in law, the word “trustee” has a fairly definite meaning. It is the designation of one who is holding something (which is not his own property) for someone, who gets the benefit of the property so held. Furthermore, a trusteeship lasts for a certain period of time—although it may not be measurable in a definite number of years—as for example, during the lifetime of the individual for whose benefit the trust is created, or until the time that the individual in question may be able to carry out a certain project. To apply these general principles in interpreting our concrete case, we may say that Great Britain is to become the trustee for the Jewish Commonwealth in Palestine, acting as the Trustee of the Commonwealth, until the beneficiary, the Jewish people in Palestine, may be able to receive the full benefits of the trust—until the “infant Republic” can stand on its own feet.

Furthermore, a trustee is responsible not only to the individual for whose benefit he is holding the property, but also to the courts of justice, or a court of arbitration, to whom he must account for the proper execution of the trust. In this case, "such League of Nations as may be formed" is the High Court of Justice and Arbitration to whom Great Britain will agree to render the account of her stewardship.

Some time ago, I pointed out the implications of such a trusteeship in the following words:

“The Balfour Declaration is not only an important political event, but also a fact of extraordinary economic and social significance. Great Britain practically undertakes to act as trustee of Palestine for the Jewish nation—to act

as its foster-parent—until our people are strong enough to make Palestine their own. For the British Declaration cannot be construed to signify that henceforth Israel is to wander in a happy fools’ paradise. The British Declaration is simply a splendid and unique opportunity, but it remains for the Jews of the world to utilize this opportunity.

“Great Britain might have declared its intentions simply to establish Palestine as a small buffer state under its protection, and in that event we might have had a free Palestine without a Jewish nation in Palestine, for the great majority of the inhabitants of the Holy Land to-day are non-Jews, who, by their mere numbers, would control the political structure and mould the character of the state. In view of that fact, England has taken an important forward step—she proposes to make Palestine not merely an insignificant buffer state, but a Homeland for the Jewish Nation.”

And even as a high-minded judge is loathe to appoint more than one trustee for the execution of a trust, since in numerous counsellors there is strife and dissension, even so the Jewish people ask for only one trustee to carry out the decree of justice, in the creation of the Jewish Commonwealth. Having found a “good and faithful servant”—a nation that has proven itself the greatest and best colonizer in history—it is altogether fitting and proper that the Jewish people should select Great Britain as the trustee for its precious inheritance—the Land of Israel. Excepting the Jews, the English are the most biblical of all the peoples of the earth, and fate itself decrees that the latter shall stand as the guardian over the heritage of the “People of the Book.”

The beneficiary of this high trust is the Jewish people, since it is specifically stated that a Jewish Commonwealth is to be established—not a mere Palestinian Commonwealth, nor a Commonwealth in Palestine. The latter would be open to misconstruction and misinterpretation; but a Jewish Commonwealth in Zion can mean only one thing, namely: that “with due regard to the rights of the existing inhabitants,” which, of course, all Zionists are desirous and anxious to safeguard, there shall be re-established in Palestine, the Jewish nation, as of old.

It is perhaps not out of place to mention that the first and second Hebrew states, from the days of Joshua until the destruction of Jerusalem under Titus, have been usually translated into English by the word “Commonwealth.” May we add that in accordance with the above definition of that word, the God of Israel was the “Protector” of the Commonwealth, and his covenant with the People of Israel was the Charter of the Commonwealth. Picking up the broken thread of our history, we shall re-establish the Commonwealth for the third time, still under the wings of the ancient “Protector,” but, also with the addition of the modern conception of a faithful trustee. This trustee is to be named in the holy covenant of the peoples of the world, when they establish the League of Nations—and this trustee, Great Britain, will deliver to us the title deed to the House of Israel.

The founder of modern Zionism dreamed of a charter which would establish, once and for all, the rights of the Jewish people to their land. Herzl had a vision of “a scrap of paper” which would transform the “Promised Land” into a Jewish Paradise. We shall behold the vision which was denied to our great leader. A Commonwealth implies a charter—and the charter will be granted by the nations of the world, so that the dream of Herzl shall be realized.