The Maccabaean
What is this intellectual standard to be? I should like to restrict myself to one point in regard to it. It must require a union of the virtues of Orient and Occident, of Hebraism and Hellenism. Consider, for example, the gulf between the Yeshibah of Volozhin and the University of Berlin. In Volozhin we find a devotion to learning which takes for its object the development of the moral life. Volozhin turns out Talmudists who unite to keen intelligence, fervent feeling, whole-souled- Jewishness, intense spirituality. In Berlin, on the other hand, we find a devotion to learning which takes for its object the development of the intellectual life. Berlin turns out scientists who unite to keen intelligence, precise order, careful system, accurate method. It is rare, however, to find men wha nite eniminalty and mothnad Where thara *e cnr.
Turkey in the War,
vicious system in which they found themselves so well placed.
It is not merely Talaat and Enver, but others too, Said Halim, Djavid Bey, Pallavicini and the egregious Liman von Sanders, that move before us in Mr. Morgenthau's spirited canvas. The depiction of these men is very well done indeed. Mr. Morgenthau is a man of affairs. It is consequently really an extraordinary achievement on his part to have put together a book that on its literary side shows qualities we should expect only from experienced and skilful writers. The value of such a book is enormously increased by a liberal use of photographs,—an advantage that older memoir writers did not always have. And as ambassadorial dignity is not inconsistent with sly humor, I have no doubt that the writer chuckled a little when he inserted the picture facing p. 73, which is entitled "Talaat and Enver at a Military Review," and which represents three befezzed Ottomans, in the left-hand corner, with their backs to the spectator.
Mr. Morgenthau is not abusive, nor does he rail. Talaat and Enver, by his showing, are human beings, although bad ones, and he lets us know that there are Turks of a different stripe. Indeed, we are by way of forgetting that a number of European observers—and not merely German ones—have found the Turkish character unqualifiedly attractive. The young French officer who wrote under the pseudonym of Claude Farrére (Mr. Schreiner calls him Fer- rar, and refers to his best b ok as L’homme qui assassinat! ) shortly before the war, wrote a panegyric of the Turks, in which he undertook to justify completely both the Bulgarian and the Armenian atrocities. This young man, to be sure, is a naive militarist, but it indicates that the Turk is less inhuman, than his rulers have sought to make him appear, when cultivated Frenchmen can so lose themselves in admiration for them. Did not an English scholar
D. S. BLONDHEIM.
A number of sources, literary and living, have been utilized in the preparation of the preceding sketch. It has profited further by a discussion of the subject before the Morais-Blumenthal Society of the Intercollegiate Zionist Association, held at the Jewish Theological Seminary, New York, November 25, 1918.
Continued from page 353
write a history of Turkish poetry in five large volumés? Perhaps the mass of Turks are as guiltless of Van and Harpoot, as the mass of Russians are of Kishineff. That does not seem altogether likely, but here, as everywhere, guilt is personal, and Mr. Morgenthau shows no disposition to forget it.
For that reason, it is all the more unfortunate that on several occasions he seems to use the religious designation of Mohammedan as though it were a term of race or nationality. And it is especially regrettable that he should give the support of a book, certain to be widely read, to a calumny that had its rise in the stress of religious wars and in the mutual ignorance of nations. "The Koran," says Mr. Morgenthau, "commands the slaughter of Christians" (p. 168). Now, the Koran does nothing of the kind. The statement is of a piece with what Christians quite generally believed was the Talmudic precept about the relation of Jews and Christians. In fact, the Koran indulges in fewer polemics against Christians than against Jews. And yet it is a well-known fact that, on the whole, Jews have fared rather better, physically, in Mohammedan countries than Christians have. But these careless repetitions of worn-out slanders are plainly dangerous when they come from a man of Mr. Morgenthau's standing.
Over a capitulated and humbled Turkey, there now rests a strained and expectant calm. Talaat and Enver and Jemal are gone the way of Abdul Hamid. Exactly what will be the disposition of all that was once the heritage of the Osmanli, we cannot as yet tell. But that the chief character of that disposition will be the confining of the Turk to the Anatolian uplands in which he is at home, seems established. There, if properly guided, he may develop the virtues of a free people, instead of the vices of a slave-overseer. Perhaps the next history of Ottoman poetry will be in ten volumes.